Absence of Entanglement Growth in Dicke Superradiance
N. S. Bassler · 2025
Read Absence of Entanglement Growth in Dicke Superradiance by N. S. Bassler (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-13646.txt.
Introduction
Nico Bassler settles a long open question about a bright flash of collective light in this 2025 physics paper. In Dicke superradiance, many identical two level systems emit light together, with peak strength growing as the square of their number.
Single states in the process are often entangled, but the state during decay is a mix of such states, so it was unclear whether the whole state counts as entangled. Bassler proves, for any number of systems, that decay from the fully excited state keeps the state separable at all times. The result shows that this striking collective effect does not need entanglement to grow, a neat point for quantum optics.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | N. S. Bassler |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 66 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-13646
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Absence of Entanglement Growth in Dicke Superradiance N. S. Bassler Abstract Dicke superradiance describes an ensemble of N N permutationally invariant two-level systems collectively emitting radiation with a peak radiated intensity scaling as N 2 N^{2} . Individual Dicke states are typically entangled. However, the density matrix during superradiant decay is a mixture of such states, raising the subtle question of whether the total state is entangled or separable. We resolve this by showing analytically that for any N N , starting from the fully excited state, the collective decay preserves separability for all times. This answers a longstanding question on the role of entanglement in Dicke superradiance and underscores that, despite collective dissipation, separable states remain separable under these dynamics. I Introduction For seven decades a basic question has shadowed Dicke superradiance [ 7 ] : Can purely collective spontaneous emission ever generate genuine multipartite entanglement? The answer matters because controlled superradiant decay is now a working tool in state‑of‑the‑art platforms—from bad‑cavity optical clocks [ 4 ] , through Rydberg “superatoms” [ 31 ] , to superconducting transmon pairs in 3D cavities [ 24 ] . A rigorous verdict therefore sets an experimental baseline: any entanglement detected during undriven decay must stem from non‑collective ingredients such as dipole–dipole shifts, inhomogeneous couplings, or external driving. Dicke states—the permutationally symmetric eigenstates of the total spin operators S^{2} and S_{z} —generically exhibit multipartite entanglement [ 34 , 8 , 22 ] except for the fully excited and ground state. Thus, Dicke superradiance is often associated with the generation of entanglement [ 30 , 39 ] . Because the system becomes a mixture of entangled states during decay, it remains unclear whether the overall state is entangled. There is indeed growing evidence that symmetric Dicke dynamics does not generate entanglement but destroys åit. The challenge lies in the fact that deciding whether a mixed quantum state is separable is NP-hard in general [ 11 , 17 , 18 , 41 ] , and entanglement detection for mixed, multipartite states lacks a simple universal criterion [ 14 , 15 , 25 , 1 ] . Wolfe and Yelin verified numerically (up to N=10 ) that the partial‑transpose (PPT) test remains satisfied throughout the decay and conjectured that this implies separability for all N [ 38 ] . Yu [ 40 ] later proved analytically that any mixture of Dicke states is separable iff it is PPT, thereby characterizing the static diagonal‑symmetric set for arbitrary N . Yu’s proof, however, does not address whether the Lindblad superradiant trajectory stays inside that separable set. Hence, a fully analytic, all‑ N answer to the dynamical question has remained open. The problem is greatly simplified since the states evolving under Dicke dynamics are permutationally invariant and diagonal (i.e., no single-particle coherence between the excited and ground state) at all times, allowing for analytical solutions of the population dynamics [ 20 , 21 , 13 , 12 ] . This structure allows the use of specialized separability criteria tailored to such states [ 9 , 33 , 32 , 3 , 40 , 26 , 28 ] . Understanding how entanglement is generated, preserved, or destroyed in open quantum systems remains a fundamental challenge in quantum information science. Despite significant efforts devoted to entanglement generation in driven or coherent settings [ 10 , 2 ] , the subtleties of entanglement dynamics under purely dissipative collective processes, such as Dicke superradiance, have remained largely unexplored [ 19 , 5 , 37 ] . Our work directly addresses this knowledge gap, providing analytic clarity and resolving whether the simplest form of collective dissipation alone can generate entanglement. It is therefore highly relevant for both fundamental quantum theory and practical quantum information applications. In this work, we use techniques from real analysis to address separability. Specifically, we apply an exact mapping to the truncated moment problem [ 29 ] . Prior work also relates separability criteria of symmetric states to the moment problem [ 26 , 28 , 40 ] . The CP‑matrix approach of Tura et al. [ 35 ] gives an equivalent static criterion for diagonal‑symmetric states. We extend the analysis to the full time evolution of Dicke superradiance. We show that the population dynamics of Dicke superradiance corresponds to the evolution of a set of moments, and that if the initial state is separable, the dynamics preserves the structure required for a classical moment representation. Considering the time evolution in the lowest nonvanishing order in time enables a full analytic proof that Dicke superradiance does not generate entanglement from initially separable states. In the Dicke limit the system state never acquires off‑diagonal components in the Dicke basis, so all dynamics are confined to the (N+1) ‑dimensional symmetric manifold. This explains why symmetric‑subspace simulations (costing only \mathcal{O}(N^{2}) or better) capture the exact evolution. Moreover, as shown in the companion Letter [ 27 ] , one can unravel the master equation into at most \lceil(N+1)/2\rceil separable spin‑coherent trajectories, yielding dramatic further speedups without loss of accuracy. Finally, by turning off any coherent drives, experiments in bad‑cavity clocks, Rydberg arrays, and transmon ensembles can use the absence of entanglement as a calibration baseline ; re‑introducing a drive then cleanly isolates genuine many‑body correlations. II The problem statement We consider a system of N identical two-level systems undergoing collective spontaneous emission in the Dicke limit. The dynamics is governed by the master equation \dot{\rho}=\Gamma\left[S\rho S^{\dagger}-\frac{1}{2}\left(S^{\dagger}S\rho+\rho S^{\dagger}S\right)\right], (1) where we set the collective decay rate \Gamma=1 , and S=\sum_{k=1}^{N}\sigma_{k} is the collective lowering operator with the single-particle lowering operator \sigma_{j}=\outerproduct{g}{e}_{j} taking the two-level system j from the excited to the ground state. Starting in the fully excited state \ket{eee\dots e} , the system remains confined to the symmetric subspace of maximal total spin S=N/2 , spanned by the Dicke states \ket{\Dicke{\ind{}}}{} with k{}=0,1,\dots,N defined by S^{\dagger}S\ket{\Dicke{\ind{}}}{}=h_{k}\ket{\Dicke{\ind{}}}{} where h_{k}{}=k{}(N-k{}+1) . Writing the density matrix as a mixture of Dicke states \rho(t)=\sum_{k=0}^{N}p_{k}{}(t)\outerproduct{\ind{}}{\ind{}} with populations p_{k}(t) and without coherences in the Dicke basis, the dynamics are then described by a set of coupled rate equations \dot{p}_{k}{}(t)=h_{k{}+1}\,p_{k{}+1}(t)-h_{k}{}\,p_{k}{}(t). (2) A key simplification is that we consider density matrices without coherence in the Dicke basis, i.e., that the density matrix is diagonal 1 1 1 Starting from the fully excited state and evolving under collective decay, the state remains diagonal in the Dicke basis at all times. This structure allows for a global phase average over spin coherent states, reducing degrees of freedom in the decomposition to a single real parameter, the excitation probability \varepsilon . As a result, the separability problem reduces to a one-dimensional truncated moment problem. . Analytical approaches to the above equations have shown a simple solution for the time dynamics of the population expressed as a contour integral in the complex plane [ 13 , 12 ] . We now address the central question: Does Dicke superradiance generate entanglement from an initially separable state? A mixed state of N emitters is separable if and only if it can be written as a convex sum of M tensor products of individual particle density operators [ 16 ] \rho(t)=\sum_{i=1}^{M}w_{i}(t)\,\rho^{(i)}_{1}(t)\otimes\cdots\otimes\rho^{(i)}_{N}(t), (3) with w_{i}(t)\geq 0 , \sum_{i}w_{i}(t)=1 , and \rho^{(i)}_{j}(t) are the single-emitter density matrices. For permutationally invariant states,