LACE: Exploring Turn-Taking and Parallel Interaction Modes in Human-AI Co-Creation for Iterative Image Generation Conference: Generative AI and HCI: A CHI 2025 Workshop; April 27, 2025; Yokohama, Japan and Online CCS: Human-centered computing Interactive systems and tools
Yen-Kai Huang, Zheng Ning, Ming Cheng · 2025
Read LACE: Exploring Turn-Taking and Parallel Interaction Modes in Human-AI Co-Creation for Iterative Image Generation Conference: Generative AI and HCI: A CHI 2025 Workshop; April 27, 2025; Yokohama, Japan and Online CCS: Human-centered computing Interactive systems and tools by Yen-Kai Huang, Zheng Ning, Ming Cheng (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-14827.txt.
Introduction
YenKai Huang, Zheng Ning, and Ming Cheng present LACE, a system that lets artists create images with generative AI inside Photoshop. Their paper appeared in 2025. Professional artists complain that AI tools are imprecise, lose coherence across revisions, and clash with their workflow. LACE answers with layer-based editing, tight prompt control, and two collaboration modes: taking turns with the AI, or working in parallel with it.
A pilot study with 21 artists found clear gains over standard AI workflows in satisfaction, sense of ownership, usability, and artistic judgment of the results. The authors share detailed feedback from the artists, both praise and friction. They draw lessons for weaving generative tools into professional practice without flattening the artist's hand.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Yen-Kai Huang, Zheng Ning, Ming Cheng |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 23 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-14827
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
LACE: Exploring Turn-Taking and Parallel Interaction Modes in Human-AI Co-Creation for Iterative Image Generation Conference: Generative AI and HCI: A CHI 2025 Workshop; April 27, 2025; Yokohama, Japan and Online CCS: Human-centered computing Interactive systems and tools Yen-Kai Huang, Zheng Ning, Ming Cheng Abstract . Generative AI (GenAI) has transformed visual art creation by allowing rapid ideation and prototyping from text prompts. However, it falls short in meeting professional artists’ needs due to their limited control over specific image elements, lack of coherence in iterative refinement, and incompatibility with established workflows. To address these challenges, we present LACE, a Human-AI co-creative system for iterative image generation with professional creative tools. Inspired from the Co-Creative Framework for Interaction (COFI) ( Rezwana and Maher 2023 ) , LACE supports both turn-taking and parallel interaction modes for iterative image generation. Through a within-subjects study with 21 participants across three creative tasks, we show preliminary results on how participation modes influence user experience, creative outcomes, and workflow preferences. Figure 1 . Main interface of LACE, integrated into Adobe Photoshop Main interface of LACE integrated into Adobe Photoshop, showing image prompting controls, layer management panels, and iterative refinement tools designed for professional artists. 1. Introduction Generative AI systems, such as MidJourney, FLUX, or Stable Diffusion, have surged in popularity for image creation. However, most of these systems still rely on single-turn workflows. Addressing this limitation, the Co-Creative Framework for Interaction (COFI) identifies participation style—parallel versus turn-taking—as critical for effective human-AI collaboration ( Rezwana and Maher 2023 ) . Although many creative support tools (CSTs) favor parallel interaction, where human and AI contributions occur simultaneously, a review of 92 CST systems revealed 89.1% adopt parallel interaction, with only 10.9% incorporating turn-taking ( Rezwana and Maher 2019 ) . Research suggests that turn-taking can foster deeper mutual understanding through clear role delineation ( Ikegami and Iizuka 2007 ) , whereas parallel interaction often supports greater real-time creative fluency ( Fan et al. 2019 ) . Despite these findings, systems that support both interaction modes remain unexplored ( van Berkel et al. 2021 ) . Enabling flexible transitions between parallel and turn-taking behaviors in human–AI co-creation may offer enhanced flexibility and better alignment with professional creative practices. To address this research gap, we introduce LACE, a system integrated into Adobe Photoshop that supports both parallel and turn-taking human-AI interactions (see figure 2 ). In parallel mode, a dual-feedback loop continuously generates AI-driven images, imported as independent layers. This allows artists to refine their work in real-time while receiving new suggestions without overwriting previous edits. In contrast, the turn-taking mode follows a more traditional text-to-image or image-to-image process, where users adjust prompts and receive a single output. Our pilot evaluation (N=21) provides preliminary evidence that such flexible interaction modes can enhance creative control and authorship. Although this study does not provide a full comparative analysis of parallel versus turn-taking modalities, our findings strongly demonstrate the potential of LACE to support flexible interaction modes, offering valuable insights into how these approaches can enhance creative control and authorship. This work provides guidance for future research to further explore and evaluate the distinct contributions of participation styles in human–AI co-creation. Our contributions are threefold: 1) we present LACE, a flexible co-creative system that integrates iterative AI pipelines within professional image editing workflows; 2) we offer initial observations on how blending parallel and turn-taking interactions may enhance user engagement and control; and 3) we outline a framework and future research agenda for more rigorous comparisons of participation styles in co-creative AI systems. Figure 2 . The LACE system supports two interaction modes: Turn-Taking and Parallel. Turn-Taking employs a classic sequential participation style, where human and AI iteratively refine the prompt and generated artifact in sequence. In Parallel mode, LACE maintains the AI loop for prompt iteration while introducing an independent Artist loop, allowing artists to refine their work in real-time without interruption. 2. RELATED WORK 2.1. Support Creativity Tools Generative AI systems such as MidJourney, FLUX, and Stable Diffusion have sparked considerable interest by producing visuals from text prompts, image prompts or maksing filling with latent diffusion models ( Rombach et al. 2022 ; MidJourney 2022 ) . However, most retain a single-turn approach—users provide a prompt, receive an image, and iterate only through prompt tweaking. While effective for rapid prototyping, this style lacks iterative refinement and local control over elements, potentially limiting creative coherence ( Gholami and Xiao 2024 ; Lugmayr et al. 2022 ) . 2.2. Parallel vs. Turn-Taking in Human-AI collaboration In Human–AI co-creativity research, participation style is widely recognized as critical to effective collaboration ( Rezwana and Maher 2023 ; Shneiderman 2002 ; Fischer 2004 ) . The Co-Creative Framework for Interaction (COFI) specifically highlights parallel (where human and AI act simultaneously) and turn-taking (structured, sequential input) as key modes ( Rezwana and Maher 2023 ) . A large-scale review of 92 creativity support tools (CST) shows an overwhelming preference for parallel interactions (89.1%), with only 10.9% incorporating turn-taking ( Rezwana and Maher 2019 ) . Despite indications that structured turn-taking fosters mutual understanding ( Ikegami and Iizuka 2007 ) and that parallel interactions benefit real-time fluency ( Fan et al. 2019 ) , comparatively few studies explore the flexibility of blending both styles ( van Berkel et al. 2021 ) . 2.3. Iterative Image Generation Professional tools (e.g., Adobe Photoshop) increasingly integrate AI functionalities, yet they often maintain single-step or prompt-driven workflows without robust iterative control ( Batley and Glithro 2024 ) . Although advanced features like neural filters and generative fill aid creativity, they rarely allow users to choose between parallel or turn-taking modes fluidly. This gap is especially noteworthy for professional creators seeking to balance spontaneity (parallel collaboration) with deliberation (turn-taking). Our approach, LACE, aims to address these shortcomings by merging continuous AI-driven suggestions with layer-based editing to preserve authorship, providing initial evidence of the potential benefits of flexible participation styles. 3. LACE SYSTEM Figure 3 . System architecture of LACE LACE builds on literature in digital art ( Okada and Yokochi 2024 ; Daniel 2022 ) , AI-assisted image creation ( Bozsó et al. 2024 ; Cao et al. 2023 ) , and control in generative models ( Feng et al. 2024 ; Yang et al. 2024 ) . It enables precise control over image generation, supports iterative refinement for creative continuity, and integrates seamlessly into professional workflows by extending Adobe Photoshop. Drawing on the Co-Creative Framework for Interaction (COFI) ( Rezwana and Maher 2023 ) , LACE supports two distinct participation styles—turn-taking and parallel—giving creators the flexibility to choose which style best aligns with their current creative task. By unifying these modes in the same Photoshop-based pipeline, LACE leverages industry-standard features such as layers, blending modes, and masking while providing different ways for the AI and user to alternate or synchronize their contributions. Figure 2 illustrates these two modes at a high level and the architecture in figure 3 . (1) Turn-taking Collaboration : Turn-taking mode enables structured workflows where users and the AI alternate contributions sequentially. This mode allows artists to iteratively refine ideas, focusing on precision and coherence. For example, users can provide the model with initial sketches or prompts, receive AI-generated