Going Down the Abstraction Stream with Augmented Reality and Tangible Robots: the Case of Vector Instruction
Sergei Volodin, Hala Khodr, Pierre Dillenbourg, Wafa Johal · 2025
Read Going Down the Abstraction Stream with Augmented Reality and Tangible Robots: the Case of Vector Instruction by Sergei Volodin, Hala Khodr, Pierre Dillenbourg, Wafa Johal (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-14562.txt.
Introduction
Sergei Volodin and co-authors test a hands-on way to teach vector sums in a 2025 study. Adding arrows head to tail is taught in high schools and used across science, yet even college physics students trip on it. Their plan fades from the concrete to the abstract in three stages.
Learners play a game that joins screen overlays with small real robots they can touch. Thirty people took part in the test run. Scores rose after the game, a clear learning gain. The team also read how learners acted at each stage. Such staged, touch-based drills may help students build a firm feel for a slip-prone topic.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Sergei Volodin, Hala Khodr, Pierre Dillenbourg, Wafa Johal |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 42 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-14562
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Going Down the Abstraction Stream with Augmented Reality and Tangible Robots: the Case of Vector Instruction Sergei Volodin, Hala Khodr, Pierre Dillenbourg, Wafa Johal Abstract Despite being used in many engineering and scientific areas such as physics and mathematics and often taught in high school, graphical vector addition turns out to be a topic prone to misconceptions in understanding even at university-level physics classes. To improve the learning experience and the resulting understanding of vectors, we propose to investigate how concreteness fading implemented with the use of augmented reality and tangible robots could help learners to build a strong representation of vector addition. We design a gamified learning environment consisting of three concreteness fading stages and conduct an experiment with 30 participants. Our results shows a positive learning gain. We analyze extensively the behavior of the participants to understand the usage of the technological tools – augmented reality and tangible robots – during the learning scenario. Finally, we discuss how the combination of these tools shows real advantages in implementing the concreteness fading paradigm. Our work provides empirical insights into how users utilize concrete visualizations conveyed by a haptic-enabled robot and augmented reality in a learning scenario. August 24, 2026 Figure 1: Activity Flow. The main working sheet (shown as C) contains 10 game levels located across a river (labeled A, B, …, I) on the working sheet. For each of the levels, participants need to set the correct velocity to reach the gold (yellow circles with gold plates on the main working sheet). The velocity is set on a separate paper sheet (shown in A). The participant grabs the robot with their hand and moves it in the direction they want to set. The direction is shown in AR (below as a green arrow). Next, the robot is placed at the starting point (dock) of the level (shown in B), and the robot moves in the direction determined by the velocity, and also by the wind and the river’s current. The tablet screens below the main sheet show the three stages of concreteness fading. 1 Introduction Graphical vector addition is studied in high-school and college, and it is a crucial component to understanding many scientific and engineering concepts, such as addition of velocities and forces in Physics, or geometrical computations in Computer Vision. Classically, a vector is characterized by two components: a magnitude and a direction (including both sense/sign and orientation). Despite being used in so many aspects of physics and mathematics, the studies show that it is difficult for college students to solve simple problems ( Knight, 1995 ) related to vector addition. Several studies showed that there are certain misconceptions or incorrect ideas that persist even after learning about vector addition ( Nguyen and Meltzer, 2003 ; Wutchana and Emarat, 2011 ) . While investigating students’ understanding of scalar multiplication of a vector, Barniol and Zavala (2012) identified several common mistakes, such as selecting an opposite direction, giving an incorrect magnitude or having issues with translating the vector to add them. In addition, studying mathematics in general results sometimes in "mathematical anxiety" ( Hembree, 1990 ; Wikipedia, 2021 ) , which could suggest that abstract concepts are difficult to learn, psychologically speaking. Hembree (1990) suggest that higher achievement can help students with mathematical anxiety. We see the problems with studying vector addition as arising from mathematics being taught in a non-intuitive or too abstract way. It means that the rules of vector addition are not understood, and the concept is not grasped intuitively on simple examples ( Nguyen and Meltzer, 2003 ; Wutchana and Emarat, 2011 ) . Spiro (1988) have proposed to use multiple analogies to reduce the formation of domain-specific misconceptions and allow students to build more generic abstract models. Following this, presenting students with concrete simple examples could be a fruitful way to introduce abstract concepts such as graphical vector addition. This idea has been instantiated by the concreteness fading technique ( Fyfe et al., 2014 ) which proposes to give students concrete examples before moving on gradually to more abstract representations. Recent developments in augmented reality (AR) and robotics (i.e. cost reduction, robustness and reliability) allowed to introduce these technologies in multiple new settings into the classroom ( Akçayır and Akçayır, 2017 ; Xia and Zhong, 2018 ) . One of the examples of robotics platforms designed for education purposes is the Cellulo robot ( Özgür et al., 2017b ) , a small versatile robot usable as a single low cost device with a haptic interface ( Khodr et al., 2020 ) or within a swarm ( Özgür et al., 2018 ) of robots. In this paper, we propose to explore the use of Cellulo and Augmented Reality as a way to instantiate the concreteness fading approach. Because the concept of vectors can be challenging for students to learn and that it is important in mathematics and physics, we chose to design our use case around teaching vector additions to our students. The learning activity we designed uses concreteness fading as a way to introduce vector addition, from intuitive and simple examples to abstract graphical representations. In order to help with mathematical anxiety, the levels of our learning activity are designed to gradually increase in difficulty. In addition, we gamify the experience (such as, adding sounds for success and failure), and use toy-like 3D models inside the game, to make the learning less daunting. Additionally, the game is played in teams, in order to distribute the problem-solving between team members and make it easier from a psychological point of view as well. The principal goal of this research is to explore performances and usage of our technological tools (augmented reality and tangible robots) throughout the concreteness fading stages. 2 Related Works Figure 2: Illustration of concreteness fading. The physical/enactive representation refers to an actual moving ship. The pictorial/iconic representation refers to the notion of a moving ship, and the idealized/symbolic representation refers to the velocity vectors of the wind (brown), the river (blue) and the boat (green). Piaget’s theory of cognitive development explains that the different stages of learning involve various degrees of physical interaction, from sensorimotor stage in which children gain knowledge from physical interactions with the world, to formal operational stage which is characterised the ability to think and reason about abstract concepts Piaget (1970) . The use of concrete or abstract materials can both present benefits for learning. Concrete materials are grounded in perception-motor experience, allowing students to easily identify links between form and its referent which they can connect to prior knowledge. Abstract materials are arbitrarily links to the referents: simpler, more transferable and generalizable across contexts. Fyfe et al. (2014) proposes to move beyond the "abstract vs concrete" debates and to investigate how these two types of material could co-exist temporally through concreteness fading . Concreteness fading refers to a three steps progression leading to instantiate a notion from concrete/physical to abstract over time ( Fyfe and Nathan, 2019 ) (see Figure 2 ): 1. Enactive: physical, concrete model of the concept 2. Iconic: graphic, pictorial form of the concept 3. Symbolic: abstract model of the concept Concreteness Fading is adopting Bruner’s modes of representations: Concrete, Pictorial and