Seeing Through Risk: A Symbolic Approximation of Prospect Theory
Ali Arslan Yousaf 1 , Umair Rehman 2 , Muhammad Umair Danish 3 · 2025
Read Seeing Through Risk: A Symbolic Approximation of Prospect Theory by Ali Arslan Yousaf 1 , Umair Rehman 2 , Muhammad Umair Danish 3 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-14448.txt.
Introduction
Ali Arslan Yousaf, Umair Rehman, and Muhammad Umair Danish propose a new way to model risky choices in this 2025 arXiv paper. The classic account, prospect theory, explains why people fear losses more than they value gains. But its smooth curves are hard to read, and its inner parts stay hidden from the user.
The authors swap those curves for plain features guided by effect sizes, so each part of the model maps to a named habit of mind. They set out the math, show the model copies known effects like framing and loss aversion, and test it on synthetic data. Scores stay close to those of less clear models. Readers in economics, policy, and AI safety get a model of risk they can inspect and explain.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Ali Arslan Yousaf 1 , Umair Rehman 2 , Muhammad Umair Danish 3 |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 18 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-14448
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Seeing Through Risk: A Symbolic Approximation of Prospect Theory Ali Arslan Yousaf 1 , Umair Rehman 2 , Muhammad Umair Danish 3 Abstract We propose a novel symbolic modeling framework for decision-making under risk that merges interpretability with the core insights of Prospect Theory. Our approach replaces opaque utility curves and probability weighting functions with transparent, effect-size-guided features. We mathematically formalize the method, demonstrate its ability to replicate well-known framing and loss-aversion phenomena, and provide an end-to-end empirical validation on synthetic datasets. The resulting model achieves competitive predictive performance while yielding clear coefficients mapped onto psychological constructs, making it suitable for applications ranging from AI safety to economic policy analysis. [email protected], {urehman6, mdanish3}@uwo.ca I Introduction Expected Utility Theory (EUT) [ 1 , 2 ] has historically served as the cornerstone of economic and game-theoretic choice models under uncertainty. However, a wealth of experimental evidence reveals consistent violations of EUT, including preference reversals, framing effects, and risk asymmetries [ 3 , 4 ] . These observations motivated alternative frameworks such as Prospect Theory (PT) [ 5 ] and its cumulative variant [ 6 ] , which integrate psychological factors (loss aversion, probability distortion) into the utility calculation [ 7 ] . While PT has strong empirical support, its practical deployment encounters two major hurdles [ 8 ] . First, structural estimation of PT can be complex, relying on nonlinear utility and weighting functions that can be computationally fragile and difficult to interpret [ 9 ] . Second, black-box machine learning models used for risk classification often lack the psychological grounding and interpretability required in high-stakes domains such as healthcare, finance, and AI safety [ 10 ] . Thus, a gap remains for cognitively faithful and computationally tractable models. In this paper, we present a symbolic prospect-theoretic approach, which approximates the core mechanisms of PT through a logistic decision equation defined on interpretable features (e.g., frame , certainty , probability_level , magnitude ). We further propose an effect-size-guided method for feature selection, ensuring that each symbolic feature retained has a statistically measurable impact on choice behavior. This hybrid strategy achieves: • Interpretability: Each coefficient directly corresponds to a Prospect Theory construct (framing, probability distortion, etc.). • Data efficiency: Incorporating only behaviorally relevant features avoids over-parameterization in utility curves. • Robustness: Using effect-size thresholds makes the model more parsimonious and stable. Empirical simulations on synthetic datasets demonstrate that our model reproduces key PT phenomena, including loss aversion, reflection effects, and overweighting of rare events. We also compare it against: 1. a classical Cumulative Prospect Theory estimator and 2. a standard logistic classifier lacking symbolic features. Our results highlight strong predictive performance and a high degree of alignment with established behavioral regularities. II Background and Related Work This section will describe Prospect Theory essentials, symbolic AI, Interpretability, and Effect-Size-Guided feature selection. II-A Prospect Theory Essentials Prospect Theory (PT) [ 11 , 12 ] posits that agents evaluate outcomes relative to a reference point r , categorizing outcomes as gains ( x\geq r ) or losses ( x<r ). The value function v(x) is typically concave for gains, convex for losses, and steeper in the loss domain (loss aversion) [ 13 ] . Additionally, PT includes a probability weighting function \pi(p) that distorts probabilities, commonly overweighting small p and underweighting large p [ 5 , 6 ] . Formally, a lottery L with outcomes \{(x_{i},p_{i})\}_{i=1}^{n} has PT-utility: V(L)=\sum_{i=1}^{n}\pi(p_{i})\,v(x_{i}-r). (1) Various parametric forms exist for v(\cdot) (e.g., piecewise power) and \pi(\cdot) (e.g., Prelec). Estimating these from data can be sensitive and prone to local optima [ 9 , 14 ] . II-B Symbolic AI and Interpretability Symbolic approaches to AI emphasize transparency by encoding domain knowledge in rules, logic, or algebraic form [ 15 , 16 ] . Unlike neural networks, symbolic models enable direct interpretation of parameters, facilitating trust and auditability [ 17 , 18 ] in domains where decisions require clear justification (e.g., medical diagnostics, policy-making) [ 17 , 19 ] . II-C Effect-Size-Guided Feature Selection In standard ML, feature selection often relies on large datasets or black-box methods [ 20 , 21 ] . By contrast, effect-size metrics (Cramér’s V , \eta^{2} , point-biserial correlation) quantify how strongly a feature correlates with the outcome [ 22 , 18 ] . We use such metrics to decide which symbolic features are behaviorally relevant before fitting a logistic equation, ensuring that each retained feature has demonstrable predictive utility [ 20 ] . III Symbolic Modeling Framework This section will describe symbolic feature definition, logistic equation [ 23 ] , effect-size thresholding, parameter estimation, and synthetic data generation. III-A Symbolic Feature Definition Let D_{i} index a binary decision (0 = safe, 1 = risky). We define a set of interpretable features X_{i}=(x_{i1},\dots,x_{id}) , each aligned to a known behavioral phenomenon in PT [ 21 ] . Examples include: • frame {}_{i}\in\{-1,+1\} : gain vs. loss context. • certainty {}_{i}\in\{0,1\} : indicates a sure option. • prob_level {}_{i}\in\{0,1\} : indicates a small-probability event ( p<0.2 ). • magnitude {}_{i}\in\mathbb{R} : a scaled difference in payoffs. • dominance {}_{i}\in\{0,1\} : whether one option stochastically dominates the other. The target label is y_{i}\in\{0,1\} , with 1 denoting choosing the risky option. III-B Symbolic Logistic Equation We posit a latent utility: U_{i}=\beta_{0}+\sum_{j=1}^{d}\beta_{j}\,x_{ij}+\epsilon_{i}, (2) where \epsilon_{i} is logistic noise. The probability of risky choice is: \mathbb{P}(y_{i}=1)=\sigma(\beta^{\top}X_{i}),\quad\text{where }\sigma(z)=\frac{1}{1+e^{-z}}. (3) III-C Effect-Size Thresholding To avoid extraneous or weak features, we compute effect sizes for each candidate x_{j} : S(x_{j})=\begin{cases}\text{Cram\'{e}r’s }V(x_{j},y),&x_{j}\text{ categorical},\\ \eta^{2}(x_{j},y),&x_{j}\text{ continuous}.\end{cases} (4) We include only x_{j} with S(x_{j})\geq\tau . This ensures the final feature set is both cognitively plausible and empirically relevant. III-D Parameter Estimation Given the filtered X_{i} , we fit \beta via maximum likelihood: \hat{\beta}=\arg\max_{\beta}\sum_{i=1}^{N}\Bigl[y_{i}\ln\sigma(\beta^{\top}X_{i})+(1-y_{i})\ln\bigl(1-\sigma(\beta^{\top}X_{i})\bigr)\Bigr]. (5) Standard software (e.g., scikit-learn ) handles optimization and provides variance estimates for \beta . IV Empirical Simulations and Validation Results In this section, we evaluate our symbolic prospect-theoretic framework on synthetically generated decision data. We compare three models: 1. Symbolic Logistic Model: interpretable, effect-size–guided features, 2. Black-box Logistic Model: raw numeric inputs without interpretive constraints, 3. Parametric CPT Model: classical Prospect Theory with a piecewise power value function and a probability weighting function, fitted by maximum likelihood. Our key objectives are to measure: (i) predictive performance, (ii) ability to capture Prospect Theory behaviors (e.g., framing), and (iii) interpretability. IV-A Synthetic Data Generation We simulate N=5000 binary choice scenarios, each with: • a safe payoff S_{i}\in[0,100] , • a risky payoff R_{i}\in[0,150] with probability p_{i}\in[0.1,0.9] , • symbolic features, e.g., frame \in\{-1,+1\} , low_prob =\mathbb{I}[p_{i}<0.2] , dominance =\mathbb{I}[p_{i}R_{i}>S_{i}] , and so on. We define a “true” latent utility for choosing the risky option as: \displaystyle U_{i} \displaystyle=\beta_{0}+\beta_{1}(\texttt{frame}_{i})+\beta_{2}(\texttt{low\_prob}_{i})+\beta_{3}(\texttt{magnitude}_{i}) \displaystyle\quad+\beta_{4}(\texttt{dominance}_{i}). (6) The observed choice y_{i}\in\{0,1\} (with 1 denoting “risky”) is drawn from \displaystyle y_{i} \displaystyle\sim\mathrm{Bernoulli}\bigl(\sigma(U_{i})\bigr),\quad\sigma(z)=\frac{1}{1+e^{-z}}. (7) We split data into 80% train and 20% test. IV-B Model Specifications We compare three decision models: 1. Symbolic Logistic Model, which uses Prospect‑Theory–grounded features; 2. Black‑box Logistic Model, trained on raw payoffs and probabilities; and 3. Parametric CPT Model, employing classical value and weighting functions. Common Notation. For each trial i : • Safe payoff: S_{i} , • Risky payoff: R_{i} , • Win probability: p_{i}\in(0,1) , • Frame: \mathrm{frame}_{i}\in\{-1,+1\} ( +1 = gain , -1 = loss ),