General Shells and Generalized Functions

Albert Huber · 2025

Read General Shells and Generalized Functions by Albert Huber (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-14402.txt.

Introduction

Albert Huber rebuilds in 2025 the mathematics of thin shells, the razor-thin layers of matter that general relativity uses to model surfaces like a collapsing star's skin or a wormhole's throat. The classic formalism manipulates distributions, spiky mathematical objects whose products are not always defined, which breaks exactly the nonlinear calculations shells demand.

Huber switches the foundation to Colombeau's generalized functions, where smoothed versions of steps and spikes can be multiplied safely. The extended formalism then handles shell problems that defeat the conventional one. It is foundational work, the kind that quietly widens what a whole field can compute.

Catalog record

CREATORAlbert Huber
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE63 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-14402

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

General Shells and Generalized Functions Albert Huber Abstract In this work, standard methods of the mixed thin-shell foramlism are refined using the framework of Colombeau’s theory of generalized functions. To this end, systematic use is made of smooth generalized functions, in particular regularizations of the Heaviside step function and the delta distribution, instead of working directly with the corresponding Schwartz distributions. Based on this change of method, the resulting extended thin shell formalism is shown to offer a decisive advantage over traditional approaches to the subject: it avoids dealing with ill-defined products of distributions in the calculation of nonlinear curvature expressions, thereby allowing for the treatment of problems that prove intractable with the ’conventional’ thin-shell formalism. This includes, in particular, the problem of matching singular spacetimes with distributional metrics (containing a delta distribution term) across a joint boundary hypersurface in spacetime, the problem of setting up the dominant energy condition for thin shells, and the problem of defining reasonably rigorously nonlinear distribution-valued curvature invariants needed in higher-derivative theories of gravity. Eventually, as a further application, close links to Penrose’s cut-and-paste method are established by proving that results of said method can be re-derived using the generalized formalism presented. Key words: Colombeau algebras, generalized functions, thin shell formalism, gluing methods; Introduction The thin-shell formalism has proven time and again to be an indispensable asset in many relativists’ toolkits [ 7 , 11 , 25 , 42 , 49 ] . This is not least due to the fact that said formalism provides powerful methods for gluing together spacetime partitions across a joint boundary hypersurface and, at the same time, the necessary junction conditions for such gluing. On top of that, the formalism enables the construction of novel weak (distributional) solutions of Einstein’s gravitational field equations, which arise naturally whenever pairs of spacetimes cannot be glued together smoothly. All these solutions have one thing in common: they lead to thin shells of matter concentrated on joint portion of the boundary hypersurface (or on a series of non-overlapping hypersurfaces) in spacetime. As such, they are typically invoked for the physical description of infinitesimally thin concentrations of massless particles, plane-fronted impulsive (pp) waves or other types of confined singular gravitational fields [ 3 , 4 , 7 ] . Mathematically, due to their singular nature, thin shells must be treated within the framework of linear distribution theory. At first glance, this seems to be bad news: after all, Einstein’s theory of gravity is a non-linear theory that requires the possiblity of multiplying distributions at the same spacetime point. According to Schwartz’s impossibility result [ 54 ] , however, the latter proves impossible, thus prompting the question of whether non-smooth gluings of spacetimes can be meaningfully treated in Einstein-Hilbert gravity at all. Yet, as is well known, the matter is not as bad as it looks at first sight: By systematically imposing junction conditions on the first and second fundamental forms of the spacetimes to be glued (or on tensorial quantities closely related to these quantities), the mentioned problems can be brought under control to a reasonable extent. This is because the imposed conditions ensure that the correction terms arising in the spacetime curvature and Einstein’s field equations at most proportional to the Dirac delta distribution, but not to its derivatives. As a consequence, the method used yields mathematically perfectly well-defined tensor distributions and associated locally singular solutions to the field equations in the presence of a non-smooth gluing of spacetime partitions across their joint boundary hypersurface; provided at least that the spacetime metrics to be glued are smooth and minimally twice differentiable. And even if everything thus appears to be perfectly in order with the formalism mentioned, there are still some serious shortcomings that should clearly be remedied, but which have not yet been addressed in the literature. Among these shortcomings is, for example, the issue that matching singular spacetimes with metrics of low regularity (such as, in particular, C^{1,1} -Lorentzian metrics) still proves impossible with traditional methods of the theory of thin shells. Furthermore, there is the problem that nonlinear curvature expressions cannot be meaningfully calculated with same formalism, since such calculations result in ill-defined products of delta distributions that cannot be defined with conventional linear distribution theory. Said products are encountered, for example, in setting up the dominant energy condition or in calculating the Kretschmann scalar for checking the singularity structure of spacetime. Also, they are ubiquitous in higher-derivative theories of gravity in which non-smooth gluings of spacetimes are considered [ 51 , 56 , 57 , 58 ] . Another shortcoming of the thin-shell formalism is that (in its present formulation) it does not allow for the derivation of familiar solutions of Einstein’s field equations for confined matter fields that can be obtained with closely related gluing methods. In particular, one would expect the thin-shell formalism to be closely related to Penrose’s cut-and-paste method, which is defined in terms of a metric with a Dirac delta distribution with support on the shell. Interesting types of geometries that have been constructed with this method are, most notably, gravitational shock wave spacetimes in flat Minkowski spacetime and in various black hole and cosmological backgrounds. This includes the geometries of Dray and ’t Hooft, Sfetsos, and other more recently derived types of gravitational shock waves in stationary axisymmetric black hole backgrounds [ 1 , 12 , 14 , 23 , 43 , 59 , 63 ] . While the problem of deriving such solutions by thin-shell methods is, as should be mentioned, treated in considerable detail in [ 39 , 40 ] , it appears that, apart from connections to Penrose’s original work and non-expanding impulsive gravitational waves in cosmological backgrounds, not too many results in that direction are known as of yet. To address this particular problem, as well as all other problems described so far, the strategy followed in this work is to incorporate Colombeau’s mathematical theory of generalized functions [ 9 , 10 , 15 , 16 , 17 , 18 , 27 , 28 , 29 , 31 , 61 , 62 ] into the gluing formalism used; culminating in a better tractable matching approach that includes the conventional thin-shell formalism as a special case. Though Colombeau algebras have previously been used in the literature on the subject, in particular in the context of signature-changing spacetimes [ 37 , 38 , 60 ] , no systematic approach seems to have yet been developed that attempts to overcome persistent mathematical shortcomings of the formalism by turning to algebras of generalized functions. To close this literature gap, the first section of this work presents a generalized matching approach that avoids the direct use of Schwartz distributions in joining metrics and curvature fields of local spacetime partitions in favor of using manifold-valued generalized functions (i.e., regularizations of the Heaviside step function and the delta distribution) that converge to these distributions in a suitable Colombeau limit. As only shown in section two of the article, this type of approach allows Lorentzian metrics of low regularity to be joined and, at the same time, to avoid ill-defined products of distributions (such as, in particular, ’squares of the delta distribution’) in the calculation of nonlinear curvature

Read the complete text