Out on a Limb: The Signatures of East-West Asymmetries in Transmission Spectra from General Circulation Models

Kenneth E. Arnold, Arjun B. Savel, Eliza M.-R. Kempton, Michael T. Roman, Emily Rauscher, Isaac Malsky, Hayley Beltz, Maria E. Steinrueck · 2025

Read Out on a Limb: The Signatures of East-West Asymmetries in Transmission Spectra from General Circulation Models by Kenneth E. Arnold, Arjun B. Savel, Eliza M.-R. Kempton, Michael T. Roman, Emily Rauscher, Isaac Malsky, Hayley Beltz, Maria E. Steinrueck (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-14060.txt.

Introduction

When a hot giant planet crosses its star, starlight filters through the planet's air, and the two edges of the planet can tell different stories. Kenneth Arnold and seven co-authors model those east-west differences in this 2025 paper. Winds can make one limb hotter than the other, and clouds and gases may spread unevenly between morning and evening sides.

The team ran a grid of global climate models for planets heated to between fifteen hundred and four thousand degrees, with several cloud recipes. They then faked the observations two ways: during entry and exit, and by splitting morning from evening limbs. A temperature gap between limbs drove most of the signal. Clouds mattered most at middling heat, since at low heat they covered both limbs evenly. The study weighs which observing style best reveals lopsided air.

Catalog record

CREATORKenneth E. Arnold, Arjun B. Savel, Eliza M.-R. Kempton, Michael T. Roman, Emily Rauscher, Isaac Malsky, Hayley Beltz, Maria E. Steinrueck
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE59 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-14060

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Out on a Limb: The Signatures of East-West Asymmetries in Transmission Spectra from General Circulation Models Kenneth E. Arnold, Arjun B. Savel, Eliza M.-R. Kempton, Michael T. Roman, Emily Rauscher, Isaac Malsky, Hayley Beltz, Maria E. Steinrueck Abstract In the era of JWST, observations of hot Jupiter atmospheres are becoming increasingly precise. As a result, the signatures of limb asymmetries due to temperature or abundance differences and the presence of aerosols can now be directly measured using transmission spectroscopy. Using a grid of general circulation models (GCMs) with varying irradiation temperatures (1500 K – 4000 K) and prescriptions of cloud formation, we simulate 3D ingress/egress and morning/evening-limb transmission spectra. We aim to assess the impact that clouds, 3D temperature structure, and non-uniform distribution of gases have on the observed spectra, and how these inhomogeneities can be identified. A second goal is to assess the relative merits of two separate methods (ingress/egress vs. morning/evening-limb spectroscopy) for isolating atmospheric asymmetries. From our models, it is evident that an east-west temperature difference is the leading order effect for producing ingress/egress or morning/evening-limb spectral differences. We additionally find that clouds contribute strongly to the observed limb asymmetry at moderate irradiation temperatures in our grid ( ∼ 2000 \sim 2000 K < T irr < 3500 <T_{\mathrm{irr}}<3500 K). At lower temperatures clouds equally dominate the optical depth on both limbs, while at higher temperatures the entire terminator region remains cloud-free. We develop limb asymmetry metrics that can be used to assess the degree of east-west asymmetry for a given planet and predict trends in these metrics with respect to irradiation temperature that are indicative of various physical processes. Our results are useful for predicting and diagnosing the signatures of limb asymmetries in JWST spectra. I Introduction Hot Jupiters are implicitly three-dimensional (3D) objects. Given that they have semimajor axes < 0.1 AU, these planets are highly irradiated, and they are believed to be synchronously rotating [ 71 , e.g.,] . The resulting strongly non-uniform heating pattern implies that they should exhibit considerable variations in temperature (and as a result, their composition, cloud properties, etc.) between their daysides and nightsides, as well as between their eastern and western hemispheres [ 82 , 14 , 35 , 73 , 63 , 78 , e.g.,] . East-west asymmetries, which are of key importance to this paper, arise because the planet’s rotation and winds carry hot gas eastward from the substellar point, leading to a hotter eastern (or “evening”) limb and colder western (or “morning”) limb [ 85 ] . The impact of these 3D inhomogeneities in hot Jupiter atmospheric properties has been shown to have observable consequences on their transmission spectra [ 25 , 24 , 18 , 48 , 39 , 97 , 94 , e.g.,] . To account for this non-uniformity, retrieval techniques have been developed to recover two-component (e.g., day/night or east/west) or multi-component atmospheres, enabling the recovery of distinct temperatures, abundances, and aerosols in each region [ 39 , 62 , 47 ] . Other retrieval techniques have been developed to identify the presence of “patchy” terminator cloud coverage [ 42 , 50 , 67 , 62 , e.g.,] . The latter approach is useful for constraining the fraction of a planet’s limb that is enshrouded in aerosols. For example, analyses of the JWST transmission spectrum of the hot Jupiter WASP-39b support the presence of patchy cloud coverage and inhomogeneous temperatures in order to fully reproduce the observations [ 23 , 10 ] . However, a downside to the classical transmission spectroscopy technique is that it cannot precisely identify where in the atmosphere any inhomogeneities arise. Another way of saying this is that transmission spectroscopy probes the entire unresolved terminator all at once (by fitting the maximum transit depth as a function of wavelength), so any spatial information is only indirectly inferred via subtle perturbations to line profile shapes. Swapping the properties of the eastern and western hemispheres will result in identical transmission spectra, and one cannot readily distinguish between globally patchy cloud coverage and clouds concentrated on a single hemisphere. Recently, more direct ways of spatially “mapping” the terminator region have been proposed. In the era of precision transmission spectroscopy with JWST, extracting phase-resolved transmission spectra, as the planet’s limb scans across the stellar disk, is an exciting new way of directly uncovering the non-uniform nature of exoplanetary atmospheres. Several techniques have been proposed to map the terminator through phase-resolved transmission spectroscopy. These include (i) separately extracting transmission spectra during ingress and egress phases [ 33 ] , (ii) modeling the shape of the spectroscopic light curves to independently recover transmission spectra corresponding to the planet’s morning and evening limbs [ 70 , 32 , 20 ] , and (iii) modeling the shape of the spectroscopic light curves to fully recover the effective shape of the terminator region as a function of the observed wavelength [ 27 ] . In this paper, we will focus on and apply the concepts of (i) and (ii) from this list, which can both be most closely linked with the spectra originating from distinct atmospheric regions. All of these transit mapping techniques are novel, and they are just now being successfully applied to data for the first time [ 21 , 60 , 88 ] . We aim in this work to predict the observational signatures arising from applying these technique and also to better understand their relative strengths and shortcomings. To predict the signatures of limb asymmetries in transmission spectra in this work, we turn to the results of hot Jupiter general circulation models (GCMs). Such models predict possible spatial variations in temperature, chemistry, and cloudiness for a given hot Jupiter, given various underlying assumptions (e.g., chemical equilibrium, specific prescriptions for atmospheric drag, or simplifications to cloud microphysics). We focus in this work specifically on the impact of clouds in imparting observable limb asymmetries because clouds have been found to be nearly ubiquitous in all but the very hottest exoplanets [ 9 , 86 , 26 , 28 , 17 , e.g.,] . Clouds also have a first-order impact in shaping transmission spectra via the muting of spectral features and producing sloped spectra at optical wavelengths [ 92 , e.g.,] . The presence of clouds is expected to be highly temperature-dependent due to the nature of condensation processes, and multiple GCMs have predicted strongly spatially inhomogeneous cloud coverage in hot Jupiter atmospheres, including at the terminator [ 63 , 70 , 78 , e.g.,] . The radiative feedback from clouds can also significantly alter the temperature structure of a hot Jupiter’s atmosphere, which may either enhance or diminish east-west temperature inhomogeneities [ 78 , 64 , 79 , 51 ] . In this paper, we simulate 3D transmission spectra from the grid of clear and cloudy hot Jupiter GCMs presented in [ 79 ] . In Section II , we describe the GCMs and our techniques for calculating simulated transmission spectra, including how we generate ingress/egress and morning/evening-limb spectra. In Section III , we present our results. We show the terminator maps that arise from the input GCMs and their resulting spectra. We additionally diagnose how these results depend on planetary irradiation temperature and treatment of

Read the complete text