Exotic periodic phenomena in the cohomology of the moduli stack of 1 1 -dimensional formal group laws
Dan Isaksen, Hana Jia Kong, Guchuan Li, Yangyang Ruan, Heyi Zhu · 2025
Read Exotic periodic phenomena in the cohomology of the moduli stack of 1 1 -dimensional formal group laws by Dan Isaksen, Hana Jia Kong, Guchuan Li, Yangyang Ruan, Heyi Zhu (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-14383.txt.
Introduction
Daniel Isaksen and four co-authors describe new periodic patterns in algebraic topology in this two thousand twenty-five paper. Their object is the cohomology of the moduli stack of one-dimensional formal group laws. This object doubles as a page in the Adams-Novikov spectral sequence, a core tool of stable homotopy theory. Known periodic families, named for each prime height, structure much of that page. The authors uncover a different kind of repetition.
Their patterns stand apart from the familiar families and show striking number-theoretic traits. The tools come from a motivic version of the Adams spectral sequence. They also find matching patterns in complex-motivic stable homotopy. The paper is aimed at specialists in chromatic homotopy theory. It hints that the classical picture still hides structure.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Dan Isaksen, Hana Jia Kong, Guchuan Li, Yangyang Ruan, Heyi Zhu |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 124 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-14383
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Exotic periodic phenomena in the cohomology of the moduli stack of 1 1 -dimensional formal group laws Thanks: The first author was supported by NSF grant DMS-2202267. Dan Isaksen, Hana Jia Kong, Guchuan Li, Yangyang Ruan, Heyi Zhu Abstract . We describe some periodic structure in the cohomology of the moduli stack of 1-dimensional formal group laws, also known as the E 2 E_{2} -page of the classical Adams–Novikov spectral sequence. This structure is distinct from the familiar v n v_{n} -periodicities, and it displays interesting number-theoretic properties. Our techniques involve the ℂ \mathbb{C} -motivic Adams spectral sequence, and we obtain analogous periodic structure in ℂ \mathbb{C} -motivic stable homotopy. \KOMAoptions twoside=false 2020 Mathematics Subject Classification Primary 55T15, 14F42; Secondary 55Q51 1. Introduction This manuscript exclusively considers 2 -primary stable homotopy. In 1.2 , we describe some periodic families of non-trivial elements in \mathbb{C} -motivic stable homotopy. Along the way in 1.5 , we describe the corresponding periodic families of non-trivial elements in the cohomology of the moduli stack of 1-dimensional formal group laws, also known as the classical Adams–Novikov E_{2} -page. 1.1. The cohomology of the moduli stack of 1-dimensional formal group laws The moduli stack of 1-dimensional formal group laws is an object of interest in number theory. The cohomology of this moduli stack is also known as the Adams–Novikov E_{2} -page, which is of interest to homotopy theorists because it is an approximation to stable homotopy via the Adams–Novikov spectral sequence. The situation is well-illustrated by v_{1} -periodic homotopy. In stems congruent to 7 modulo 8, v_{1} -periodic homotopy is detected in the Adams–Novikov E_{2} -page in filtration 1 . (In stems congruent to 3 modulo 8, Adams–Novikov differentials and hidden extensions occur.) In other words, v_{1} -periodic homotopy is detected by the cohomology of the moduli stack of 1-dimensional formal group laws. This observation is intended to “explain” the appearance of number-theoretic structure in v_{1} -periodic homotopy. Following this logic, we should not be surprised to find other regular patterns in the Adams–Novikov E_{2} -page that also display number-theoretic structure. This manuscript describes such a regular pattern. Long experience shows that the information in the stable homotopy groups of spheres can be sorted into separate periodic families. It is a deep and central fact of classical stable homotopy theory that the only such 2 -primary periodicities are v_{n} for n\geq 0 . The traditional v_{n} -periodicities appear along horizontal lines in the Adams–Novikov E_{2} -page. However, the Adams–Novikov E_{2} -page possesses additional algebraic periodicities [ Kra18 ] . We study a particular family of elements in the Adams–Novikov E_{2} -page that exhibits an “exotic” periodicity. Our elements lie along lines of slope \frac{1}{5} in the Adams–Novikov E_{2} -page. 1.2. Motivation from topological modular forms One of the many roles of the topological modular forms spectrum \mathit{tmf} in stable homotopy theory is that it serves as a testing ground for computational methods and strategies. If a method computes the homotopy of \mathit{tmf} efficiently, then it is likely to be of use for the much more difficult sphere spectrum. The manuscript [ IKL+24 ] studies \mathit{tmf} , and also its \mathbb{C} -motivic analogue \mathit{mmf} , from a g -periodic perspective, where g is a particular element in the 20-stem. The g -periodic structure of \mathit{mmf} reveals certain information that is otherwise difficult to obtain. Therefore, we expect that a g -periodic perspective on the \mathbb{C} -motivic sphere is also interesting. In this manuscript, building on previous work of Michael Andrews [ And18 ] , we investigate g -periodic phenomena in the \mathbb{C} -motivic sphere spectrum. We find a very rich structure, analogous to the number-theoretically interesting v_{1} -periodic homotopy, but quantifiably distinct from v_{1} -periodic phenomena. In fact, our results only scratch the surface of a vastly more complicated structure. 1.3. w_{1} -periodicity Remarkably, \mathbb{C} -motivic stable homotopy theory possesses additional periodicities that are completely separate from the classical v_{n} -periodicities [ Kra18 ] [ Ghe17 ] . A chromatic approach to \mathbb{C} -motivic homotopy theory necessarily requires that we study these exotic periodicities. The first exotic periodicity is the Hopf map \eta , which is not nilpotent in \mathbb{C} -motivic homotopy theory. The \eta -periodic \mathbb{C} -motivic stable homotopy groups are now well-understood, both computationally [ GI15 ] [ AM17 ] and theoretically [ BH20 ] . The second exotic periodicity is w_{1} , and it is the subject of this manuscript. Note that g from Section 1.2 is the same as w_{1}^{4} . The goal of this manuscript is to describe a small portion of \mathbb{C} -motivic w_{1} -periodic homotopy that displays number-theoretically interesting properties. Michael Andrews predicted that \mathbb{C} -motivic w_{1} -periodic homotopy would be at least as complicated as classical v_{1} -periodic homotopy. Because \mathbb{C} -motivic \eta -periodicity is only slightly more complicated than classical 2 -periodicity, there is some hope that w_{1} -periodicity is only slightly more complicated than v_{1} -periodicity. Our results show a very large increase in computational difficulty from the v_{1} -periodic context to the w_{1} -periodic context. As of now, it is unrealistic to expect a complete description of the w_{1} -periodic homotopy of the \mathbb{C} -motivic sphere. 1.4. Some w_{1} -periodic homotopy The \mathbb{C} -motivic homotopy groups display w_{1} -periodic structure that is analogous to the well-known classical v_{1} -periodic structure. We refer the reader ahead to Section 4.1 for an explicit recollection of the classical v_{1} -periodic computations. The relationship of v_{1} to 2 is analogous to the relationship of w_{1} to \eta . For example, the classical cofiber of 2 possesses a v_{1}^{4} self-map, which leads to the familiar 8-fold periodicity of v_{1} -periodic homotopy. Analogously, the \mathbb{C} -motivic cofiber of \eta possesses a w_{1}^{4} self-map of degree (20,12) [ And18 ] , which leads to infinite families of \mathbb{C} -motivic stable homotopy elements whose bidegrees are in arithmetic progression with difference (20,12) . Here we grade \mathbb{C} -motivic stable homotopy groups by stem and motivic weight. However, the w_{1}^{4} self-map on S/\eta is only useful for producing w_{1} -periodic families that are annihilated by \eta . The most interesting parts of v_{1} -periodic homotopy consist of elements that are not annihilated by 2 . Analogously, there is much to say about \mathbb{C} -motivic w_{1} -periodic homotopy elements that are not annihilated by \eta . In this manuscript, we establish the existence of many w_{1} -periodic homotopy elements that are not annihilated by \eta . In order to summarize our results, we will refer to the motivic coweight, which is the difference of the stem and the weight. The coweight is relevant because \eta has coweight zero. Consequently, a homotopy element and its \eta multiple share a common coweight, while their stems and weights both differ by 1 . We describe non-zero \mathbb{C} -motivic stable homotopy elements in coweights that are congruent to 3 modulo 4. We start with one previously identified element in each coweight that is annihilated by \eta , and we divide by \eta multiple times to produce additional non-zero elements in the same coweight. This is analogous to starting with the unique non-zero 2 -torsion element in a cyclic v_{1} -periodic stable homotopy group, and then dividing by 2 repeatedly to determine