Consensus in Motion: A Case of Dynamic Rationality of Sequential Learning in Probability Aggregation
Polina Gordienko 1, Christoph Jansen 2, Thomas Augustin 1, Martin Rechenauer 3 · 2025
Read Consensus in Motion: A Case of Dynamic Rationality of Sequential Learning in Probability Aggregation by Polina Gordienko 1, Christoph Jansen 2, Thomas Augustin 1, Martin Rechenauer 3 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-14624.txt.
Introduction
Polina Gordienko, Christoph Jansen, Thomas Augustin, and Martin Rechenauer study group belief updates in a 2025 paper. Groups must merge member probabilities into one view, and that view should update cleanly when new facts arrive. Static rules miss that dynamic need. Their frame rests on propositional probability logic and a shared common ground.
Any rule that respects consensus and independence on a non-nested agenda must be linear, they show. If members start by agreeing on a common ground and new facts stay inside it, updating before or after merging gives the same result. A health and immigration policy case runs through the paper as an example.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Polina Gordienko 1, Christoph Jansen 2, Thomas Augustin 1, Martin Rechenauer 3 |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 31 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-14624
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Consensus in Motion: A Case of Dynamic Rationality of Sequential Learning in Probability Aggregation Polina Gordienko 1, Christoph Jansen 2, Thomas Augustin 1, Martin Rechenauer 3 Abstract We propose a framework for probability aggregation based on propositional probability logic. Unlike conventional judgment aggregation, which focuses on static rationality, our model addresses dynamic rationality by ensuring that collective beliefs update consistently with new information. We show that any consensus-compatible and independent aggregation rule on a non-nested agenda is necessarily linear. Furthermore, we provide sufficient conditions for a fair learning process, where individuals initially agree on a specified subset of propositions known as the common ground, and new information is restricted to this shared foundation. This guarantees that updating individual judgments via Bayesian conditioning—whether performed before or after aggregation—yields the same collective belief. A distinctive feature of our framework is its treatment of sequential decision-making, which allows new information to be incorporated progressively through multiple stages while maintaining the established common ground. We illustrate our findings with a running example in a political scenario concerning healthcare and immigration policies. 1 Introduction Traditional aggregation methods, such as majority voting, are notorious for producing collective judgments that are logically inconsistent and for failing to meet minimal rationality constraints. This shortcoming lies at the heart of the impossibility theorems that have emerged in judgment aggregation theory over the past two decades (e.g., [ 3 , 16 , 6 , 15 , 19 , 23 , 21 , 4 , 22 , 14 ] ). Unlike social choice—where preferences involve ranking alternatives – the aggregation of judgments concerns interconnected issues that capture acts of assent or dissent. Despite numerous attempts to weaken constraints on aggregation functions in order to achieve logical consistency [ 24 , 20 ] , prior research has focused mainly on static rationality. In contrast, this paper advocates a shift toward a dynamic theory of collective decision-making in which both individual and collective beliefs update rationally in response to new information (see [ 5 ] ). Motivated by the first impossibility result for dynamically rational judgment aggregation [ 10 ] , our main contribution is a possibility result for dynamically rational collective decision-making on logically interconnected propositions. We introduce a framework of probability aggregation based on propositional probability logic that generalizes traditional approaches from both judgment and preference aggregation. Building on prior work in probability aggregation [ 17 , 1 , 2 , 12 , 18 , 7 , 9 ] , our first theorem establishes that any consensus-compatible and independent aggregation rule on a non-nested agenda must be linear . Furthermore, we show that dynamically rational linear aggregation is attainable when the domain of the aggregation function is restricted to profiles in which all group members share the same probabilistic judgments for a specified subset of propositions—what we term the common ground (here understood in line with a broader notion of consensus) 1 1 1 Throughout this paper, “consensus” is used in two senses: (i) as a broad notion of mutual agreement—here, synonymous with our technical term “common ground” and (ii) as “consensus compatibility,” the requirement that if all individuals assign probability 1 to a proposition, then the collective judgment must also assign 1. . This common ground represents the set of propositions on which all individuals already agree, and by ensuring that new information is limited to this shared foundation—a process we call fair learning —all members benefit equally, preventing dynamically irrational outcomes arising from unequal starting beliefs. Importantly, we demonstrate that fair learning not only achieves dynamic rationality but also preserves the common ground across sequential updates. The paper is organized as follows. In Section 2.1 and Section 2.2 we develop our framework of probability aggregation based on propositional probability logic. Section 2.3 introduces a running example from the context of political decision-making, which we use to illustrate our framework throughout the paper. Section 3 is divided into two parts: Section 3.1 presents our characterization result for the linear aggregation rule, and Section 3.2 introduces a Bayesian updating process that demonstrates dynamic rationality under a restricted domain. Section 4 concludes. 2 The model of probability aggregation 2.1 Propositional probability logic Let \mathcal{L} be the set of all logically non-equivalent 2 2 2 Logical equivalence (i.e., \phi\equiv\psi if and only if \models\phi\leftrightarrow\psi ) is an equivalence relation. We select one finitary representative from each equivalence class so that no two distinct formulas in \mathcal{L} are equivalent. Since A is finite, and we consider only finitary formulas, \mathcal{L} is finite. formulas based on a propositional logic with a finite set A of atomic formulas. The variable \phi is then a generic variable ranging over all well-formed formulas in \mathcal{L} , i.e., any expression that can be constructed from the atomic elements in A using the logical connectives \neg,\land,\lor,\rightarrow,\leftrightarrow . Definition 1 An agenda is defined as a finite subset X\subseteq\mathcal{L} such that \forall\ \phi\in\mathcal{L}\colon\phi\in X\Rightarrow\neg\phi\in X . An agenda X is called \wedge -stable , if \forall\ r\in\mathbb{N},\ \forall\phi_{1},...,\phi_{r}\in X\colon\bigwedge_{j=1}^{r}\phi_{j}\in X . A propositional probability is a map P\colon\mathcal{L}\rightarrow[0,1] such that the following holds: • P(\phi)=1 if \models\phi (i.e. \phi is a tautology); • If \phi_{1},\phi_{2}...\in\mathcal{L} such that \models\neg(\phi_{i}\land\phi_{j}) for all i\neq j\in\mathbb{N} , then P(\bigvee_{i=1}^{\infty}\phi_{i})=\sum_{i=1}^{\infty}P(\phi_{i}). 2.2 The framework of probability aggregation Each individual i\in N with N=\{1,2,\dots,n\} holds a probabilistic judgement which is considered as a degree of confidence in the truth of the propositions in the agenda X that ranges from 0 (maximal doubt) to 1 (maximal confidence). Definition 2 The probabilistic judgement J is a function J\colon X\rightarrow[0,1] . The judgement J is called probabilistically rational if there exists a propositional probability P^{*}\colon\mathcal{L}\rightarrow[0,1] on the whole set \mathcal{L} such that \forall\ \phi\in X\colon J(\phi)=P^{*}(\phi) . A probabilistic profile on an agenda X is a tuple (J_{1},...,J_{n}) , where each of J_{1},...,J_{n} is a probabilistically rational probabilistic judgement. The probabilistic aggregation rule is a function F\colon J(X)^{n}\rightarrow J(X), where J(X) is the collective set of all probabilistically rational probabilistic judgements on the agenda X . Note that the propositional probability P^{*} is an extension of the probabilistic judgement J . The probabilistic profile captures the landscape of beliefs across group members, while the aggregation rule consolidates these individual probabilities into a unified collective judgment that maintains probabilistic rationality. 2.3 A Running Example: A Political Scenario To illustrate the concepts introduced in Section 2.2 , consider a \wedge -stable agenda X that comprises the following atomic propositions along with their logical interconnections: a : Population ageing is straining the healthcare and pension systems. b : It is necessary to implement new immigration policies to attract more skilled professionals who can contribute to the economy. c : The current tax revenue is sufficient to meet the fiscal demands imposed by population ageing. Table 1 shows a sample probabilistic profile on the agenda X , where we have three individuals (denoted by J_{1} , J_{2} , and J_{3} ). This example serves as our running example throughout the paper. Table 1: A sample probabilistic profile on the agenda X=\pm\{a,b,c,a\rightarrow b,a\land b,a\land c,b\land c,a\land b\land c\} , where each individual assigns a degree of confidence (ranging from 0 to 1) to the propositions. Each entry is chosen so as to align with the relationships