Machine-learning Closure for Vlasov-Poisson Dynamics in Fourier-Hermite Space

N. Barbour \aff 1,2 \corresp, W. Dorland \aff 1,2, I. G. Abel \aff 2, and M. Landreman \aff 2 · 2025

Read Machine-learning Closure for Vlasov-Poisson Dynamics in Fourier-Hermite Space by N. Barbour \aff 1,2 \corresp, W. Dorland \aff 1,2, I. G. Abel \aff 2, and M. Landreman \aff 2 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-13313.txt.

Introduction

Four plasma physicists teach a machine to finish an equation that never ends. Simulating hot plasma with the Vlasov-Poisson system splits the particle distribution into an endless ladder of fluid-like moments, and any simulation must cut the ladder somewhere. The team works in a Fourier-Hermite representation, where the physics becomes that ladder, and uses reservoir computing to model the small-scale rungs that truncation would throw away.

With the learned closure in place, the solver needed far fewer velocity points for the same accuracy. In gentle, near-linear cases the error at the closed rung stayed within two percent. In strongly turbulent cases the method tracked the true spectra better than plain truncation and cut the needed velocity resolution sixteen-fold. The authors present the work as a first step toward cheap, accurate models for designing magnetic fusion reactors.

Catalog record

CREATORN. Barbour \aff 1,2 \corresp, W. Dorland \aff 1,2, I. G. Abel \aff 2, and M. Landreman \aff 2
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE61 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-13313

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Machine-learning Closure for Vlasov-Poisson Dynamics in Fourier-Hermite Space N. Barbour \aff 1,2 \corresp, W. Dorland \aff 1,2, I. G. Abel \aff 2, and M. Landreman \aff 2 Abstract Accurate reduced models of turbulence are desirable to facilitate the optimization of magnetic-confinement fusion reactor designs. As a first step toward higher-dimensional turbulence applications, we use reservoir computing, a machine-learning (ML) architecture, to develop a closure model for a limiting case of electrostatic gyrokinetics. We implement a pseudo-spectral Eulerian code to solve the one-dimensional Vlasov-Poisson system on a basis of Fourier modes in configuration space and Hermite polynomials in velocity space. When cast onto the Hermite basis, the Vlasov equation becomes an infinitely coupled hierarchy of fluid moments, presenting a closure problem. We exploit the locality of interactions in the Hermite representation to introduce an ML closure model of the small-scale dynamics in velocity space. In the linear limit, when the kinetic Fourier-Hermite solver is augmented with the reservoir closure, the closure permits a reduction of the velocity resolution, with a relative error within two percent for the Hermite moment where the reservoir closes the hierarchy. In the strongly-nonlinear regime, the ML closure model more accurately resolves the low-order Fourier and Hermite spectra when compared to a naïve closure by truncation and reduces the required velocity resolution by a factor of sixteen. 1 Introduction One of the most important ongoing efforts in the pursuit of magnetic fusion energy is the study of microturbulence ( Yoshida et al., 2025 ) . While magnetic-confinement fusion plasmas are designed to be stable to macroscopic magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) perturbations, the steep gradients in temperature and density that are present in all current designs also drive small-scale instabilities. These instabilities drive sustained turbulence, which then dominates the transport of particles, energy, and momentum in the plasma. As the fusion industry turns its focus toward designing first-of-a-kind pilot plants, optimizing these designs to mitigate turbulent heat losses is an urgent objective. Significant progress in turbulence optimization for tokamaks ( Highcock et al., 2018 ) and stellarators ( Roberg-Clark et al., 2023 ; Kim et al., 2024 ) has been achieved. However, the space of candidate magnetic equilibria remains vast, and high-resolution turbulence simulations are computationally expensive. A unifying feature of fluid ( Kolmogorov, 1991 ; Kraichnan, 1959 ) , MHD ( Goldreich & Sridhar, 1995 ) , and gyrokinetic ( Bañón Navarro et al., 2011 ) turbulence theory is that free energy tends to cascade from large scales to small scales through local interactions in phase space, and these cascades are well-described by power laws 1 1 1 Power laws typically arise when a scale-local transfer of energy occurs, and a separation between energy injection and dissipation scales exists. The relevance of scale locality to energy cascades in gyrokinetics has been studied in detail by Barnes et al. (2011) and Teaca et al. (2017) . In some systems of interest, inverse cascades occur, driving invariants from small scales to large scales. The theory of inverse cascades has been developed for several two-dimensional systems ( Hasegawa & Mima, 1978 ; Plunk et al., 2010 ) , yet an open question remains about their applicability to the full five-dimensional gyrokinetic system. . Therefore, models that can accurately calculate large-scale quantities, including spectra and heat fluxes, without needing to resolve small scales, are both desirable and plausible. In the field of fluid turbulence modeling, two successful approaches to constructing reduced, lower-resolution models that capture large-scale behavior are Reynolds-Averaged Navier-Stokes (RANS, Reynolds (1895) ) and large eddy simulation (LES, Deardorff (1970) ). LES also has been used to build reduced models of gyrokinetic turbulence ( Bañón Navarro et al., 2014 ) . These formalisms accelerate turbulence simulations by averaging over time and filtering out the small-scale dynamics. Closure models provide another pathway to filter out the small scales while retaining accurate large-scale statistics. In kinetic plasma physics, Hammett & Perkins (1990) developed a landmark analytic linear closure for the low-frequency response to small Langmuir oscillations. An alternative method for building reduced models is to use data-driven, statistical techniques like machine learning (ML) and Bayesian optimization. In recent years, the proliferation of ML models has led to advancements in pattern identification and model construction for magnetic fusion. Some example applications include improved prediction and avoidance of tokamak disruptions using the DECAF framework ( Piccione et al., 2020 ) and on the DIII-D tokamak ( Rea et al., 2019 ; Fu et al., 2020 ) , improved active-feedback plasma control systems with reinforcement learning ( Degrave et al., 2022 ; Seo et al., 2024 ; Kerboua-Benlarbi et al., 2024 ) , optimized execution of gyrokinetic simulations with the PORTALS framework ( Rodriguez-Fernandez et al., 2022 ) , and accelerated, low-resolution turbulence simulations ( Greif et al., 2023 ; Castagna et al., 2024 ; Clavier et al., 2025 ) . Data-driven, configuration space ( Ma et al., 2020 ; Qin et al., 2023 ) and heat flux ( Ingelsten et al., 2024 ; Huang et al., 2025 ) closure models of Landau damping have also been developed. In this paper, we choose to use the one-dimensional, collisionless Vlasov-Poisson system as a test problem for implementing an ML closure in velocity space. This system is the one-dimensional, electrostatic limit of the full five-dimensional gyrokinetic system ( Parker & Dellar, 2015 ) . It models dynamics parallel to the magnetic field, and it contains a quadratic nonlinearity present in the full gyrokinetic system. These features make the Vlasov-Poisson system a suitable foundation to assess the future potential for a closure model to be developed for gyrokinetic turbulence. In parallel velocity space, we use properties of the Hermite basis to cast the objective of reducing resolution requirements as a closure problem. The Hermite basis has been used extensively to solve problems in kinetic plasma dynamics ( Armstrong, 1967 ; Grant & Feix, 1967 ; Joyce et al., 1971 ; Gibelli & Shizgal, 2006 ; Zocco & Schekochihin, 2011 ; Loureiro et al., 2013 ; Parker & Dellar, 2015 ; Kanekar et al., 2015 ; Jorge et al., 2017 ; Adkins & Schekochihin, 2018 ; Mandell et al., 2018 ; Frei et al., 2023 ) . In this work, we opt to focus on velocity space because the Hermite basis naturally expresses the interaction between scales in velocity space as local interactions in a coupled hierarchy of moments. This property of the moment formalism directly presents a single-term target for a closure. Specifically, the interaction between resolved scales and unresolved scales in velocity space appears as a single unknown term in an equation in this representation. In contrast, the spectral representation of configuration space introduces some nonlocal interactions across scales, complicating the development of a closure model. Additionally, the Hermite basis explicitly expresses conservation laws for particle number, momentum, and energy as evolution equations for the lowest-order moments. These properties allow us to develop a closure that preserves the low-order conservation laws. More details on the closure problem are presented in Section 3.5 . We use reservoir computing, an ML architecture, to implement a spectral, proof-of-concept, velocity-space closure for the moment hierarchy that maintains accurate spectra and reduces resolution requirements. The reservoir computing model maintains an internal representation of the

Read the complete text