Corrections of the GR eikonal limit by a class of renormalizable gravity models
Leandro Lanosa, Osvaldo P. Santillán · 2025
Read Corrections of the GR eikonal limit by a class of renormalizable gravity models by Leandro Lanosa, Osvaldo P. Santillán (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-14434.txt.
Introduction
Leandro Lanosa and Osvaldo Santillán test gravity tweaks in a fast particle limit in a 2025 paper. The eikonal limit covers a light particle glancing off a heavy one, a classic route to gravity formulas. The pair place that clash inside renormalizable gravity models with higher derivative terms.
If a new gravity scale sits well below the Planck mass, the plain relativity formulas gain a changed factor. The terms of the approximation then need a fresh check, which the text gives. Next order terms, often zero in plain relativity, turn out nonzero here. A stated regularization scheme, built on Riesz and Hadamard steps, tames the loose ends.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Leandro Lanosa, Osvaldo P. Santillán |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 154 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-14434
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Corrections of the GR eikonal limit by a class of renormalizable gravity models Leandro Lanosa, Osvaldo P. Santillán Abstract In the present work, the scattering between a light scalar particle ϕ \phi and a heavy scalar σ \sigma in the eikonal limit is considered, for gravity scenarios containing higher order derivatives, such as the ones studied in [ 1 ] - [ 6 ] . It is suggested that if one of the new gravity scales introduced in the higher order action is smaller than the Planck mass, for instance of the order of M G U T ∼ 10 15 M_{GUT}\sim 10^{15} GeV, the functional form of the GR eikonal formulas appears changed by a factor. However, in this situation, the conditions for the eikonal approximation to hold has to be revised, this issue is analyzed in the text. The statements of the present work should be taken with a grain of salt, as the Schwarzschild radius for these polynomials theories is not yet established. The results presented here, in our opinion, are in agreement with the suppression of corrections to GR pointed out in [ 95 ] , [ 108 ] and [ 112 ] for the Stelle gravity. The next to leading order approximation and part of the seagull diagrams are estimated. Different to the GR case, this order generically is non vanishing. An explicit regularization scheme is presented, based on Riesz and Hadamard procedures. The need of a regularization is partially expected, as the inclusion of small energy fluctuations may spoil the eikonal approximation. 1. Introduction The study of effective field quantum theories of gravity beyond GR is one of the main topics of theoretical physics. There exist renormalizable theories of gravity, such as the Stelle ones [ 1 ] - [ 2 ] or the super-renormalizable ones presented in [ 3 ] - [ 6 ] and [ 7 ] , which improve the bad perturbative behavior of GR, at the price of accepting apparent instabilities [ 8 ] . The main argument of [ 8 ] is that a theory with classical fourth order equations of motion may improve the bad power counting that GR has at perturbative level. The propagator of such fourth order theory will be given in a Pauli Villars form as D\sim\frac{1}{k^{2}}-\frac{1}{k^{2}+M^{2}}. It is a simple exercise to see that for large values of k this propagator will go as M^{2}k^{-4} . In QFT without gravity, the mass M is interpreted as a cutoff, which tends M\to\infty at the end of the calculations. In the gravity approach, this cutoff is rendered finite, and the minus sign suggests the presence of a state with negative kinetic energy, which may indicate a potential instability. However, there exist several references suggesting that these instabilities may be avoided. An incomplete list is [ 9 ] - [ 23 ] and the references therein. These works suggest that the problem of the apparent instabilities may be solved by employing variants of the quantization method, some of them with roots at the Pauli and Dirac days. Those approaches are of clear interest. A first question that arises is that, if one starts with a theory whose classical formulation is unstable, and becomes stable after quantization, which type of classical limit it leads to. Clearly, the study of classical or semi-classical limits of renormalizable theories of gravity, with or without the prescriptions given in [ 9 ] - [ 23 ] , is of interest in this context. After the appearance of pioneer works [ 24 ] - [ 30 ] about the eikonal approximation in QFT, besides the fundamental works about QCD reviewed in [ 31 ] - [ 33 ] , a large number of applications in gravity theories were found, even beyond the Planck scale [ 34 ] - [ 38 ] . The work in [ 39 ] presents a link between classical and quantum aspects for horizon formation in black holes, and this line was further studied in several works such as [ 44 ] - [ 49 ] . In addition, in recent years, new semi classical methods for effective field theories for studying compact binaries were reported in several papers [ 53 ] - [ 58 ] , detailed reviews can be found in [ 50 ] - [ 60 ] and references therein. Semiclassical methods for modified gravity theories have been considered, for instance, in [ 61 ] - [ 72 ] and also in [ 73 ] - [ 74 ] . More recently, the study of particle creations inside the so named Page time interval [ 75 ] - [ 80 ] near a black hole horizon, which may throw light on the information paradox problem and the nature of gravitational collapse, was studied by the use of these tools. Furthermore, eikonal methods were applied recently in order to characterize the gravitational wave spectrum that is obtained after a collision between two particles takes place [ 86 ] . Modern references covering these aspects are [ 82 ] - [ 93 ] . The eikonal limit was employed also in [ 94 ] - [ 99 ] to the study of causality issues in gravity theories. The present work deals with the eikonal limit of the gravitational models of [ 3 ] - [ 6 ] . There exist several types of eikonal limits in the literature, some are related to scattering of massless particles with high center of mass energy, and others study scattering between a extremely heavy and a extremely light particle. This second situation will be considered here, and the corrections to the Shapiro time delay and angle deflection will be partially estimated. In addition, the validity of the eikonal limit is analyzed and the lower bounds for the value of the energy of the center of mass \sqrt{s} are discussed. The exact bounds are based on the dependence of the generalized Schwarzschild radius for the theory. The explicit black hole solutions are not known for gravity theories with higher order derivatives, even though some hints of them can be seen in [ 100 ] - [ 102 ] . The present work is organized as follows. In section 2 the general situation to be analyzed is described, and some eikonal identities that are useful are summarized. In section 3 the gravity models under consideration are described in some detail, and the effective coupling constants of the problem are identified. These couplings describe the strength of the gravitational interaction for these models. In section 4 the eikonal approximation for the above mentioned scattering is worked out, together with a description of the validity of such approximation. Section 5 contains some considerations for specific gravity models. Section 6 describes the next to leading order and seagull approximations for these models. Section 7 contains a discussion about the obtained results and new perspectives related to them. 2. Generalities about the problem The aim of the present work is the study of gravitational scattering between an ultra energetic light (almost massless) scalar particle \phi of energy E_{\phi} and an extremely heavy, almost static, scalar particle \sigma of mass M_{\sigma} . It is assumed that the