What determines the brightness of magnetically open solar corona?: Insights from three-dimensional radiative MHD simulations and observations
Haruhisa Iijima · 2025
Read What determines the brightness of magnetically open solar corona?: Insights from three-dimensional radiative MHD simulations and observations by Haruhisa Iijima (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-14049.txt.
Introduction
Haruhisa Iijima asks what sets the brightness of open corona regions on the Sun in a 2025 paper. Coronal holes are dark patches tied to open magnetic fields. The textbook view says open regions are dark by nature. Three-dimensional simulations with radiation and magnetics test that view.
Open regions in the model shine about as bright as quiet regions. Energy fed in from churning surface magnetism sets the brightness, not corona dissipation quirks. Fake telescope maps show standard brightness cuts can miss open regions, above all at low resolution. Real satellite maps back the claim. Field extrapolation settings sway results too. The open flux problem may stem from such misses.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Haruhisa Iijima |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 56 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-14049
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
What determines the brightness of magnetically open solar corona?: Insights from three-dimensional radiative MHD simulations and observations Haruhisa Iijima Abstract We investigate the relationship between solar coronal holes and open-field regions using three-dimensional radiative magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) simulations combined with remote-sensing observations from the Solar Dynamics Observatory (SDO). Our numerical simulations reveal that magnetically open regions in the corona can exhibit brightness comparable to quiet regions, challenging the conventional view that open-field regions are inherently dark coronal holes. We find that the coronal brightness is primarily determined by the total energy input from photospheric magnetic activities, such as the small-scale dynamo, rather than differences in dissipative processes within the corona. Using synthesized EUV intensity maps, we show that brightness thresholds commonly used to identify coronal holes may overlook open-field regions, especially at lower spatial resolutions. Observational analysis utilizing SDO/HMI and AIA synoptic maps supports our simulation results, demonstrating that magnetic field extrapolation techniques, such as the Potential Field Source Surface (PFSS) model, are sensitive to the chosen parameters, including the source surface height. We suggest that discrepancies in estimates of open magnetic flux (the “open flux problem”) arise both from the modeling assumptions in coronal magnetic field extrapolation and systematic biases in solar surface magnetic field observations. Our findings indicate the need for reconsidering criteria used to identify coronal holes as indicators of open-field regions to better characterize the solar open magnetic flux. I Introduction Coronal holes are dark, cool regions in the solar corona. The formation mechanism of these dark coronal holes has been discussed for many years. One popular model is that the brightness of a coronal hole is determined by its magnetic connectivity to interplanetary space [ 41 ] . If the coronal magnetic field is open to space, the mechanical energy input is used to both accelerate the solar wind and heat the coronal plasma. Therefore, the coronal brightness becomes smaller than in magnetically closed regions. From this concept, the term “coronal hole” is often used to refer to the magnetically open region on the solar surface, independent on the coronal brightness. If most magnetic flux in the interplanetary space comes from coronal holes, the total flux from coronal holes should be equal to the interplanetary magnetic flux as estimated from the in-situ observations. It is known that the strength of the interplanetary magnetic field does not show a strong dependence on the solar latitude [ 52 , e.g., ] . Thus, the total flux of open magnetic field can be estimated from several methods: (1) measuring the solar surface magnetic flux in coronal holes, (2) using the extrapolation method of coronal magnetic field, and (3) using the in-situ observation of interplanetary magnetic field. However, a discrepancy between these values has been reported by several groups [ 59 , 20 , 45 , 62 , 49 , 37 ] . [ 37 ] named this discrepancy the “open flux problem”. There are several potential solutions to solve the “open flux problem”. One possibility is a systematic error in the polarimetric magnetic field observations on the solar surface [ 46 , 60 , e.g.] . Another possibility is a systematic bias in the coronal magnetic field extrapolation. One example is the potential field source surface (PFSS) model [ 48 ] , which assumes that the magnetic field is open above a certain height. However, the height of the source surface, where the magnetic field is assumed to be open, is not well constrained. The source surface height is often set to 2.5R_{\odot} [ 48 , 21 ] , validated by the correspondence between open-field regions and coronal holes [ 46 ] . However, the other (lower) values for the source surface height have been suggested to better explain other metrics, including the interplanetary magnetic field strength, magnetic field direction inferred from polarimetric measurements, open-field source identified from temperature-dependent emission structures, magnetic polarity reversals, streamer belts, or solar wind velocity [ 36 , 35 , 15 , 16 , 3 , 4 , 24 , 57 , e.g.] . In this study, we investigate the formation mechanism of coronal holes based on two approaches: first, three-dimensional radiative magnetohydrodynamic simulations of a realistic magnetically open solar corona, and second, remote-sensing observations of solar coronal holes using the PFSS model. To avoid the confusion, we define coronal holes as regions with weak intensity of X-rays or extreme ultraviolet, and strictly distinguish these dark regions from open-field regions, where magnetic field lines are open to interplanetary space. In Sec. II , we show a series of three-dimensional simulations of a magnetically open corona, including coronal holes. We find that magnetically open corona can be bright, similar to quiet regions outside coronal holes. In Sec. III , we use the PFSS model to extrapolate the coronal magnetic field and observations by the Solar Dynamics Observatory (SDO) to further examine the relationship between coronal holes and open-field regions. Sec. IV summarizes the results and discusses the implications of our findings. II Numerical simulations of magnetically open solar corona First, we present a series of three-dimensional magnetohydrodynamic simulations that mimic the heating process of the magnetically open ambient corona, including coronal holes. In observational data, it is very difficult to strictly identify open-field regions independent of the magnetic field extrapolation models. Thus, it is advantageous to investigate the heating process of magnetically open corona using numerical simulations. II.1 Basic equations and implementations We used the radiative MHD code RAMENS [ 29 , 30 , 28 ] to solve one-fluid MHD equations including the effects of partial ionization, field-aligned thermal conduction by electrons, and radiative energy exchange. As our model directly resolves the MHD wave propagation from the solar surface to the corona, we do not employ any empirical heating terms except for the numerical diffusion required for the numerical stability. The model integrates the one-fluid compressible magnetohydrodynamic equations: \displaystyle\frac{\partial{\rho}}{\partial t}+\nabla\cdot\left(\rho\bm{V}\right) \displaystyle=0, (1) \displaystyle\frac{\partial\left({\rho}\bm{V}\right)}{\partial t}+\nabla\cdot\left(\rho\bm{V}\bm{V}+P\right) \displaystyle=\frac{1}{4\pi}\left(\nabla\times\bm{B}\right)\times\bm{B}+\rho\bm{g}, (2) \displaystyle\frac{\partial e_{\rm int}}{\partial t}+\nabla\cdot\left(e_{\rm int}\bm{V}\right) \displaystyle=-P\nabla\cdot\bm{V}+Q_{\rm vis}+Q_{\rm res}+Q_{\rm rad}+Q_{\rm cnd}, (3) \displaystyle\frac{\partial\bm{B}}{\partial t}+\nabla\times\left(\bm{V}\times\bm{B}\right) \displaystyle=0, (4) where {\rho} , P , e_{\rm int} , \bm{V} , \bm{B} , and \bm{g} are mass density, gas pressure, internal energy density, velocity field, magnetic field, and gravitational acceleration by the Sun, respectively. Q_{\rm vis} and Q_{\rm res} indicate viscous and resistive heating rates, respectively, caused by the numerical diffusion in the equations of motion and induction. Although we do not solve the equation of the total energy conservation explicitly, the energy-consistent discretization keeps the total energy conservation throughout the time integration [ 26 ] . We assumed the local thermodynamic equilibrium (LTE) in the equation of state. The latent heat by the partial ionization transports two-thirds of the total convective energy in the near-surface convection zone [ 55 ] . Thus, we used a tabulated equation of state accounting for the latent heat change including the most abundant twelve elements using the partition function by [ 31 ] . The latent heat of the molecular hydrogen is also taken into account. The radiative heating rate Q_{\rm rad} is defined as a combination of optically thick and optically thin rates \displaystyle Q_{\rm rad}=(1-f_{\rm thin})Q_{\rm thick}+f_{\rm thin}Q_{\rm thin}, (5) where \displaystyle f_{\rm thin}=1-{\rm e}^{-(\rho/\rho_{\rm thin})^{2}}. (6) Here, the threshold value \rho_{\rm thin} is set to