Aerodynamic Control of Laminar Separation on a Wall-Bounded Airfoil at Transitional Reynolds Numbers
Charles Klewicki, Ari Schenkman, Geoffrey R. Spedding · 2025
Read Aerodynamic Control of Laminar Separation on a Wall-Bounded Airfoil at Transitional Reynolds Numbers by Charles Klewicki, Ari Schenkman, Geoffrey R. Spedding (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-15191.txt.
Introduction
Charles Klewicki, Ari Schenkman, and Geoffrey Spedding report a 2025 wind tunnel study on flow over a wing at slow speeds. At such speeds the airflow can peel off the wing in two ways: a low-lift state, or a high-lift state where the flow closes back into a bubble. The flow flips between them near a set tilt.
The team used sound pulses to nudge the flow toward the good state. One rescaled pulse rate worked best across speeds, tied to the thin layer of air at the wing's skin. Where along the wing to pulse shifted with rate and tilt, always upstream of the peel-off point.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Charles Klewicki, Ari Schenkman, Geoffrey R. Spedding |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 71 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-15191
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Aerodynamic Control of Laminar Separation on a Wall-Bounded Airfoil at Transitional Reynolds Numbers Charles Klewicki, Ari Schenkman, Geoffrey R. Spedding Abstract Experiments were conducted in a low-turbulence wind tunnel to investigate the efficacy of localised acoustic forcing upon the dynamics and stability of the flow on a cambered, wall-bounded airfoil over a range of Reynolds numbers (Re) where the flow state can switch between two limits – a low-lift state (SI) where separation continues beyond the trailing edge and a high-lift state (SII) where the separated flow is closed off to form a laminar separation bubble. The switching between SI and SII can occur close to a critical angle of attack ( α crit \alpha_{\textrm{crit}} ) which varies with Re . The most effective forcing frequencies are found at a constant value of a rescaled Strouhal number, St ∗ = St / Re 1 / 2 = 0.027 \mbox{{S}t}^{*}=\mbox{{S}t}/\mbox{{R}e}^{1/2}=0.027 , which indicates that though the primary unstable modes of the separated shear layer are of the inviscid, Kelvin-Helmholtz type, these modes are seeded by length scales that originate in the laminar (viscous) boundary layer. The most effective chordwise forcing location varies with St / Re 1 / 2 \mbox{{S}t}/\mbox{{R}e}^{1/2} and incidence angle, α \alpha , and is always upstream of the separation point. Although the boundary layer flows are far from two-dimensional, forcing at a fixed chord location across all spanwise locations is effective in controlling the SI – SII transition. Strategies for active and passive feedback control are suggested. A Preprint 1 Introduction 1.1 Transitional Aerodynamics As the chord-based Reynolds number, \mbox{{R}e}=Uc/\nu ( U is the flight speed, c is the chord length, and \nu is the kinematic viscosity), of a flying vehicle falls below about 10^{6} , the aerodynamic properties become strongly influenced not only by the angle of incidence, \alpha , but also Re itself (which is the source of only minor variations when \mbox{{R}e}>10^{6} ). In particular, in the range \mbox{{R}e}=10^{4}-10^{5} , there is a sometimes delicate balance as the laminar boundary has relatively weak resistance to separation but can also reattach, in a time-averaged sense, thanks to the rapid development of shear-layer instabilities and their subsequent transition to turbulence. There is a strong dependence of performance metrics such as the lift to drag ratio, L/D , on whether the flow does or does not reattach; and there is considerable interest in the origin of separation as well as the development of initially small perturbations in the detached shear layer. When the shear layer instabilities are of sufficient amplitude, either in the form of spanwise coherent vortices or as turbulent fluctuations that bring high-speed fluid close to the wall, time-averaged reattachment occurs. The effective airfoil shape then includes the streamline curvature as the separated flow is closed off before the trailing edge, and this closed, recirculating region is termed a laminar separation bubble, or LSB ( Tani, 1964 ) . As noted by Lissaman (1983) , the dynamics of the LSB then dictate the aerodynamic performance of the wing section. For a uniform, turbulence-free condition, far from boundary effects, the performance of a given wing section is a function of Re and \alpha . The effects of Re variation were demonstrated by Zaman and McKinzie (1991) , showing abrupt jumps in C_{L} as Re rose through the range of 5-7\times 10^{4} for two airfoils (LRN-(1)-1007 and Wortmann FX 63-137), and more recently by Toppings and Yarusevych (2024) on a NACA 0018 across a range of 3^{\circ}\leq\alpha\leq 9^{\circ} by varying Re through =4.8-8.6\times 10^{4} in a single time series. Doubling or halving of C_{L} was observed when Re was increased or decreased around a critical value where LSB formation would occur. The variation with \alpha was examined by Tank et al. (2021) on a NACA 65(1)412 at \mbox{{R}e}=2\times 10^{4} . A critical angle of attack ( \alpha_{\textrm{crit}} ) was identified at which point the wing would experience an abrupt, non-linear jump in lift and drop in drag if \alpha were increased by an increment as small as 0.5^{\circ} . Through time-averaged PIV fields, Tank et al. (2021) connected the discontinuity in the lift and drag polars to a change in flow state from one with laminar separation without reattachment (SI), to one with laminar separation with reattachment (SII), much as previously noted for the Eppler 387 by Yang and Spedding (2014) In addition to the governing parameters Re and \alpha , small variations in geometry and/or freestream conditions are known to influence the flow state. Both Jaroslawski et al. (2023) and Istvan et al. (2018) found that that higher freestream turbulence intensities promote transition, resulting in the formation and shrinking of LSBs. Such sensitivities likely are responsible for the difficulty in reconciling experimental and numerical results for ostensibly similar conditions ( Selig, 1995 ; Yang and Spedding, 2013a ; Tank et al., 2017 ) . A number of studies have investigated the mechanisms of transition in the shear layer originating from laminar separation ( Burgmann et al., 2008 ; Jones et al., 2010 ; Rodriguez et al., 2013 ; Kurelek et al., 2021 ) . The boundary layer separates from the airfoil surface and initially remains laminar, creating a stagnant zone termed the dead-air region by Horton (1968) . As the separation line further diverges from the surface, reverse flow velocities increase and a strong shear layer develops. Exponential growth of disturbances causes the shear layer to destabilize into a two-dimensional instability similar to a Kelvin-Helmholtz (K-H) ( Thomson, 1871 ; Helmholtz, 1868 ) instability, albeit with a nearby boundary. Diwan and Ramesh (2009) experimentally investigated laminar separation on a flat plate and found that the origin of perturbation growth was due to inflectional instabilities upstream of separation. Studies by Probsting and Yarusevych (2015) and Michelis et al. (2018) have also located the amplification of disturbances as occurring upstream of separation and confined to a select frequency range. The inflectional instabilities identified by Diwan and Ramesh (2009) were found to be convective in nature and the dominant mechanism for the growth of disturbances into the dead-air region. After detachment of the boundary layer and sufficient distancing of the separation streamline from the airfoil surface, the dominant amplification mechanism of disturbances becomes that of an inviscid shear layer instability, with higher growth rates. Similar findings by Yarusevych et al. (2006) ; Jones et al. (2008) and Boutilier and Yarusevych (2012) identified these K-H shear layer instabilities as the primary mechanism for disturbance growth through experiment and linear stability theory. In contrast to the convective instabilities discussed by Diwan and Ramesh (2009) , studies by Alam and Sandham (2000) and Dellacasagrande et al. (2024) identified the onset of absolute instabilities for reverse flows of sufficient height or magnitude within the separated region. In either case,exponential growth of disturbances leads to two-dimensional roll-up vortices which initially remain coherent. Eventually, these roll-up vortices are destabilized by nonlinear interactions as they convect downstream and rapidly transition to turbulence. Direct Numerical Simulations by Klose et al. (2025) detail the three-dimensional transition process for a NACA 65(1)412, noting the appearance and merging of braid vortices (also discussed by Ho and Huerre (1984) in relation to K-H instabilities) between successive roll-up vortices as the beginning