Atmospheric Muon Flux Suppression at Potential New Low-Radiation Underground Physics Laboratory in Israel
Nadav Hargittai, Igor Zolkin, Yiftah Silver, Yan Benhammou, Gilad Mizrachi, Hagar Landsman, Erez Etzion, Ranny Budnik · 2025
Read Atmospheric Muon Flux Suppression at Potential New Low-Radiation Underground Physics Laboratory in Israel by Nadav Hargittai, Igor Zolkin, Yiftah Silver, Yan Benhammou, Gilad Mizrachi, Hagar Landsman, Erez Etzion, Ranny Budnik (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-15102.txt.
Introduction
Nadav Hargittai and co-workers measure cosmic ray muons deep underground at a possible new physics lab in Israel, in a 2025 paper. The site sits in tunnels of a pumped-storage plant under a national park, with thick rock overhead. Low radiation is vital for rare-event physics.
Using stacked detector plates over several days, they compared the muon flow underground with the flow at the surface. The rock cut the flow by a factor of several thousand. The shape of the mountain showed up clearly in the direction data. Radon levels were low. The team concludes the site suits future low-background research.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Nadav Hargittai, Igor Zolkin, Yiftah Silver, Yan Benhammou, Gilad Mizrachi, Hagar Landsman, Erez Etzion, Ranny Budnik |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 17 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-15102
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Atmospheric Muon Flux Suppression at Potential New Low-Radiation Underground Physics Laboratory in Israel Nadav Hargittai, Igor Zolkin, Yiftah Silver, Yan Benhammou, Gilad Mizrachi, Hagar Landsman, Erez Etzion, Ranny Budnik Abstract The residual atmospheric muon flux was measured at a candidate site for a new underground, low-radiation physics laboratory beneath the Kokhav HaYarden national park in Israel. Located inside the tunnels of a hydroelectric pumped-storage facility operating since 2024, the proposed site benefits from a vertical rock overburden of 361 meters, large potential floorspace, and easy access by road. A muon hodoscope of vertically stacked wide-area 144 × 60 × 1.2 144\times 60\times 1.2 cm 3 plastic scintillator plates was employed to measure the suppression in the integrated muon flux at the site as compared with above ground at sea level. Data-taking took place in mid-August of 2024 for several days and was split into South-North and West-East orientations to account for the directional acceptances due to the geometry of the detector. The suppression factor is reported at 4456 ± 77 4456\pm 77 , expressed as 3.75 ± 0.06 × 10 − 6 3.75\pm 0.06\times 10^{-6} cm -2 s -1 in absolute terms, corresponding to an effective overburden of roughly 873 873 m.w.e.. A deeper location at the site may also be available, but it could not be reached at this time. Furthermore, the asymmetric topography of the mountain above and its muon shadow are clearly visible in the angular data. Finally, auxiliary environmental measurements recorded low background radon activity at 28.3 ± 14.0 28.3\pm 14.0 Bq m -3 . The experimental campaign thus succeeded in demonstrating the viability of the site’s working conditions for future scientific research. keywords Underground laboratory, muons, hodoscope, low radiation, dark matter, superconducting qubits. 1 Introduction Figure 1 : S-N (South-North) and West-East (W-E) profile cuts of the topography above the measurement site at KY. Elevation is above and below sea level. Operating low-background physics experiments often requires going underground to find shielding from high levels of atmospheric muons, the most abundant high-energy component of the cosmic ray flux on the surface. Several such underground laboratories exist in the world, hosting a range of experiments in areas such as rare-event searches in dark matter direct detection Undagoitia and Rauch 2015 ; Cooley 2022 , neutrinoless double-beta decay Dolinski et al. 2019 , and neutrino physics Kumaran et al. 2021 ; Joo 2017 . In the field of quantum information science, the need to shield superconducting qubits from ionising radiation to achieve longer coherence times and higher fidelity has also sparked interest in underground environments Cardani et al. 2021 ; Vepsäläinen et al. 2020 ; Bertoldo et al. 2025 . Therefore, the suppressed atmospheric muon flux is a crucial parameter in evaluating potential sites. This quantity must be measured directly since accurate geological profiles for use in simulations are hard to obtain. Preliminary work in identifying sites for a new low-radiation underground laboratory in Israel has begun by exploring one of two locations, both of which are part of pumped-storage hydroelectric projects that require boring service tunnels deep into the sides of mountains. Smaller tunnel branches, used during construction but no longer necessary thereafter, provide potentially prime real-estate. There is a precedent for taking advantage of these facilities at the YangYang underground laboratory in the Republic of Korea Lee et al. 2006 ; Yoon et al. 2021 . This work presents the first exploratory campaign performed at Kokhav HaYarden (KY) pumped storage facility Hutchison Water in the Valley of Springs regional council in Israel, at a vertical depth of 361 m. The second pumped-storage facility, located close to Kibbutz Manara in the Upper Galille Regional Council Ellomay Capital Ltd. , is still under construction but promises over double the depth at approximately 750 m. 2 Kokhav HaYarden Site The Kokhav HaYarden (KY) pumped storage facility sits squarely in between the town of Beit-She’an and the southern tip of the Sea of Galilee. It takes advantage of the height difference between the Jordan valley and the KY national park above to its west for the operations of its hydroelectric power plant. A roughly 1 km long service tunnel, easily accessible by even large vans, extends horizontally west into the mountain from Route 90 in the valley, leading to the large engine and turbine halls, from which lesser tunnels branch out. It was at the entrance to one of these unused branches that we could perform measurements. Most of the unused branches are blocked off by a concrete wall, and access is currently limited due to increased safety requirements. However, the potential available floor space where the rest of the branch is to be commissioned is estimated to be several hundred square metres with a ceiling height of 6 m. Furthermore, a 25\% increase in vertical overburden is possible deeper into the tunnel as compared with 361 m at the measurement location. For safety reasons, we were prevented from using those deeper tunnels at this time. Figure 2 : Slant depths, defined as the length of earth with respect to the measurement site, shown both for S-N and W-E orientations. The direction of the minimum overburden for each orientation is indicated by the dashed lines. The right axis displays the overburden in units of m.w.e., using a representative rock density value of 2.6 g cm -3 . Figure 3 : Full sky slant depth. The \phi angle is measured from the geographical north. Figure 4 : Satellite image with an overlay of the service tunnel map, showing the location of the measurements site Google Earth . The South-North (S-N) and West-East (W-E) overburden profile cuts, shown in figure 1 , were extracted from a surface elevation map using Google’s elevation API Google Maps Platform 2025 in accordance with the separate S-N and W-E oriented data-taking campaigns. The slant depth, defined as the length of overburden at a given angle with respect to the measurement site, is shown in figure 2 . While this figure presents the S-N and W-E slant depth profiles, a full two-dimensional slant depth distribution as a function of azimuth and zenith angle is shown in figure 3 . A simplified simulation was performed to estimate the effective vertical overburden of the underground site. It was based on the standard sea-level cosmic-ray muon flux and the continuous energy loss model for muons in matter Workman et al. 2022 . The muon spectrum was generated using the Gaisser parametrization, and particles were propagated in angular and energy bins through the rock overburden, using the two-dimensional slant-depth map. The resulting flux attenuation corresponds to a flat overburden of approximately 860 m.w.e. in good agreement with the measured value reported here. The layout of the tunnel and a photograph of the measurement site are shown in figures 4 and 5 , respectively. The above-ground, slightly above sea-level measurement site was located at the High Energy Laboratory at Tel-Aviv University (TAU). A summary of the two locations is shown in table 1 . Figure 5 : Photograph of the measurement site at the KY underground location, with the muon hodoscope seen on the right at a South-North orientation (the photograph is looking south). The rest of the unused tunnel and