Geometry of color perception. Part 1: Structures and metrics of a homogeneous color space

Edoardo Provenzi · 2025

Read Geometry of color perception. Part 1: Structures and metrics of a homogeneous color space by Edoardo Provenzi (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-15478.txt.

Introduction

Edoardo Provenzi revisited in 2025 a classic result on the geometry of color perception. A 1974 theorem by Resnikoff says our perceived color space can carry only two possible curved geometries, once a few natural rules and a sameness condition hold. Provenzi restates that model in modern color science terms and gives a much simpler proof of the main result.

He then shows the favored geometry clashes with a known effect where colors sharpen against pale backgrounds. Experiments are needed to test one key assumption. The mismatch tells designers that current color distance formulas rest on shaky ground.

Catalog record

CREATOREdoardo Provenzi
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE60 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-15478

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Geometry of color perception. Part 1: Structures and metrics of a homogeneous color space Edoardo Provenzi Abstract This is the first half of a two-part paper dealing with the geometry of color perception. Here we analyze in detail the seminal 1974 work by H.L. Resnikoff, who showed that there are only two possible geometric structures and Riemannian metrics on the perceived color space 𝒫 {\cal P} compatible with the set of Schrödinger’s axioms completed with the hypothesis of homogeneity. We recast Resnikoff’s model into a more modern colorimetric setting, provide a much simpler proof of the main result of the original paper and motivate the need of psychophysical experiments to confute or confirm the linearity of background transformations, which act transitively on 𝒫 {\cal P} . Finally, we show that the Riemannian metrics singled out by Resnikoff through an axiom on invariance under background transformations are not compatibles with the crispening effect, thus motivating the need of further research about perceptual color metrics. 1 Introduction and state of the art This first half of a two-part paper provides a thorough review and a critical analysis of the pioneering work of H.L. Resnikoff on color perception developed within the papers [ 18 , 19 , 20 ] and the book [ 17 ] . These works are amongst the major inspirations for a modern program of re-foundation of colorimetry that will be discussed in the second part, in which it will be shown how to recast Resnikoff’s model in a quantum-like theory via the framework of Jordan algebras. Even if it may be surprising at first glance, Resnikoff belongs to a vast ensemble of mathematicians, physicists, biologists, philosophers and even poets fascinated by the concept of color. The list is impressive, ranging from Plato to Wittgenstein, passing through Aristotle, Descartes, Hook, Newton, Euler, Young, Helmholtz, Maxwell, Grassmann, Riemann, Goethe, Schopenhauer, Locke, Weber, Fechner, Dalton, Hering and, last but not least, Schrödinger, see e.g. [ 16 ] for a modern translation of Schrödinger’s work on color. In fact, it is the research about the mathematical analogies between optics and color, on one side, and the oscillating behavior of quantum particles, on the other, that led Schrödinger to propose the famous equation which bears his name in quantum mechanics [ 24 ] . As it will be recalled in section 2 , Schrödinger performed a synthesis of the most important findings about the mathematical theory of color perception in a coherent set of axioms, introducing one of his own. This can be thought as a psycho-physical counterpart of what Maxwell did for electromagnetism. The experiments of Wright and Guild, see e.g. [ 29 ] , could have paved the way for a further development in the mathematical understanding of color perception, however, the then recently founded Commission Intérnational de l’Éclairage (CIE), took a more practical path by building up geometrically flat color spaces which had the advantage to be easier to handle for engineering purposes. While the XYZ space still stands today as a handy color space for colorimetry, its developments until recent years, see e.g. [ 22 ] , lacked of mathematical rigor and introduced ad-hoc parameters to adapt newly discovered phenomena to the existing color space structures, instead of modifying their geometry to fit the new observations. Resnikoff’s papers and book, instead, put in question the flat geometry of the color space. They were written in the middle of the ’70s of the twentieth century, about the same period when researchers in relativistic quantum field theory developed the standard model of fundamental physical interactions and when some first attempts to fuse quantum mechanics and general relativity into a single theory have been proposed. This zeitgeist could explain the reason why Resnikoff decided to use techniques which are quite common in theoretical physics (as Riemannian geometry, homogeneous spaces, Lie groups and algebras) to study color perception. In this sense, his achievements could be considered a very elegant example of ‘theoretical psycho-physics’. In spite of its extreme originality and deepness, Resnikoff’s work remained practically unnoticed until today, probably due to the fact that the mathematical knowledge needed to understand the meaning of his findings is quite vast and does not belong to the typical mathematical background of scientists working on colorimetry. One of the aims of this paper is to rewrite Resnikoff’s results in more modern and pedagogical terms, thus making them accessible to a wider range of researchers in colorimetry, vision science and image processing. We will discuss in particular detail the homogeneity axiom for the space of perceived colors {\cal P} , which led Resnikoff to show that, if we accept the homogeneity hypothesis, {\cal P} can only be the canonical Helmoltz-Stiles space well-known to colorimetrists, or a completely new space of hyperbolic nature. We will provide an alternative and much simpler proof of this result, underlining also an error in the original demonstration proposed by Resnikoff in [ 18 ] . Differently from the standard colorimetric setting, Resnikoff established his theory in what we call today color in context , i.e. a color stimulus embedded in a uniform background. This aspect reveals to be crucial for the development of his theory, because the group of transformations acting transitively on {\cal P} are identified with background changes. However, we remark that a major issue remains open: background transformations must be linear to fit in Resnikoff’s theory, but no experimental data is available yet to confirm or confute this hypothesis. For this reason, we will discuss a psycho-physical experiment that can be used to verify the linearity of background transformations. Finally, we will show that the crispening effect contradicts Resnikoff’s hypothesis that background changes are isometries with respect to the perceptual color metric. Thus underlying the need of further research about perceptual color metrics. 2 Review of Schrödinger’s axioms for the space of perceived colors Schrödinger’s axioms for the space of perceived colors can be resumed with the following statement: the space of perceived colors is a regular convex cone embedded in a real vector space of dimension less or equal to 3 . The validity of this sentence, however, is bounded within the limits of the standard observational conditions of colorimetry , which, as we are going to discuss, are very restrictive and far from those of a natural visual scene. We start with the notation and nomenclature that we need for the rest of the paper. • \Lambda=[\lambda_{\text{min}},\lambda_{\text{max}}] denotes the visual spectrum , the extrema of \Lambda are left unspecified because their numerical values are not important and because there is no agreement about them. Typically, one chooses \lambda_{\text{min}}=380 nm (extreme violet) and \lambda_{\text{max}} =780nm (extreme red). • \textbf{x}:\Lambda\to\mbox{$\mathbb{R}$}^{+} : is the light function representing the electromagnetic radiation associated to the color stimulus , or physical light . A spectral color stimulus \textbf{x}_{\lambda_{0}}(\lambda) relative to the wavelength \lambda_{0} is a narrow-band visible radiation, generally modeled by a Gaussian centered in \lambda_{0} and with a small standard deviation (typically of the order of 1nm), or a piece-wise constant function everywhere null in \Lambda apart from a small interval of wavelengths containing \lambda_{0} . • Since light stimuli have finite energy, i.e. \int_{\Lambda}\textbf{x}(\lambda)^{2}\,d\lambda<+\infty , a physical light can be considered as an

Read the complete text