Using Generative AI Personas Increases Collective Diversity in Human Ideation
Yun Wan, Yoram M Kalman · 2025
Read Using Generative AI Personas Increases Collective Diversity in Human Ideation by Yun Wan, Yoram M Kalman (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-13868.txt.
Introduction
Yun Wan and Yoram M Kalman present a 2025 study asking whether varied AI personas can stop AI help from making everyone's ideas alike. Earlier work found that AI story prompts lift individual creativity but narrow the spread of stories across a group. The authors trace that trade-off to how the AI inputs are designed.
In a first phase, ten distinct personas generated three hundred story plots, whose diversity was confirmed by text analysis. In a second phase, people wrote stories with or without those plots. Diverse AI input kept the group's variety at the level of unaided writers, with hints of improvement when a single plot was given. Design, not AI itself, drives the squeeze.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Yun Wan, Yoram M Kalman |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 38 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-13868
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Using Generative AI Personas Increases Collective Diversity in Human Ideation Thanks: Citation : Authors. Title. Pages…. DOI:000000/11111. Yun Wan, Yoram M Kalman Abstract This study challenges the widely-reported tradeoff between generative AI’s (GenAI) contribution to creative outcomes and decreased diversity of these outcomes. We modified the design of such a study, by Doshi and Hauser (2024), in which participants wrote short stories either aided or unaided by GenAI plot ideas [ 1 ] . In the modified study, plot ideas were generated through ten unique GenAI "personas" with diverse traits (e.g. cultural backgrounds, thinking styles, genre preferences), creating a pool of 300 story plots. While plot ideas from any individual persona showed high similarity (average cosine similarity of 0.92), ideas across different personas exhibited substantial variation (average similarity of 0.20). When human participants wrote stories based on these diverse plot ideas, their collective outputs maintained the same level of diversity as stories written without GenAI assistance, effectively eliminating the diversity reduction observed in [ 1 ] . Traditional text analytics further revealed that GenAI-assisted stories featured greater diversity in descriptive and emotional language compared to purely human-generated stories without GenAI assistance. Our findings demonstrate that introducing diversity at the AI input stage through distinct personas can preserve and potentially enhance the collective diversity of human creative outputs when collaborating with GenAI. K eywords generative AI \cdot creativity \cdot AI persona 1 Introduction Several recent studies of the contributions of GenAI to human performance of creative tasks demonstrated an interesting trade-off: GenAI can boost the quality of the creative outputs, but this involves a reduction in the diversity of the outputs [ 1 , 2 , 3 ] . For example, Doshi and Hauser [ 1 ] demonstrated that GenAI plot ideas enhanced the creativity of individual storywriters but, notably, reduced the collective diversity of the stories. Their experiment showed that when participants had access to GenAI-generated plot ideas, their stories were rated as more creative on an individual level, but the semantic similarity between stories increased significantly, with cosine similarity scores rising by 10.7% and 8.9% for participants with access to one or five GenAI ideas, respectively. This finding about the reduction in collective diversity was in line with at least two previous findings from earlier studies. In the first case, Boston Consulting Group consultants using GenAI were more productive and produced better ideas, but there was a marked reduction in the variability of their ideas compared to consultants who did not use GenAI [ 2 ] . The consultants using GenAI were found to generate more solutions to client problems and these solutions were rated as higher quality, but the diversity of solutions decreased according to their semantic similarity metrics. In the second study, Chen and Chan [ 3 ] demonstrated that GenAI support improved the quality of nonexpert ad copies, but decreased the semantic divergence (ie, diversity) of the ads. Their research revealed that participants using GenAI for ghostwriting or reviewing produced ad copies with higher linguistic quality and persuasiveness, but the semantic similarity of user’ outputs increased by 60% and 32% respectively, indicating a significant standardization effect. Is this trade-off between GenAI assistance in a creative task and the diversity of the creative outcome an inevitable result of working with GenAI? We hypothesize it is not. Instead, we propose that the reduced diversity of creative outcomes stems directly from an unintentional narrowing of the diversity in the outputs prompted from the GenAI. We tested this hypothesis by replicating the experiment of [ 1 ] , but instead of using the simple prompt that Doshi and Hauser used in their experiment, we prompted ten diverse GenAI “personas” (e.g. [ 4 , 5 ] ) to suggest plot ideas. Why might providing the participants with plot ideas from ten diverse Gen-AI personas result in more diverse stories? GenAI’s agency and autonomy point to its ability to boost human creativity, much like a human collaborator in a team. By acting as an active and effective contributor, a GenAI agent can reshape collaborative processes to foster greater productivity and creativity. This analogy suggests the well-established link between participant diversity and improved creative outputs in collaborative settings. Diverse teams, characterized by a variety of cognitive styles, backgrounds, and perspectives, are consistently shown to produce more innovative and creative results [ 6 , 7 ] . A common limitation across all three previous studies was that they employed homogeneous GenAI prompting strategies, using identical or highly similar prompts to generate AI assistance for human participants (e.g. [ 1 ] used GPT-4 large language model (LLM) via OpenAI’s API). This standardized approach, while methodologically sound, may have inadvertently constrained the diversity of GenAI outputs. We hypothesized that diversifying the prompts could lead to more diverse ideas and would increase the collective diversity of the creative outcomes. This diversification could be achieved by using diverse GenAI personas [ 4 , 5 ] . Prompting different personas for plot ideas is analogous to pairing the human participants to collaborate with a diverse group of GenAI collaborators, rather than having multiple humans interact with the same standardized GenAI. In our experiment, we created ten distinct GenAI personas to generate plot ideas. Our analysis revealed an interesting pattern: While plot ideas from any single persona lacked diversity, the ideas generated across different personas showed substantial variation. When human participants wrote stories using these diverse plot ideas, their collective work maintained the same level of diversity as stories written without any GenAI assistance. This effectively eliminated the negative impact on collective diversity that previous research had observed when using GenAI for creative tasks. 2 Results 2.1 Story plots generated by distinctive GenAI personas are highly diverse We conducted a modified replication of [ 1 ] experiment by expanding the diversity of GenAI-generated plot ideas. We created a pool of 300 unique story plots generated by ten distinct GenAI personas who differed from each other on a large number of characteristics such as cultural background (e.g. Latin American, Middle Eastern), preferred literary genres (e.g. Fantasy, Dystopian), proficiency in different creative thinking tools (e.g. TRIZ, Six Thinking Hats), interests and hobbies, etc. Next, we measured the diversity of the plot ideas generated by the personas. In line with the methodology used in [ 1 ] , we compared the cosine similarities of the plot idea embeddings of both intra- and inter-persona. We first calculated the diversity of intra-persona plot ideas. The intra-persona cosine similarities were calculated by comparing each focal story plot with the average of the embeddings of all other 29 story plots generated by the same persona. The results range from 0.91 to 0.94 with an average of 0.92, see Table 1 , indicating the 30 story plots generated by each persona are quite similar to each other. Table 1: Average cosine similarity of story plots generated by the same persona Persona ID Average cosine similarity 1 0.94423452 2 0.91036449 3 0.93004611 4 0.92683913 5 0.92619111 6 0.91949296 7 0.90747349 8 0.92013156 9 0.91386100 10 0.93288739 Average 0.92315218 We then calculated the inter-persona cosine similarity by comparing average plot idea embeddings of each focal persona with the average embeddings of all other personas’ plot ideas. The results range from