New chiral structures for nucleon baryon number violating decays
Yi Liao, Xiao-Dong Ma, Hao-Lin Wang · 2025
Read New chiral structures for nucleon baryon number violating decays by Yi Liao, Xiao-Dong Ma, Hao-Lin Wang (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-14855.txt.
Introduction
Yi Liao, Xiao-Dong Ma, and Hao-Lin Wang map, in a 2025 physics paper, the basic ways a nucleon can decay while breaking baryon number. Many theories predict such decays at faint rates. The authors sort the three-quark interactions by how they transform under the chiral symmetry of the strong force. Four families appear, plus their mirror partners.
Half of these families were known; the other half are named here for the first time. Matching each family to the low-energy world of baryons and light mesons gives each a unique fingerprint. One new family enters at the same leading order as the classic ones, so searches should not skip it. The work widens the hunt for proton decay.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Yi Liao, Xiao-Dong Ma, Hao-Lin Wang |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 45 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-14855
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
New chiral structures for nucleon baryon number violating decays Yi Liao, Xiao-Dong Ma, Hao-Lin Wang Abstract We examine the most general nucleon decay interactions that involve three light quarks without being acted upon by a derivative. We identify four generic operator structures that correspond to the irreducible representations in the chiral group SU ( 3 ) 𝙻 ⊗ SU ( 3 ) 𝚁 {\rm SU(3)}_{\tt L}\otimes{\rm SU(3)}_{\tt R} of QCD, { 𝟖 𝙻 ⊗ 𝟏 𝚁 \boldsymbol{8}_{\tt L}\otimes\boldsymbol{1}_{\tt R} , 𝟑 ¯ 𝙻 ⊗ 𝟑 𝚁 \bar{\boldsymbol{3}}_{\tt L}\otimes\boldsymbol{3}_{\tt R} , 𝟔 𝙻 ⊗ 𝟑 𝚁 \boldsymbol{6}_{\tt L}\otimes\boldsymbol{3}_{\tt R} , 𝟏𝟎 𝙻 ⊗ 𝟏 𝚁 \boldsymbol{10}_{\tt L}\otimes\boldsymbol{1}_{\tt R} }, plus their chirality partners under the interchange of chiralities 𝙻 ↔ 𝚁 {\tt L}\leftrightarrow{\tt R} . While half of them have been extensively discussed in the literature, the other half, 𝟔 𝙻 ( 𝚁 ) ⊗ 𝟑 𝚁 ( 𝙻 ) \boldsymbol{6}_{\tt L(R)}\otimes\boldsymbol{3}_{\tt R(L)} and 𝟏𝟎 ¯ 𝙻 ( 𝚁 ) ⊗ 𝟏 𝚁 ( 𝙻 ) \bar{\boldsymbol{10}}_{\tt L(R)}\otimes\boldsymbol{1}_{\tt R(L)} , are identified for the first time. We perform chiral matching for these interactions at the leading chiral order and find that each has a unique chiral realization in terms of the octet baryons and pseudoscalars. Notably, the chiral interaction in the 𝟔 𝙻 ( 𝚁 ) ⊗ 𝟑 𝚁 ( 𝙻 ) \boldsymbol{6}_{\tt L(R)}\otimes\boldsymbol{3}_{\tt R(L)} representation appears at the same chiral order as those of the known ones, while the one in the 𝟏𝟎 𝙻 ( 𝚁 ) ⊗ 𝟏 𝚁 ( 𝙻 ) \boldsymbol{10}_{\tt L(R)}\otimes\boldsymbol{1}_{\tt R(L)} representation appears at a higher chiral order. These new structures are prevalent in effective field theories and UV models, and offer novel experimental avenues to search for baryon number violating nucleon decays. Introduction. Baryon number violation is one of the three Sahkarov conditions Sakharov:1967dj to explain the overwhelming dominance of matter over antimatter in the current Universe. And baryon number violating (BNV) nucleon decays are the most feasible processes that can be searched for in terrestrial laboratories. Because of its fundamental importance, experimental endeavors have a long history that dates back to the latter half of the 20th century. Large fiducial mass experiments, such as IMB Irvine-Michigan-Brookhaven:1983iap , SNO+ SNO:2018ydj , KamLAND KamLAND:2015pvi , Kamiokande Hirata:1988ad and its upgrade, Super-Kamiokande Takhistov:2016eqm , have investigated various characteristic nucleon decays, yielding null results that have imposed stringent limits on their occurrence. The next generation of neutrino experiments Dev:2022jbf , including DUNE DUNE:2016evb ; DUNE:2020ypp , Hyper-Kamiokande Hyper-Kamiokande:2018ofw , JUNO JUNO:2015zny , and THEIA Theia:2019non , are expected to further enhance sensitivity to nucleon decays. It is important that all possible decay channels should be attempted, exotic as well as conventional, and this requires a complete analysis of relevant interactions at both effective and fundamental levels. BNV nucleon decays are rare, if existing at all. This implies that baryon number violation must originate from physics at a very high energy scale. Indeed, baryon number violation is a common prediction in theories beyond the standard model (SM) such as grand unified theories Georgi:1974sy ; Sakai:1981pk ; Hisano:1992jj . Effective field theory (EFT) provides a systematic and consistent framework to relate the physical origin of BNV at high energy to the experimentally sought processes at low energy. Most importantly, with minimal assumptions it does not rely on the details of high energy physics and is thus universal in a broad sense. In this Letter we investigate general BNV interactions of the octet baryons that violate baryon number by one unit ( |\Delta B|=1 ) and thus contribute to BNV nucleon decays. To employ experimental results at low energy to shed light on physical origin of BNV at high energy, we explore BNV interactions in the low energy effective field theory (LEFT) that involve three light quarks without being acted upon by a derivative. By matching the interactions to those in chiral perturbation theory (ChPT), we can establish BNV effective interactions for the octet baryons and pseudoscalars, neutrinos and charged leptons, and the photon, plus any new light particles beyond the SM. We find that the above triple quark structures are classified into four irreducible representations (irreps) plus their chirality partners under the chiral group \rm SU(3)_{\tt L}\otimes SU(3)_{\tt R} of QCD: \boldsymbol{8}_{\tt L(R)}\otimes\boldsymbol{1}_{\tt R(L)} , \bar{\boldsymbol{3}}_{\tt L(R)}\otimes\boldsymbol{3}_{\tt R(L)} , \boldsymbol{6}_{\tt L(R)}\otimes\boldsymbol{3}_{\tt R(L)} , \boldsymbol{10}_{\tt L(R)}\otimes\boldsymbol{1}_{\tt R(L)} , where the subscripts {\tt L},{\tt R} refer to the left- and right-handed chirality of quarks. While the first half of irreps were known in the 1980s Wilczek:1979hc ; Ellis:1979hy ; Weinberg:1979sa ; Weinberg:1980bf ; Abbott:1980zj ; Kaymakcalan:1983uc in the form of dimension-6 (dim-6) operators, the other half irreps are identified for the first time. A ChPT was built in Ref. Claudson:1981gh based on the irreps \boldsymbol{8}_{\tt L(R)}\otimes\boldsymbol{1}_{\tt R(L)} and \bar{\boldsymbol{3}}_{\tt L(R)}\otimes\boldsymbol{3}_{\tt R(L)} . Since then, nearly all phenomenological analyses of BNV nucleon decays have been based on these results. In particular, these chiral interactions have been extensively employed in recent studies of various nucleon decay modes from the EFT perspective Hambye:2017qix ; Fonseca:2018ehk ; Helo:2019yqp ; Heeck:2019kgr ; Girmohanta:2019xya ; He:2021sbl ; Beneito:2023xbk ; Gargalionis:2024nij ; Fajfer:2023gfi ; Li:2024liy ; Li:2025slp . As we will show in this work, the new structures, \boldsymbol{6}_{\tt L(R)}\otimes\boldsymbol{3}_{\tt R(L)} and \boldsymbol{10}_{\tt L(R)}\otimes\boldsymbol{1}_{\tt R(L)} , naturally appear in higher-dimension operators. We will find that they have nontrivial chiral realizations in ChPT, operate ( \boldsymbol{6}_{\tt L(R)}\otimes\boldsymbol{3}_{\tt R(L)} ) at the same chiral order as those previously identified ( \boldsymbol{8}_{\tt L(R)}\otimes\boldsymbol{1}_{\tt R(L)} and \bar{\boldsymbol{3}}_{\tt L(R)}\otimes\boldsymbol{3}_{\tt R(L)} ) Claudson:1981gh , and thus may significantly influence nucleon decays. They are especially important for exotic nucleon decays that are either prohibited at dim-6 order or involve new light particles. General BNV triple quark interactions. In the LEFT framework or its extensions with new light fields, we find that a general BNV operator involving three quarks ( q=u,d,s ) without being acted upon by a covariant derivative can always be expressed in terms of the following four structures, \displaystyle{\cal O}_{a}^{yzw} \displaystyle=(\overline{\Psi_{a}}q_{{\tt L},y}^{\alpha})(\overline{q_{{\tt L},z}^{\beta{\tt C}}}q_{{\tt L},w}^{\gamma})\epsilon_{\alpha\beta\gamma}, (1a) \displaystyle{\cal O}_{b}^{yzw} \displaystyle=(\overline{\Psi_{b}}q_{{\tt R},y}^{\alpha})(\overline{q_{{\tt L},z}^{\beta{\tt C}}}q_{{\tt L},w}^{\gamma})\epsilon_{\alpha\beta\gamma}, (1b) \displaystyle{\cal O}_{c}^{yzw} \displaystyle=(\overline{\Psi_{c,\mu}}q_{{\tt L},\{y}^{\alpha})(\overline{q_{{\tt L},z\}}^{\beta{\tt C}}}\gamma^{\mu}q_{{\tt R},w}^{\gamma})\epsilon_{\alpha\beta\gamma}, (1c) \displaystyle{\cal O}_{d}^{yzw} \displaystyle=(\overline{\Psi_{d,\mu\nu}}q_{{\tt L},\{y}^{\alpha})(\overline{q_{{\tt L},z}^{\beta{\tt C}}}\sigma^{\mu\nu}q_{{\tt L},w\}}^{\gamma})\epsilon_{\alpha\beta\gamma}, (1d) and their chirality partners with {\tt L}\leftrightarrow{\tt R} . Here y,z,w=1,2,3 are light quark flavor indices, with q_{1,2,3}=u,d,s . The curly brackets indicate symmetrization in all flavor indices of like-chirality fields included, viz., A_{\{y}B_{z\}}\equiv(1/2)(A_{y}B_{z}+A_{z}B_{y}) and A_{\{y}B_{z}C_{w\}}\equiv(1/6)[A_{y}B_{z}C_{w}+\mbox{5 perms of}(y,z,w)] . The conjugate fermion-type external fields \overline{\Psi_{a}},\overline{\Psi_{b}},\overline{\Psi_{c,\mu}},\overline{\Psi_{d,\mu\nu}} are combination of non-QCD fields that can be identified for each specific operator. The completeness and independence of the structures in Eq. 1 can be proved using the non-standard Fierz identities provided in Liao:2016hru ; Liao:2020jmn . For instance, by using the Fierz identity, (\overline{\psi_{1{\tt R}}}\psi_{2{\tt L}})(\overline{\psi_{3{\tt L}}^{\tt C}}\psi_{4{\tt L}})=-(\overline{\psi_{1{\tt R}}}\psi_{3{\tt L}})(\overline{\psi_{2{\tt L}}^{\tt C}}\psi_{4{\tt L}})-(\overline{\psi_{1{\tt R}}}\psi_{4{\tt L}})(\overline{\psi_{3{\tt L}}^{\tt C}}\psi_{2{\tt L}}) and its variation, operators with antisymmetric flavor indices in two like-chirality quarks in two bilinears, or with a tensor quark bilinear, are not independent but can be transformed into the above ones, \displaystyle(\overline{\Psi_{c,\mu}}q_{{\tt L},[y}^{\alpha})(\overline{q_{{\tt L},z]}^{\beta{\tt C}}}\gamma^{\mu}q_{{\tt R},w}^{\gamma})\epsilon_{\alpha\beta\gamma} \displaystyle={1\over 2}(\hbox{\pagecolor{gray!20}$\overline{\Psi_{c,\mu}}\gamma^{\mu}$}q_{{\tt R},w}^{\alpha})(\overline{q_{{\tt L},z}^{\beta{\tt C}}}q_{{\tt L},y}^{\gamma})\epsilon_{\alpha\beta\gamma}\sim{\cal O}_{b}^{yzw}, (2a) \displaystyle(\overline{\Psi_{d,\mu\nu}}q_{{\tt R},y}^{\alpha})(\overline{q_{{\tt L},z}^{\beta{\tt C}}}\sigma^{\mu\nu}q_{{\tt L},w}^{\gamma})\epsilon_{\alpha\beta\gamma} \displaystyle=-2i(\hbox{\pagecolor{gray!20}$\overline{\Psi_{d,\mu\nu}}\gamma^{\mu}$}q_{{\tt L},\{z}^{\alpha})(\overline{q_{{\tt L},w\}}^{\beta{\tt C}}}\gamma^{\nu}q_{{\tt R},y}^{\gamma})\epsilon_{\alpha\beta\gamma}\sim{\cal O}_{c}^{yzw}, (2b) \displaystyle(\overline{\Psi_{d,\mu\nu}}q_{{\tt L},[y}^{\alpha})(\overline{q_{{\tt L},z]}^{\beta{\tt C}}}\sigma^{\mu\nu}q_{{\tt L},w}^{\gamma})\epsilon_{\alpha\beta\gamma} \displaystyle=-{1\over 2}(\hbox{\pagecolor{gray!20}$\overline{\Psi_{d,\mu\nu}}\sigma^{\mu\nu}$}q_{{\tt L},w}^{\alpha})(\overline{q_{{\tt L},y}^{\beta{\tt C}}}q_{{\tt L},z}^{\gamma})\epsilon_{\alpha\beta\gamma}\sim{\cal