Bosonic Fortuity in Vector Models

Robert de Mello Koch, Animik Ghosh, Hendrik J.R. Van Zyl · 2025

Read Bosonic Fortuity in Vector Models by Robert de Mello Koch, Animik Ghosh, Hendrik J.R. Van Zyl (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-14181.txt.

Introduction

Robert de Mello Koch, Animik Ghosh, and Hendrik Van Zyl count the independent gauge-invariant operators in coupled matrix-vector quantum systems, in a physics paper from 2025. Such counting tells physicists the true degrees of freedom of a theory at finite size. Earlier work handled single matrix models; adding vectors changes the rules.

Using a classic integral formula, the team computed the partition function and sorted operators into primary and secondary invariants. Checks with trace relations confirmed the sets are complete. When the number of vector species stays at or below the matrix size, primaries alone freely generate the space. Beyond that, secondaries appear, born of trace relations. The authors derive how their number grows and suggest a bosonic cousin of the fortuity effect.

Catalog record

CREATORRobert de Mello Koch, Animik Ghosh, Hendrik J.R. Van Zyl
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE41 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-14181

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Bosonic Fortuity in Vector Models Robert de Mello Koch, Animik Ghosh, Hendrik J.R. Van Zyl Abstract We investigate the space of U ⁡ ( N ) U(N) gauge-invariant operators in coupled matrix-vector systems at finite N N , extending previous work on single matrix models. By using the Molien-Weyl formula, we compute the partition function and identify the structure of primary and secondary invariants. In specific examples we verify, using the trace relations, that these invariants do indeed generate the complete space of gauge invariant operators. For vector models with f ≤ N f\leq N species of vectors, the space is freely generated by primary invariants, while for f > N f>N , secondary invariants appear, reflecting the presence of nontrivial trace relations. We derive analytic expressions for the number of secondary invariants and explore their growth. These results suggest a bosonic analogue of the fortuity mechanism. Our findings have implications for higher-spin holography and gauge-gravity duality, with applications to both vector and matrix models. 1 Introduction The structure of the space of gauge invariant operators for the multi-matrix quantum mechanics of d matrices, at finite N , was recently considered in deMelloKoch:2025ngs . For a single matrix, this space is the ring generated by single traces containing no more than N matrices per trace. One might have expected a similar structure for multi-matrix models, but this naive expectation is incorrect. At finite N there is a complete set of generating invariants, which fall into two distinct categories: primary and secondary invariants. Primary invariants are algebraically independent and generate the ring freely, while secondary invariants satisfy quadratic relations. The number of primary invariants grows as \sim N^{2} which is much smaller that the exponentially larger growth of the secondary invariants \sim e^{cN^{2}} with c an order 1 constant. Although all single-trace operators with \leq N matrices appear among the generators, the generating set also includes invariants involving traces of more than N matrices. There is no sense in which traces of matrices with \leq N matrices represents a complete set. In constructing the space of gauge-invariant operators, the primary invariants act freely and can appear with arbitrary multiplicity, naturally giving rise to a Fock space structure. They are therefore best interpreted as perturbative degrees of freedom. In contrast, each secondary invariant can appear only once and enters linearly, resembling a fixed background. From this perspective, secondary invariants serve as non-perturbative backgrounds that can be populated by perturbative excitations. 1 1 1 As demonstrated explicitly in deMelloKoch:2025ngs , most secondary invariants involve O(N^{2}) fields. In the \frac{1}{2} -BPS sector of \mathcal{N}=4 super Yang–Mills theory, it is well known that under the AdS/CFT duality such operators correspond to new spacetime geometries Lin:2004nb . There are however some secondary invariants which involve only O(N) fields. These are best thought of as new states that need to be added to obtain a complete description of the Hilbert space. There is again a complete Fock space built on each of them. These gauge invariant operators are the collective fields in a collective field theory description Jevicki:1979mb ; deMelloKoch:2002nq . The results in deMelloKoch:2025ngs were obtained by computing exact finite- N partition functions using the Molien–Weyl formula. These partition functions take the form ( x=e^{-\beta} ) Z(x)=\frac{1+\sum_{i}c^{s}_{i}x^{i}}{\prod_{j}(1-x^{j})^{c^{m}_{j}}}, (1) which is precisely the structure predicted by the Hironaka decomposition sturmfels ; Grinstein:2023njq . In this decomposition, the denominator captures the contribution of primary invariants, while the numerator accounts for secondary invariants. Specifically, c^{m}_{j} counts the number of primary invariants constructed from j fields, and c^{s}_{i} counts the number of secondary invariants built from i fields. As N is increased, secondary invariants change their character and transition to become primary invariants. In the N=\infty limit all invariants are primary. This matches the fact that at infinite N there are no trace relations and the ring of gauge invariant operators is generated freely. Finite- N effects have also played a central role in recent developments in black hole microstate construction, particularly through the discovery of the fortuity mechanism Chang:2022mjp ; Choi:2022caq ; Choi:2023znd ; Chang:2023zqk ; Choi:2023vdm ; Chang:2024zqi . These \frac{1}{16} -BPS microstates fall into two classes: monotone and fortuitous. Monotone states preserve their BPS nature for all N , whereas fortuitous states cease to be BPS above a certain critical value of N . As a result, some states that appear as \frac{1}{16} -BPS microstates at a fixed N no longer qualify as microstates when N is increased. This breakdown is directly linked to trace relations, which play a crucial role in BPS saturation. Related discussions in the context of the SYK model and the D1–D5 system can be found in Chang:2024lxt ; Chang:2025rqy . A striking observation in deMelloKoch:2025ngs is that the growth in the number of secondary invariants at large N closely tracks the expected scaling of black hole entropy. This suggests a natural interpretation: secondary invariants may correspond to black hole microstates. Moreover, the promotion of secondary to primary invariants as N increases can be viewed as a purely bosonic analog of the fortuity mechanism. An interesting direction in which the results of deMelloKoch:2025ngs can be extended is the study of coupled matrix–vector models. As we explain in Section 2 , such models admit new types of gauge-invariant operator structures not present in purely matrix systems. In the context of gauge–gravity duality, this distinction reflects the fact that matrix models are expected to be dual to closed string theories, while coupled matrix–vector systems correspond to theories involving both open and closed strings. In this letter, we explore the structure of the space of gauge-invariant operators at finite N in coupled matrix–vector systems. In Section 2 , we derive the Molien–Weyl formula for the associated partition function. Section 3 examines a simple model with a single matrix and a single vector at N=2 , where we show how trace relations allow the full space of gauge-invariant operators to be reconstructed from the generating set. In Section 4 , we turn to purely vector models. We demonstrate that the number of primary invariants is f^{2} when f\leq N , and N^{2}+2N(f-N) when f>N . In the latter case, secondary invariants appear, and we present evidence suggesting that their number grows asymptotically as e^{2\log 2\,Nf} for large f . Section 5 analyzes the high-temperature limit of vector models, yielding an entropy S=f^{2}\log T for f\leq N , and S=\text{const}+(N^{2}+2N(f-N))\log T when f>N . Section 6 extends the analysis to matrix–vector models. Here, we show how trace relations imply that secondary invariants are quadratically reducible, and we begin to quantify the number of primary and secondary invariants required to generate the complete ring of gauge-invariant operators. Finally, Section 7 presents a discussion of our results and outlines potential directions for future research. 2 Partition Function Consider the free quantum mechanics of f complex vector fields \phi^{i}_{\alpha} , \phi^{i\dagger}_{\alpha} for i=1,2,\ldots,f , and d Hermitian matrix fields \Phi^{I}_{\alpha\beta} for I=1,2,\ldots,d , described by the action S=\int dt\sum_{i=1}^{f}\left(\partial_{t}\phi^{i\dagger}\cdot\partial_{t}\phi^{i}-\phi^{i\dagger}\cdot\phi^{i}\right)+\int dt\sum_{I=1}^{d}\mbox{Tr\,}\left(\partial_{t}\Phi^{I}\partial_{t}\Phi^{I}-\Phi^{I}\Phi^{I}\right), (2) where the “color” indices \alpha,\beta run over 1,2,\ldots,N . The model has a global U(N) symmetry, under which the fields transform as \phi^{i}_{\alpha}\to U_{\alpha\beta}\phi^{i}_{\beta},\qquad\phi^{i\dagger}_{\alpha}\to\phi^{i\dagger}_{\beta}U^{\dagger}_{\beta\alpha},\qquad\Phi^{I}_{\alpha\beta}\to U_{\alpha\gamma}\Phi^{I}_{\gamma\tau}U^{\dagger}_{\tau\beta}, (3) i.e. \phi^{i} is in the fundamental representation, \phi^{i\dagger} is in the anti-fundamental and \Phi^{I}

Read the complete text