Pricing AI Model Accuracy

Nikhil Kumar · 2025

Read Pricing AI Model Accuracy by Nikhil Kumar (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-13375.txt.

Introduction

Nikhil Kumar studies how firms should price the accuracy of AI models. His paper, from twenty twenty-five, builds a two-firm market model. Buyers differ in how much they value accuracy. Each firm tries to cut its model's error, but the paper shows that aim can mislead.

In a duel, cutting overall error does not always lift profit. A firm gains by cutting the error kind where it already leads. It loses by spending on the kind where it trails. Errors split into false alarms and misses, each open to investment. Profitable accuracy work can still hurt buyers as a group. Total welfare, though, rises from such investment.

Catalog record

CREATORNikhil Kumar
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE58 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-13375

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Pricing AI Model Accuracy Nikhil Kumar Abstract Abstract: This paper examines the market for AI models in which firms compete to provide accurate model predictions and consumers exhibit heterogeneous preferences for model accuracy. We develop a consumer-firm duopoly model to analyze how competition affects firms’ incentives to improve model accuracy. Each firm aims to minimize its model’s error, but this choice can often be suboptimal. Counterintuitively, we find that in a competitive market, firms that improve overall accuracy do not necessarily improve their profits. Rather, each firm’s optimal decision is to invest further on the error dimension where it has a competitive advantage. By decomposing model errors into false positive and false negative rates, firms can reduce errors in each dimension through investments, and they are strictly better off investing on their superior dimension and strictly worse off with investments on their inferior dimension. Profitable investments adversely affect consumers but increase overall market welfare. Keywords: AI model market, model error trade-off, heterogeneous cost sensitivities, horizontal differentiation, Hotelling’s model. JEL Codes: D21, D43. 1 Introduction In the artificial intelligence (AI) and machine learning (ML) industry, an AI model supplier’s central goal is to minimize its model’s error. This error metric can be very task-dependent; generative AI models prioritize producing outputs strongly resembling the user’s intended requests, whereas traditional classification models may try to minimize incorrect predictions on test data. In all such cases, though, firms typically try to minimize some corresponding measure of overall error as a proxy for model performance. While this goal is theoretically optimal, achieving a minimal error rate can be both costly and impractical for firms ( Zhang et al., 2019 ). Improving multiple error dimensions simultaneously can be expensive and inefficient. In addition, an improvement in one dimension may lead to a worsening in another dimension, inducing an inverse trade-off across dimensions ( Yaniv and Foster, 1995 ). A typical example of this is binary classification, where directly minimizing both Type I and Type II errors with a fixed sample size is typically infeasible ( Mudge et al., 2012 ). Assuming a fixed total level of error, designing a model with fewer false positive (FP) errors would shrink the rejection region but also simultaneously lead to an increase in false negative (FN) error risk, and vice versa. As a result, model designers have to prioritize between FP and FN errors based on their expectations about consumer preferences. A standard statistical approach is fixing one dimension and optimizing the other ( Maier and Lakens, 2022 ). On the demand side, consumers often care less about the total model error and more about the specific types of errors a model makes, as some errors may be more costly to them than others. The bias-variance trade-off is an example of this inverse relation in model performance; lowering bias by improving model complexity typically leads to higher variance ( Geman et al., 1992 ). One specific measure of model performance that consumers often consider is based on FP and FN rates ( Cappelen et al., 2023 ). Different consumers exhibit varying levels of sensitivities to FP and FN rates, depending on their specific use cases and their associated cost sensitivities to FP and FN errors. A prevalent shortcoming with generative AI models is hallucination, where the model generates entirely incorrect outputs. Hallucination rates, or more broadly FP rates, of the most popular models like ChatGPT remain quite significant ( Rawte et al., 2023 ). Users employing AI for creative writing may have a completely different tolerance for hallucination compared to someone using the same model for disease diagnosis. This consumer heterogeneity can be captured by different sensitivities toward hallucination rates. For example, a scientific user may prefer a non-informative model output (i.e., “I don’t know”) as opposed to a model hallucination. As a motivating example, consider two model users, Company A and Company B, both searching for new employees but struggling to choose new hires. Each company employs an AI-based labor screening model that, for every candidate, outputs either 1 (recommended hire) or 0 (recommended reject). The model therefore has two potential kinds of errors: false positives —recommending a hire who is actually unsuitable, and false negatives —rejecting a candidate who would have been a strong hire. Suppose that Company A is a large tech firm, and thus can tolerate a higher volume of applicants; its main concern is missing strong candidates, so false negatives are especially costly. Company B, on the other hand, is a small research lab with very few positions; its main concern is the disruption caused by a bad hire, so false positives are more costly. This implicit trade-off between FP and FN rates perceived by consumers, along with the difficulties associated with pure error reduction, leads to product differentiation by model suppliers. Such firms specialize through investments towards reducing error rates on certain dimensions to maximize profits; with limited resources, they must choose whether to spend on reducing their FP/FN error rates or expanding their training dataset which reduces the marginal cost of future error improvements. As a result, these supplying firms try to invest in a way that increases profits, attracting more consumers while also maintaining a sufficiently high price. In sum, two relevant phenomena are present in the AI model market: (i) heterogeneous cost sensitivity levels among consumers and (ii) an implicit firm-level trade-off between FP and FN rates. In this paper, we develop an economic model that captures both these phenomena and produces a somewhat counter-intuitive result: firms should invest in growing their competitive advantage rather than closing the gap on their inferior error dimension. This result stems from the economic intuition that closing the gap will have a minimal positive effect on market share but a greater negative effect on equilibrium prices, resulting in the firm being worse off. We develop a firm-consumer market model where firms are endowed with an initially fixed error rate, and they can then make investments toward improving either their FP or FN rate. Consumers exhibit heterogeneity through negatively correlated cost sensitivities towards FP and FN rates, which generates a natural trade-off between the two error types. We define the static version of the model in Section 3, where firms are endowed with fixed FP and FN rates, and equilibrium prices are determined endogenously. Within this fixed error rate framework, we introduce heterogeneity in the cost sensitivities of consumers. Under perfectly positively correlated cost sensitivities, our model simplifies to an extension of the standard Hotelling model. We then consider perfectly negatively correlated sensitivities and analyze the resulting equilibria in the market. Naturally, total firm revenue is maximized when all consumers have negatively correlated sensitivities, as firms are able to differentiate effectively and charge higher prices to attract consumers that match their cost sensitivities. Model dynamics are introduced in Section 4, where we consider the stability of the equilibria presented in Section 3. Firms can invest in two ways: directly improving their FP and FN error rates or increasing their firm size, and implicitly the size of their training dataset. We show that the initial market clearing prices are not equilibria; profitable deviations often exist for both firms. The equilibria can be categorized into cases of split

Read the complete text