Bol loops of order 27
Alexander Grishkov, Michael Kinyon, Petr Vojtěchovský · 2025
Read Bol loops of order 27 by Alexander Grishkov, Michael Kinyon, Petr Vojtěchovský (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-14646.txt.
Introduction
Alexander Grishkov, Michael Kinyon, and Petr Vojtěchovský classify a family of algebraic structures called Bol loops of order twenty-seven in a 2025 paper. A loop is like a group, with a way to combine elements and undo it, but the grouping rule can fail. Bol loops obey one weaker replacement rule that shows up in geometry and physics-flavored algebra.
Mixing theory with computer search, the team find exactly fifteen such loops with twenty-seven elements. Five of them are ordinary groups. For the ten truly non-group loops, the paper gives fresh constructions that build each one explicitly. Complete lists like this anchor the theory, giving later researchers a fixed census to test guesses against.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Alexander Grishkov, Michael Kinyon, Petr Vojtěchovský |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 29 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-14646
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Bol loops of order 27 Thanks: A. Grishkov supported by FAPESP (grant 2018/23690-6), CNPq (grants 307593/2023-1 and 406932/2023-9), Brazil, and in accordance with the state task of the IM SB RAS, project FWNF-2022-003, Russia. P. Vojtěchovský supported by the Simons Foundation Mathematics and Physical Sciences Collaboration Grant for Mathematicians MPS-TSM-00855097. Alexander Grishkov, Michael Kinyon, Petr Vojtěchovský Abstract . We classify Bol loops of order 27 27 , using a combination of theoretical results and computer search. There are 15 15 Bol loops of order 27 27 , including five groups. New constructions for the ten nonassociative Bol loops of order 27 27 are given. 1991 Mathematics Subject Classification 20N05 1. Introduction Classifying algebras up to isomorphism in a given variety is an important task in abstract algebra. In this paper we will classify Bol loops of order 27 . The classification is made complicated by the fact that, unlike for p -groups or Moufang p -loops, Bol p -loops are not necessarily centrally nilpotent. It turns out that all 15 Bol loops of order 27 have already appeared in the literature. Our result can therefore be summarized as follows: No additional Bol loops of order 27 exist . We also present compact constructions of all Bol loops of order 27 and list some invariants by which the loops can be recognized. A loop is right Bol if it satisfies the identity (1.1) ((x\cdot y)\cdot z)\cdot y=x\cdot((y\cdot z)\cdot y). Left Bol loops are loops satisfying the dual (mirror image) of the identity 1.1 . The much-studied Moufang loops are precisely the loops that are both right Bol and left Bol. Remark . We will work with right Bol loops here. All results obtained in this paper for right Bol loops can be dualized to left Bol loops. It is customary to refer to right Bol loops or left Bol loops simply as Bol loops , as we have done in the title and in the narrative above. However, we employ this abbreviation only when it is safe to do so. We therefore avoid statements such as “Bol loops have the right inverse property,” which is meant to be a shorthand for the true statement “right Bol loops have the right inverse property,” but which can potentially be read as one of the false statements “left Bol loops have the right inverse property” or “Bol loops have the inverse property.” 1.1. Related classification results for Bol loops Bol loops were introduced by Bol [ 3 ] in the context of finite geometry. The first systematic algebraic study of Bol loops is due to Robinson [ 28 , 29 ] , who proved, among other results, that any Bol loop of prime order is a group. Let p\neq q be primes. Burn showed that Bol loops of order p^{2} and 2p are groups and he classified nonassociative Bol loops of order 8 [ 5 ] . Kinyon, Nagy and Vojtěchovský classified Bol loops of order pq [ 17 ] , building upon [ 27 ] . (See [ 32 ] for a classification of Bol loops of order pq up to isotopism.) For every odd prime p , there are precisely two nonassociative right Bol loops of order 2p^{2} [ 6 , 30 ] . There are many interesting examples of finite simple non-Moufang Bol loops [ 1 , 23 , 24 ] , making the classification of finite simple Bol loops challenging. Right Bruck loops are right Bol loops satisfying the property (xy)^{-1}=x^{-1}y^{-1} . Bruck loops of order p^{3} (resp. pq ) were classified in [ 2 ] (resp. [ 17 ] ). 1.2. Bol loops of order 27 in the literature Let us briefly describe where all Bol loops of order 27 appeared for the first time as far as we know. For every prime p , there are precisely 5 groups of order p^{3} . For an odd prime p , this was proved independently by Cole and Glover [ 7 ] , Hölder [ 14 ] and Young [ 33 ] . Using a backtracking algorithm, Moorhouse [ 21 ] constructed many Bol loops of small orders, including the 8 nonassociative Bol loops of order 27 with a nontrivial center. One of the two nonassociative Bol loops of order 27 with trivial center was found by Keedwell [ 15 , 16 ] in a different context—the cited papers do not mention that the loop satisfies a Bol identity. Kinyon noticed that Keedwell’s loop Q is a Bol loop and discovered the second Bol loop with trivial center by investigating all loop isotopes of Q . The two loops then appeared in [ 9 ] and [ 20 ] . 2. Loops See [ 4 ] for an introduction to loop theory. A loop (Q,\cdot,\backslash,/,1) is a set Q with binary operations \cdot , \backslash , / and an element 1\in Q satisfying the identities x\cdot(x\backslash y)=y=x\backslash(x\cdot y) , (x\cdot y)/y=x=(x/y)\cdot y and 1\cdot x=x=x\cdot 1 . The theory of loops encompasses the vast space between purely combinatorial objects (normalized latin squares) and highly structured algebras (groups). On the algebraic side, one often studies loops satisfying additional axioms. Remark . From now on, we will also use juxtaposition in place of the multiplication operation \cdot , and we declare \cdot to be less binding than the division operations / and \backslash , which will in turn be less binding than the juxtaposition. So, for instance, x/yz\cdot u\backslash v stands for (x/(y\cdot z))\cdot(u\backslash v) . For a loop Q and x\in Q , let L_{x}:Q\to Q , y\mapsto L_{x}(y)=xy be the left translation by x in Q , and R_{x}:Q\to Q , y\mapsto R_{x}(y)=yx the right translation by x in Q . Denote by \mathrm{Mlt}_{\ell}(Q)=\langle L_{x}:x\in Q\rangle,\quad\mathrm{Mlt}_{r}(Q)=\langle R_{x}:x\in Q\rangle,\quad\mathrm{Mlt}(Q)=\langle R_{x},L_{x}:x\in Q\rangle the left multiplication group , the right multiplication group and the multiplication group of Q , respectively. The left inner mapping group \mathrm{Inn}_{\ell}(Q) , the right inner mapping group \mathrm{Inn}_{r}(Q) and the inner mapping group \mathrm{Inn}(Q) are then the stabilizers of 1 in \mathrm{Mlt}_{\ell}(Q) , \mathrm{Mlt}_{r}(Q) and \mathrm{Mlt}(Q) , respectively. With L_{x,y}=L_{xy}^{-1}L_{x}L_{y},\quad R_{x,y}=R_{yx}^{-1}R_{x}R_{y},\quad T_{x}=L_{x}^{-1}R_{x}, it is well known that \mathrm{Inn}_{\ell}(Q)=\langle L_{x,y}:x,y\in Q\rangle , \mathrm{Inn}_{r}(Q)=\langle R_{x,y}:x,y\in Q\rangle and \mathrm{Inn}(Q)=\langle L_{x,y},R_{x,y},T_{x}:x,y\in Q\rangle . A subloop N\leq Q is normal in Q , denoted by N\unlhd Q , if \varphi(N)=N for all \varphi\in\mathrm{Inn}(Q) . The factor loop Q/N is then defined as usual. For a loop Q consider \displaystyle\mathrm{Nuc}_{\ell}(Q) \displaystyle=\{x\in Q:x\cdot yz=xy\cdot z\text{ for all }y,z\in Q\}, \displaystyle\mathrm{Nuc}_{m}(Q) \displaystyle=\{x\in Q:y\cdot xz=yx\cdot z\text{ for all }y,z\in Q\}, \displaystyle\mathrm{Nuc}_{r}(Q) \displaystyle=\{x\in Q:y\cdot zx=yz\cdot x\text{ for all }y,z\in Q\}, \displaystyle\mathrm{Nuc}(Q) \displaystyle=\mathrm{Nuc}_{\ell}(Q)\cap\mathrm{Nuc}_{m}(Q)\cap\mathrm{Nuc}_{r}(Q), the left nucleus , middle nucleus , right nucleus and nucleus of Q , respectively. Each of the four nuclei is a subloop of Q . Note that the elements of \mathrm{Nuc}_{\ell}(Q) are precisely the fixed points of \mathrm{Inn}_{r}(Q) . Let also \displaystyle\mathrm{Com}(Q) \displaystyle=\{x\in Q:xy=yx\text{ for all }y\in Q\}, \displaystyle Z(Q) \displaystyle=\mathrm{Nuc}(Q)\cap\mathrm{Com}(Q) be the commutant and the center of Q , respectively. The commutant is not necessarily a subloop of Q , even in Bol loops [ 19 ] . The center is always a normal subloop of Q . A loop Q is said to be centrally nilpotent if the series Q,\ Q/Z(Q),\ (Q/Z(Q))/Z(Q/Z(Q)),\ \dots