A Binary Collision Method for Screened Coulomb Collisions in weakly and moderately coupled Plasmas
Justin Ray Angus, Johannes Johgan van de Wetering · 2025
Read A Binary Collision Method for Screened Coulomb Collisions in weakly and moderately coupled Plasmas by Justin Ray Angus, Johannes Johgan van de Wetering (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-14067.txt.
Introduction
Justin Ray Angus and Johannes van de Wetering wrote a 2025 physics paper on a computer method for collisions in plasmas. A plasma is a hot gas of charged particles, found in stars and fusion devices. Particles in a plasma constantly deflect each other through electric forces, an effect called Coulomb collisions.
Exact simulation of every encounter is too costly, so codes use statistical collision models. Their method pairs particles at random and applies a screened collision rule, valid when the plasma is weakly or moderately coupled. It matches the standard theory with first-order corrections and reduces to the classic method for small time steps. The code change is about ten lines, so existing simulation programs can adopt it easily.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Justin Ray Angus, Johannes Johgan van de Wetering |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 38 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-14067
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A Binary Collision Method for Screened Coulomb Collisions in weakly and moderately coupled Plasmas Justin Ray Angus, Johannes Johgan van de Wetering Abstract A binary-pairing Monte Carlo collision method is presented here for screened Coulomb collisions in plasmas that is valid in the weakly and moderately coupled regimes. The method models the Fokker-Planck collision operator with first order corrections with respect to the Coulomb logarithm in the appropriate limits and identically reduces to a standard Monte Carlo method for solving the Boltzmann collision integral for screened Rutherford collisions when the time step is sufficiently small. The method is exceptionally simple and can be integrated into existing binary methods for cumulative scattering with the addition of about 10 lines of code. Journal: Manuscript for submission to the Journal of Computational Physics (LLNL-JRNL-2003045) 1 Introduction The Landau-Fokker-Planck (LFP) equation governs collisional processes in fully ionized, weakly coupled plasmas, where the Coulomb logarithm is large ( \ln\Lambda\gtrsim 10 ). This equation describes the collisional evolution of a species’ distribution function due to cumulative small-angle scattering. The Coulomb logarithm quantifies the relative importance of cumulative small-angle scattering to single large-angle collisions. The latter can be important for moderately coupled plasmas where 2\lesssim\ln\Lambda\lesssim 10 , such as those found in inertial confinement fusion (ICF) experiments [ 1 ] . Li and Petrasso generalized the LFP equation to include large-angle scattering [ 2 ] , which they applied to quantify charged particle stopping powers in ICF plasmas [ 3 ] . In this model, contribution of large-angle scattering to the stopping power appears through terms that scale a 1{/}\ln\Lambda . Recently, this model has been used to examine the effects of alpha-ion stopping on ignition criteria in ICF experiments [ 4 ] . The binary-pairing algorithms by Takizuka and Abe [ 5 ] (TA77) and Nanbu [ 6 ] (N97) are two standard Monte Carlo (MC) methods used in particle-in-cell (PIC) codes to model the LFP equation. These methods belong to a broader class of MC methods that solve the LFP equation [ 7 , 8 ] . Several studies have focused on incorporating large-angle collisions into these binary-pairing methods. Turrell et al. achieved this by splitting the scattering into small-angle and large-angle groups, separated by a cut off angle (typically 90 degrees) [ 9 ] . Large-angle scattering was modeled using the conventional MC method for the Boltzmann collision integral, while small-angle scattering was treated using the TA77 method with a reduced Coulomb logarithm. Higginson extended the N97 method to include large-angle collisions using a continuous distribution function that is like that from N97 for angles below a critical angle and transitions to the Rutherford distribution at larger angles [ 10 ] . This method requires solving a nonlinear three-variable system for each binary pair to enforce the imposed constraints on the distribution function for the scattering angle. This paper presents a binary-pairing MC method for screened Coulomb collisions in plasmas, applicable to both the weakly and moderately coupled regimes. The method models the LFP equation with first order 1/\ln\Lambda corrections in the appropriate limits and transitions to a standard MC method for solving the Boltzmann collision integral for screened Rutherford collisions when the time step is sufficiently small. The algorithm is remarkably simple and can be integrated into any existing MC method for cumulative scattering with the addition of about 10 lines of code. The key insight enabling this simplicity is that the specific form of the distribution function used to model the LFP equation is unimportant. What matters is that the transport moment matches that obtained from the Rutherford differential cross section for screened Coulomb collisions [ 8 ] . The remainder of the paper is outlined as follows. Methods for modeling screened Coulomb collisions in a plasma via cumulative and single scattering events are discussed in Sec. 2 . Our generalized method for screened Coulomb collisions in plasmas is presented in Sec. 3 . Verification tests are presented in Sec. 4 . In Sec. 5 , the method is used to quantify knock-on ion production and collisional stopping of a high-energy alpha beam in a DT plasma at ignition-relevant conditions [ 11 ] . Finally, further discussion and a summary is provided in Sec. 6 . 2 The Rutherford cross section for screened Coulomb collisions in plasmas Consider a particle i belonging to species \alpha with charge q_{\alpha}=Z_{\alpha}e and mass m_{\alpha} and particle j belonging to species \beta with charge q_{\beta}=Z_{\beta}e and mass m_{\beta} . The differential cross section for a Coulomb collision between particle i and j is given by the Rutherford formula: I_{R}=\frac{b^{2}_{\bot}}{4\sin^{4}\frac{\theta}{2}}, (1) where \theta is the polar scattering angle in the center-of-momentum frame, and b_{\bot}=|q_{\alpha}q_{\beta}|/\left(4\pi\epsilon_{0}\mu_{\alpha\beta}v_{ij}^{2}\right) is the classical impact parameter for a 90^{\circ} scatter with \mu_{\alpha\beta}=m_{\alpha}m_{\beta}/\left(m_{\alpha}+m_{\beta}\right) the reduced mass and v_{ij} is the relative velocity. The total Rutherford cross section is infinite. However, inter-particle potentials in a plasma are screened at a distance set by the plasma Debye length, \lambda_{De} . This gives a maximum impact parameter, b_{\max}=\lambda_{De} , which corresponds to a minimum scattering angle. The total Rutherford cross section for Coulomb collisions in a plasma is \sigma_{\text{tot}}\equiv 2\pi\int_{\theta_{\min}}^{\pi}I_{R}\sin\theta d\theta=\pi b_{\bot}^{2}\left(\frac{1}{\sin^{2}\frac{\theta_{\min}}{2}}-1\right). (2) The corresponding transport cross section is \sigma_{\text{tr}}\equiv 2\pi\int_{\theta_{\min}}^{\pi}\left(1-\cos\theta\right)I_{R}\sin\theta d\theta=4\pi b_{\bot}^{2}\ln\Lambda, (3) where \ln\Lambda=\frac{1}{2}\ln\left[\frac{1}{\sin^{2}\frac{\theta_{\min}}{2}}\right] (4) is the Coulomb logarithm. The \sin^{2}\frac{\theta_{\min}}{2} terms in Eqs. 2 - 4 can be expressed in terms of the impact parameter b . Classically, the relationship between the scattering angle \theta and the impact parameter b is given as \sin^{2}\frac{\theta}{2}=\frac{b^{2}_{\bot}}{b^{2}_{\bot}+b^{2}}. (5) A fundamental impact parameter from quantum mechanics is b_{\text{qm}}=\hbar/\left(2\mu_{\alpha\beta}v_{ij}\right) . The classical relation given in Eq. 5 is only valid for low-velocity interactions such that \kappa\equiv b_{\bot}/b_{\text{qm}}>1 . In this work, we use the following generalization of Eq. 5 obtained using the transformations b^{2}_{\bot}\rightarrow b^{2}_{\bot}+b^{2}_{\text{qm}} and b^{2}\rightarrow\left(b+b_{\text{qm}}\right)^{2}-b^{2}_{\text{qm}} [ 12 ] : \sin^{2}\frac{\theta}{2}=\frac{b^{2}_{\bot}+b^{2}_{\text{qm}}}{b^{2}_{\bot}+\left(b+b_{\text{qm}}\right)^{2}}, (6) which results in the following expression for the Coulomb logarithm: \ln\Lambda=\frac{1}{2}\ln\left[\frac{b^{2}_{\bot}+\left(b_{\max}+b_{\text{qm}}\right)^{2}}{b^{2}_{\bot}+b^{2}_{\text{qm}}}\right]. (7) This expression reduces to the classical value for large \kappa [ 9 ] and agrees well with the quantum calculation of the Coulomb logarithm otherwise [ 12 ] . The normalized mean free path associated with the total and transport cross sections are fundamental parameters for scattering algorithms. For particle i\in\alpha colliding with particle j\in\beta during interval \Delta t , these parameter are defined, respectively, as \displaystyle N_{ij} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\sigma_{\text{tot}}v_{ij}n_{\min}\Delta t, (8) \displaystyle s_{ij} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\sigma_{\text{tr}}v_{ij}n_{\min}\Delta t, (9) where n_{\min}=w\min\left(N_{\alpha},N_{\beta}\right)/\Delta V is the density of the species with the lower number of simulation particles in a cell of volume \Delta V . The simulation particles are assumed to have equal weights in this work ( w_{i}=w_{j}=w ), in which case momentum and energy are identically conserved for each binary pair, and the expressions in Eq. 8 - 9 are symmetric with respect to i and j . The particle pairing procedure used for the algorithm here is the same as that used in TA77 - the number of binary pairs per time step is \max\left(N_{\alpha},N_{\beta}\right) and the velocity of particles that collide multiple times are updated sequentially. See Ref. [ 13 ] for a discussion on how to properly account for particles of varying weights. In the standard MC method for solving the Boltzmann collision integral, the probability of a collision occurring between a binary