Environmental Monitoring Requirements for the ngVLA

T. K. Sridharan, Jeff Mangum & Bryan Butler · 2025

Read Environmental Monitoring Requirements for the ngVLA by T. K. Sridharan, Jeff Mangum & Bryan Butler (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-14451.txt.

Introduction

Sridharan and co-authors wrote a 2025 memo on weather checks for a planned large radio telescope array. Good telescope work needs close watch on the air around the dishes. The memo sets how exact those weather readings need to be. It builds on past guides for two older arrays and on a broad review of the topic.

The memo deals with the weather side of the site, not radio noise, safety, or buildings. Two weather effects get close care. One is the bend of signals as they pass through air, which shifts where a dish seems to point. The other is uneven delay in signal arrival across the array. Staff who plan and run the array can use the stated limits to pick sensors. The memo is a working guide, not a report of new sky data.

Catalog record

CREATORT. K. Sridharan, Jeff Mangum & Bryan Butler
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE22 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-14451

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Environmental Monitoring Requirements for the ngVLA T. K. Sridharan, Jeff Mangum & Bryan Butler Abstract Memo No. 115 1 Introduction Measurement of environmental parameters is one of the basic requirements for the proper operation of a telescope. Therefore, the subject has been addressed by several observatories. This memo is intended to provide guidance for the measurement accuracy requirements in the context of the ngVLA. It relies on previous work for the EVLA ( Butler & Perley 2008 ) and ALMA ( Mangum 2001 ) and a review of the subject by Mangum & Wallace 2015 . The local operational environment can be broadly divided into two categories: electromagnetic and physical. Meteorological parameters (weather) primarily constitute the physical environmental component and radio frequency interference (RFI) is the essential element of the electromagnetic environment. This memo focuses on the weather component and does not address the RFI, safety and physical infrastructure components. Under weather, the relevant topics are (1) the correction to pointing arising from refraction in the atmosphere (2) the different delays in the arrival times of signals at different antennas due to propagation in the atmosphere (3) monitoring weather parameters to provide operations support, e.g. in determining prevalence of precision or normal conditions, dynamic scheduling and the choice of antennas to constitute a sub-array with a given set of characteristics, among others, and (4) archival. Here we restrict ourselves to the first two topics which impact the data obtained and its calibration. 2 Pointing Sensitivity to Weather Closed form analytic expressions exist for the dependence of refraction correction to antenna pointing in elevation on surface temperature, pressure, and relative humidity at the location of the antenna (commonly used approximations of sufficient accuracy; reviews and references can be found in Mangum 2001 , Butler & Perley 2008 and Mangum & Wallace 2015 , and are not repeated here). To estimate the sensitivity of the pointing correction to weather, we take the approach of deriving the partial derivatives of these expressions with respect to the respective weather parameters. Starting from Mangum & Wallace 2015 (which also includes more information and citations to the origin of these equations), replacing R_{0} with \Delta z for the refraction correction (Equation 11) we have \Delta z=0.206265N_{0}(ppm)\tan{z_{o}}~\textrm{(arcsec)} (1) and for refractivity (Equation 66): {}^{Rueger}N^{rad}_{0} \displaystyle= \displaystyle 77.6890\frac{P_{d}}{T}+71.2952\frac{P_{w}}{T}+3.75463\times 10^{5}\frac{P_{w}}{T^{2}}~\textrm{(ppm)} (2) \displaystyle= \displaystyle 77.6890\frac{P}{T}-6.3938\frac{P_{w}}{T}+3.75463\times 10^{5}\frac{P_{w}}{T^{2}}~\textrm{(ppm)} where P_{d} is the partial pressure of dry gases in the atmosphere (in hPa), P_{w} is the partial pressure of water vapor (in hPa), P is the total barometric pressure (in hPa), which is equal to P_{d}+P_{w} , and T is the ambient air temperature (in Kelvin). z_{0} is the zenith angle of the observation {}^{Rueger}N^{rad}_{0} is the radio refractivity (Rueger formulation) While the calculations for ngVLA requirements do not need the number of significant digits included here for the various coefficients, we retain full precision for completeness. Noting that the total atmospheric pressure P must be measured by a barometer at the telescope site, P_{w} may be calculated from the expression: P_{w}=RH\frac{e_{sat}}{100} (3) where RH is the surface relative humidity (in percent) and e_{sat} is the surface saturated water vapour pressure (in hPa). There are two forms for e_{sat} that we can use. The first, from Crane 1976 (which is used by Butler & Perley 2008 ), is given by: \displaystyle e^{crane}_{sat} \displaystyle= \displaystyle 6.105\exp\left[25.22\left(\frac{T-273}{T}\right)-5.31\ln\left(\frac{T}{273}\right)\right]~\textrm{(hPa)} (4) \displaystyle= \displaystyle 6.105\left(\frac{T}{273}\right)^{-5.31}\exp\left[25.22\left(\frac{T-273}{T}\right)\right]~\textrm{(hPa)}. A second expression commonly used is given by Buck 1981 (Equation C1 in Mangum & Wallace 2015 ): e^{buck}_{sat}=\left(1.0007+3.46\times 10^{-6}P\right)6.1121\exp\left[\frac{17.502\left(T-273.15\right)}{T-32.18}\right]~\textrm{(hPa)}. (5) The difference between the Crane 1976 and Buck 1981 formalisms for e_{sat} is \lesssim 1 % over the range of surface pressure and temperature from 500 to 1000 mb and 255 to 300 K, respectively, appropriate for the ngVLA. In the following we will use the Buck 1981 formalism for e_{sat} . We now derive the partial derivatives of Equation 1 with respect to the respective weather parameters. We start with the partial derivative with respect to total pressure P . Noting that P_{w}=P-P_{d} and that P_{d}\gg P_{w} , so that \frac{\partial P_{d}}{\partial P}\sim 1 and \frac{\partial P_{w}}{\partial P}\ll 1 , only the first term in Equation 2 is retained: \displaystyle\frac{\partial{\Delta z}}{\partial{P}} \displaystyle= \displaystyle 0.206265\tan{z_{o}}\left(\frac{77.6890}{T}\right)~\textrm{(arcsec)} (6) \displaystyle\simeq \displaystyle\left(\frac{16.024}{T}\right)\tan{z_{o}}~\textrm{(arcsec)} where we have ignored the insignificant dependence of e_{sat} on the pressure P . Figure 1 shows Equation 6 for a representative range of ground temperatures. The partial derivative with respect to relative humidity RH (in percent) requires substitution of Equation 3 into Equation 2 : \displaystyle\frac{\partial{\Delta z}}{\partial{RH}} \displaystyle= \displaystyle 0.206265\tan{z_{o}}\left(\frac{77.6890e^{buck}_{sat}}{100T}-\frac{6.3938e^{buck}_{sat}}{100T}+\frac{3.75463\times 10^{5}e^{buck}_{sat}}{100T^{2}}\right)~\textrm{(arcsec)} (7) \displaystyle\simeq \displaystyle\tan{z_{o}}\left(\frac{0.160e^{buck}_{sat}}{T}-\frac{0.013e^{buck}_{sat}}{T}+\frac{774.45e^{buck}_{sat}}{T^{2}}\right)~\textrm{(arcsec)} \displaystyle\simeq \displaystyle\tan{z_{o}}\left(\frac{0.147e^{buck}_{sat}}{T}+\frac{774.45e^{buck}_{sat}}{T^{2}}\right)~\textrm{(arcsec)} with e^{buck}_{sat} given by Equation 5 . There is a negligibly weak dependence of the partial derivative on pressure through e^{buck}_{sat} . Figure 2 shows Equation 7 for a representative range of ground temperatures and pressures. Figure 1: Refraction correction dependence on ground pressure (Equation 6 ) per mbar for a representative range of ground temperatures T and observing elevations. The temperature range for precision conditions is marked. The required pointing correction accuracy of < 0.5 ′′ (Section 3 ) is outside the box and can be met with a 4.5 mbar pressure measurement accuracy for elevations > 30 ∘ Figure 2: Refraction correction dependence on ground relative humidity (Equation 7 ), per 1% for a representative range of ground temperatures T , pressures P (whose effect is not discernible) and observing elevations. The temperature range for precision conditions is marked. The required pointing correction accuracy of < 0.5 ′′ shown (section 3 ) can be met with a 1% relative humidity measurement accuracy for elevations > 30 ∘ Finally, the partial derivative with respect to temperature T (in Kelvin) is a bit more complicated to derive as both N_{0} and P_{w} (through the temperature dependence in e^{buck}_{sat} ) have dependencies on T : \displaystyle\frac{\partial{\Delta z}}{\partial{T}} \displaystyle= \displaystyle 0.206265\tan{z_{o}}\left[\frac{\partial}{\partial{T}}\left(77.6890\frac{P_{d}}{T}\right)+\frac{\partial}{\partial{T}}\left(71.2952\frac{P_{w}}{T}\right)+\frac{\partial}{\partial{T}}\left(3.75463\times 10^{5}\frac{P_{w}}{T^{2}}\right)\right] (8) \displaystyle\simeq \displaystyle\tan{z_{o}}\left[\frac{\partial}{\partial{T}}\left(16.02\frac{P_{d}}{T}\right)+\frac{\partial}{\partial{T}}\left(14.71\frac{P_{w}}{T}\right)+\frac{\partial}{\partial{T}}\left(7.74\times 10^{4}\frac{P_{w}}{T^{2}}\right)\right]~\textrm{(arcsec)} The derivative of the second term in Equation 8 is given by: \displaystyle\frac{\partial}{\partial{T}}\left(14.71\frac{P_{w}}{T}\right) \displaystyle= \displaystyle 14.71\left(\frac{T\frac{\partial}{\partial{T}}\left(RH\frac{e^{buck}_{sat}}{100}\right)-RH\frac{e^{buck}_{sat}}{100}}{T^{2}}\right) (9) \displaystyle= \displaystyle 0.1471RH\left(\frac{T\frac{\partial{e^{buck}_{sat}}}{\partial{T}}-e^{buck}_{sat}}{T^{2}}\right) with the partial derivative of e_{sat} with respect to T given by: \displaystyle\frac{\partial{e^{buck}_{sat}}}{\partial{T}} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\left(1.0007+3.46\times 10^{-6}P\right)6.1121\exp\left(\frac{17.502\left(T-273.15\right)}{T-32.18}\right)\left(\frac{4217.46}{(T-32.18)^{2}}\right) (10) \displaystyle= \displaystyle\frac{4217.46}{(T-32.18)^{2}}e^{buck}_{sat}~\textrm{(hPa)}. The derivative of the third term in Equation 8 is given by: \displaystyle\frac{\partial}{\partial{T}}\left(7.74\times 10^{4}\frac{P_{w}}{T^{2}}\right) \displaystyle= \displaystyle 7.74\times 10^{4}\left(\frac{T^{2}\frac{\partial}{\partial{T}}\left(RH\frac{e^{buck}_{sat}}{100}\right)-2TRH\frac{e^{buck}_{sat}}{100}}{T^{4}}\right) (11) \displaystyle= \displaystyle 774RH\left(\frac{T\frac{\partial{e^{buck}_{sat}}}{\partial{T}}-2e^{buck}_{sat}}{T^{3}}\right) with the partial derivative of e_{sat} with respect to T given by Equation 10 . Combining Equations 9 and 11 into Equation 8 we find: \displaystyle\frac{\partial{\Delta z}}{\partial{T}} \displaystyle\simeq \displaystyle\tan{z_{o}}\left[-16.02\frac{P_{d}}{T^{2}}+0.1471RH\left(\frac{T\frac{\partial{e^{buck}_{sat}}}{\partial{T}}-e^{buck}_{sat}}{T^{2}}\right)+774RH\left(\frac{T\frac{\partial{e^{buck}_{sat}}}{\partial{T}}-2e^{buck}_{sat}}{T^{3}}\right)\right] \displaystyle\simeq \displaystyle\tan{z_{o}}\left[\frac{-16.02}{T^{2}}\left(P-P_{w}\right)+0.1471RH\left(\frac{T\frac{\partial{e^{buck}_{sat}}}{\partial{T}}-e^{buck}_{sat}}{T^{2}}\right)+774RH\left(\frac{T\frac{\partial{e^{buck}_{sat}}}{\partial{T}}-2e_{sat}}{T^{3}}\right)\right] \displaystyle\simeq \displaystyle\frac{-16.02\tan{z_{o}}}{T^{2}}\left[\left(P-P_{w}\right)-0.009RH\left(T\frac{\partial{e^{buck}_{sat}}}{\partial{T}}-e^{buck}_{sat}\right)-48.31RH\left(\frac{T\frac{\partial{e^{buck}_{sat}}}{\partial{T}}-2e^{buck}_{sat}}{T}\right)\right]~\textrm{(arcsec)} with P_{w} and the derivative of e^{buck}_{sat} with respect to T given by Equations 3 and 10 , respectively. Figure 3 shows Equation for a representative range of ground temperatures and pressures. As a check of this derivation we have verified numerical agreement between these expressions and the computational results for specific cases presented in Mangum 2001 for ALMA, where we find agreement to <0.03^{\prime\prime} . We also find them to be consistent with the results of a numerical variational analysis presented in Butler & Perley 2008 for the EVLA. These expressions are used below to determine the accuracies to which the weather parameters need to be measured. As can be seen, the sensitivities for humidity and pressure only depend on temperature and the temperature sensitivity depends on all three weather parameters. The functional dependence of all sensitivities on elevation

Read the complete text