Traversing the Star-Forming Main Sequence with Molecular Gas Stacks of z ∼ \sim 1.6 Cluster Galaxies

Alex Pigarelli, Allison Noble, Gregory Rudnick, William Cramer, Stacey Alberts, Yannick Bahe, Patrick S. Kamieneski, Sebastian Montaño, Adam Muzzin, Julie Nantais, Sarah Saavedra, Eelco van Kampen, Tracy Webb, Christina C. Williams, Gillian Wilson, H. K. C. Yee · 2025

Read Traversing the Star-Forming Main Sequence with Molecular Gas Stacks of z ∼ \sim 1.6 Cluster Galaxies by Alex Pigarelli, Allison Noble, Gregory Rudnick, William Cramer, Stacey Alberts, Yannick Bahe, Patrick S. Kamieneski, Sebastian Montaño, Adam Muzzin, Julie Nantais, Sarah Saavedra, Eelco van Kampen, Tracy Webb, Christina C. Williams, Gillian Wilson, H. K. C. Yee (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-15381.txt.

Introduction

Alex Pigarelli and co-authors weigh cold gas in young cluster galaxies in this 2025 paper. Galaxy clusters can strip or feed the gas that fuels star birth, but faint members long escaped direct measure. The team stacked radio spectra of galaxies in a cluster seen as it was long ago.

Fifty-four galaxies were sorted into nine groups by mass and star birth rate. Eight groups gave clear gas signals. On average the cluster galaxies held gas much like field galaxies of like mass and rate. Below the main star-forming trend, though, cluster members split from field norms in both directions. The authors blame cluster forces, pending sharper field baselines.

Catalog record

CREATORAlex Pigarelli, Allison Noble, Gregory Rudnick, William Cramer, Stacey Alberts, Yannick Bahe, Patrick S. Kamieneski, Sebastian Montaño, Adam Muzzin, Julie Nantais, Sarah Saavedra, Eelco van Kampen, Tracy Webb, Christina C. Williams, Gillian Wilson, H. K. C. Yee
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE53 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-15381

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Traversing the Star-Forming Main Sequence with Molecular Gas Stacks of z ∼ \sim 1.6 Cluster Galaxies Alex Pigarelli, Allison Noble, Gregory Rudnick, William Cramer, Stacey Alberts, Yannick Bahe, Patrick S. Kamieneski, Sebastian Montaño, Adam Muzzin, Julie Nantais, Sarah Saavedra, Eelco van Kampen, Tracy Webb, Christina C. Williams, Gillian Wilson, H. K. C. Yee Abstract The cluster environment has been shown to affect the molecular gas content of cluster members, yet a complete understanding of this often subtle effect has been hindered due to a lack of detections over the full parameter space of galaxy star formation rates and stellar masses. Here we stack CO(2-1) spectra of z ∼ 1.6 z\sim 1.6 cluster galaxies to explore the average molecular gas fractions of galaxies both at lower mass (log( OPEN M ∗ / M ⊙ ) ∼ 9.6 M_{*}/M_{\odot})\sim 9.6 ) and further below the Star Forming Main Sequence (SFMS; Δ \Delta MS ∼ − 0.9 \sim-0.9 ) than other literature studies; this translates to a 3 ​ σ 3\sigma gas mass limit of ∼ 7 × 10 9 ​ M ⊙ \sim 7\times 10^{9}\,M_{\odot} for stacked galaxies below the SFMS. We divide our sample of 54 z ∼ 1.6 z\sim 1.6 cluster galaxies, derived from the Spitzer Adaptation of the Red-Sequence Cluster Survey, into 9 groupings, for which we recover detections in 8. The average gas content of the full cluster galaxy population is similar to coeval field galaxies matched in stellar mass and star formation rate. However, when further split by CO-undetected and CO-detected, we find that galaxies below the SFMS have statistically different gas fractions from the field scaling relations, spanning deficiencies to enhancements from 2 ​ σ 2\sigma below to 3 ​ σ 3\sigma above the expected field gas fractions, respectively. These differences between z = 1.6 z=1.6 cluster and field galaxies below the SFMS are likely due to environmental processes, though further investigation of spatially-resolved properties and more robust field scaling relation calibration in this parameter space are required. I Introduction It has been well-established in the literature that a galaxy’s environment has an impact on various galactic properties, including morphology [ 25 , 27 , 52 ] and star formation rate (SFR) [ 26 , 37 , 50 ] . In recent years, an abundance of molecular gas studies have also looked at the link between environment and its impact on the gas properties of galaxies. Molecular gas, the raw fuel of star formation, provides a unique perspective on galaxy evolution as it probes future star formation in galaxies and it has been shown to be affected by cluster environments. Historically, carbon monoxide (CO) has been used as a tracer of molecular gas in galaxies due to the difficulty of observing molecular hydrogen [ 59 , 12 ] . In particular, several high-resolution studies at low-redshift have investigated the molecular gas reservoirs in cluster galaxies: the Virgo Environment Traced in CO (VERTICO; Brown et al. 9 ), the ALMA Fornax Cluster Survey (AlFoCS; Zabel et al. 74 ), and the GAs Stripping Phenomena in galaxies survey (GASP; Poggianti et al. 51 ). These surveys explored the environmental effects on cluster galaxies, with all finding evidence of a significant population of cluster galaxies with debris trails (“jellyfish galaxies”), and/or disturbed morphologies and kinematics, most likely as a result of ram-pressure stripping (RPS; Zabel et al. 74 , Moretti et al. 39 , Zabel et al. 75 ). Aside from morphological changes to the molecular gas in galaxies, environmental effects have also been observed to alter a galaxy’s total gas content 1 1 1 Details of environmental quenching mechanisms can be found in [ 17 , 8 , 2 ] . Some quenching mechanisms strictly remove gas from galaxies, but RPS has been observed to remove gas while also compressing gas on the leading edge of the galaxy, which can create a favorable environment for molecular gas formation [ 65 , 35 , 19 , 20 , 39 , 54 ] . RPS can therefore potentially increase the total molecular gas content of a galaxy so that it can be detected through either gas tails, as in jellyfish galaxies, or possibly through elevated gas content. One such example of RPS forming as well as removing molecular gas is the jellyfish JW100, where the total integrated molecular gas content of the galaxy and tail exceeds the molecular gas content of similar, undisturbed galaxies [ 39 ] . To detect deviations in integrated molecular gas content, one must compare observations of cluster galaxies to those of coeval field galaxies. Large samples of integrated CO in field galaxies across redshift are thus key to assessing the ubiquity of an environmental impact on molecular gas. Work by [ 64 ] found an empirically-derived “field scaling relation” (hereafter T18, see also Genzel et al. 30 ) between a galaxy’s redshift, stellar mass, SFR, and molecular gas mass among star-forming field galaxies. T18 used 1,444 measurements of molecular gas at 0<z<4 from many surveys and found the relationship between the galaxy properties and molecular gas content had a fairly narrow scatter (0.2 dex for individual galaxies, 0.1 dex for averages of galaxies). Therefore, cluster galaxies can be classified as gas-deficient or gas-rich in relation to field galaxies of similar properties. However, the T18 relation was mainly created from galaxies with SFRs along and above the Star-Forming Main Sequence (SFMS). As such, the field scaling relation is not calibrated for galaxies below the SFMS and does not predict observed gas masses in quiescent galaxies (see Williams et al. 70 , Whitaker et al. 68 ). For galaxies on and around the SFMS, the field scaling relation can be used to investigate trends of gas content in cluster galaxies over redshift. In [ 2 ] , this is depicted in Figure 14 for CO measurements in cluster galaxies from z\sim 0-2 . To summarize, in local clusters between z=0-0.2 , there is a wide range of gas content which spans \sim 2 dex below to \sim 0.5 dex above T18. At slightly higher redshift ( 0.2<z<0.6 ), integrated molecular gas measurements have similarly found cluster galaxies that are gas-deficient as well as galaxies that are gas-rich [ 13 , 23 , 28 , 29 , 62 ] . At high redshift ( z>1 ), a majority of cluster galaxies are consistent with or gas-rich compared to the T18 field scaling relation and, unlike low redshift results, a population of significantly gas-deficient star-forming galaxies is notably absent [ 3 , 66 , 46 , 47 , 32 , 71 , 56 ] . It is not known whether this result simply reflects limited CO sensitivity and Malmquist Bias, or indicates a reversal of what has been observed in the local galaxy clusters. In this paper, we address this problem by probing CO emission to fainter luminosities through stacking analyses with 54 galaxy cluster members in three z\sim 1.6 galaxy clusters from the Spitzer Adaptation of the Red-Sequence Cluster Survey (SpARCS; Wilson et al. 72 , Muzzin et al. 43 ). These clusters are of particular interest as their members are known to have elevated gas fractions [ 47 ] , high levels of kinematic asymmetries [ 21

Read the complete text