Birds of a Different Feather Flock Together: Exploring Opportunities and Challenges in Animal-Human-Machine Teaming

Myke C. Cohen, David A. Grimm, Reuth Mirsky, Xiaoyun Yin · 2025

Read Birds of a Different Feather Flock Together: Exploring Opportunities and Challenges in Animal-Human-Machine Teaming by Myke C. Cohen, David A. Grimm, Reuth Mirsky, Xiaoyun Yin (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-13973.txt.

Introduction

Myke Cohen and co-authors mapped teams of animals, humans, and machines in two thousand twenty-five. Hybrid teams can outdo any single member type. Dogs smell, humans judge, machines tirelessly compute. Yet designing such teams lacks a shared framework. The paper proposes dimensions for studying them. Each member's strengths should cover others' weaknesses.

Three examples show the framework in action. Airport screening pairs dogs with scanners and handlers. Search and rescue mixes animals with drones. Guide dog work is the oldest such team. Open research questions close the paper. Designers gain vocabulary for a strange frontier.

Catalog record

CREATORMyke C. Cohen, David A. Grimm, Reuth Mirsky, Xiaoyun Yin
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE24 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-13973

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Birds of a Different Feather Flock Together: Exploring Opportunities and Challenges in Animal-Human-Machine Teaming Myke C. Cohen, David A. Grimm, Reuth Mirsky, Xiaoyun Yin Abstract Animal-Human-Machine (AHM) teams are a type of hybrid intelligence system wherein interactions between a human, AI-enabled machine, and animal members can result in unique capabilities greater than the sum of their parts. This paper calls for a systematic approach to studying the design of AHM team structures to optimize performance and overcome limitations in various applied settings. We consider the challenges and opportunities in investigating the synergistic potential of AHM team members by introducing a set of dimensions of AHM team functioning to effectively utilize each member’s strengths while compensating for individual weaknesses. Using three representative examples of such teams—security screening, search-and-rescue, and guide dogs—the paper illustrates how AHM teams can tackle complex tasks. We conclude with open research directions that this multidimensional approach presents for studying hybrid human-AI systems beyond AHM teams. Keywords: multi-agent systems, animal-human-machine teaming, functional allocation 1 Introduction Consider a Blind or Visually Impaired (BVI) person training to be assisted by a guide dog. When the pair reaches an obstacle along their path, they can aim to employ a learned protocol: the dog stops, then the BVI person investigates the cause for the stop, be it a wall, a stair, etc. With modern vision technologies, the pair could be equipped with a designated camera and a vision algorithm that automatically identifies the reason for the dog’s stop [ 1 ] , reducing the need for the BVI person to investigate manually. Such a system can be considered as an animal-human-machine (AHM) team that functions as a synergistic unit that can tackle complex tasks and challenges. Conversely, the absence of any of the members makes AHM teams less capable: without a vision system, a BVI person must exert inefficient and potentially risky efforts to interpret why their guide dog pair made a stop; even the most cutting-edge robots cannot fully replace a guide dog [ 2 , 3 , 4 , 5 ] ; and obviously, the team’s goal ceases to exist without the BVI person. Figure 1: The properties of Animal-Human-Machine team. In the ideal scenario, each member of an AHM team is given a role that maximizes their respective strengths and compensates for individual weaknesses to optimize the team’s functionality. However, in high-stakes, rapidly changing scenarios, individual workloads are often exceeded, whether through anticipated or unanticipated circumstances. In those situations, flexible reallocation is needed to redistribute responsibilities across other team members [ 6 ] . This paper investigates AHM teams as a type of a multiagent system (MAS) and discusses the unique research challenges and opportunities in this setup. We define an AHT team as follows: Definition 1.1 . An Animal-Human-Machine team is a multiagent system with three or more members: at least one is an animal, one is a human, and one is a machine. Each member has agency grounded in unique sensing, decision-making, and acting capabilities. Previous work has also highlighted some conceptual similarities between domestic animals and machines [ 7 ] . As some robots are of organic matter [ 8 ] and animals are incorporated into machines [ 9 ] , we might reach a point where the distinction between the different agents is blurred [ 10 ] . At this time, however, we assume that the boundaries between humans, animals, and machines are clear. We note that this paper focuses on the technological aspects of AHM rather than its legal or ethical implications, which are not negligible. Interested researchers can refer to [ 10 , 11 , 12 ] . We move on to discuss AHM from the lens of related work, including team functional allocation from industrial/organizational psychology and computational work linking human-animal and human-agent interaction paradigms. 2 Related Works In organizational psychology, teams are often defined as groups of people with a shared sense of identity who collaborate with distinct roles for a limited time to achieve a common goal [ 13 ] . By this definition, AHM teams seem paradoxical due to having non-human members. But treating components like sense of identity or role distinction as variable elements of teaming (i.e., “teamness”; [ 14 ] ) can aid in understanding a broad range of collaborations. Consider ad-hoc teamwork, where amorphous team compositions may result in a lack of clear shared identities among collaborators [ 15 ] . Treating shared identity as a variable has borne algorithmic solutions that aid teammates in establishing common ground, inferring each other’s capabilities, and interpreting other agents ’ underlying cooperative intents [ 16 , 17 ] . Similarly, considering “humanness” as a spectrum rather than a requirement of teaming has benefited the recent surge in research and development of human-machine systems wherein people and machines collectively achieve feats they could not apart [ 18 , 14 ] . The same logic has long been used to describe human-animal systems [ 19 ] . Human-animal teams are increasingly used as a metaphor for human-machine teams. Both are interactive systems that achieve joint outcomes despite having different cognitive processes between animal, human, and machine members [ 20 , 21 , 22 , 23 ] . Human-animal teams and human-machine teams also share intractable physical and cognitive asymmetries between each member type, limiting the tasks they can perform and their understanding of the team’s overarching goals [ 24 ] . These asymmetries are amplified in AHM teams due to the concurrent presence of at least two types of non-human teammates [ 25 ] , defining a complex range of research paradigms and application domains. For example, how to support the development of shared mental models between human and machine teammates [ 26 , 27 , 28 , 29 , 30 ] ; however, the impacts of these efforts will likely be limited in full AHMs due to animal cognitive limitations. Conversely, the evolutionary origin of human-animal relationships results in interaction dynamics that are more social and emotional than human-robot ones [ 21 ] . One quality that AHM teams ostensibly share is role heterogeneity, i.e., each member is assigned a unique set of tasks to fulfill a role within a team [ 31 ] . Role heterogeneity often results from delegating tasks to individuals based on their abilities. In all-human teams like surgical teams, task assignment decisions are based on limited pools of team members who can fulfill roles like surgeon, anesthesiologist, or nurse at a given time [ 32 , 33 ] . However, further training can enable today’s nurse to be assigned the role of surgeon in the future. In contrast, such decisions in AHM teams are limited by ethical, legal, and technological concerns that come with assigning non-human members to potentially consequential tasks [ 34 , 35 , 36 ] . In human-machine systems, Fitts’ list [ 37 , 38 ] is an influential framework that operates on the principle of non-overlapping task allocations based on the relative strengths and weaknesses of people and machines (often called “HABA-MABA”, short for “humans-are-better-at/machines-are-better-at”). Current functional allocation paradigms in human teams and human-machine teams are still predominantly based on individual members’ capabilities [ 39 , 40 , 41 , 42

Read the complete text