The β \beta -decay spectrum of Tritiated graphene: combining nuclear quantum mechanics with Density Functional Theory

Andrea Casale, Angelo Esposito, Guido Menichetti, Valentina Tozzini · 2025

Read The β \beta -decay spectrum of Tritiated graphene: combining nuclear quantum mechanics with Density Functional Theory by Andrea Casale, Angelo Esposito, Guido Menichetti, Valentina Tozzini (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-13259.txt.

Introduction

Graphene laced with tritium could serve future neutrino hunts, and a 2025 paper by Andrea Casale and co-authors models how the tritium decays while stuck to that sheet. Tritium decays to helium by beta decay, and the sheet beneath it can bend the energy pattern of the outgoing electron.

The team joins density functional theory, which gives the forces between the atoms, with quantum calculations of the decay itself. They test several loadings and layouts of tritium on the graphene. From those they build the expected event rate, folding in some of the sheet's own quantum motion. The results help judge which host material suits a precision neutrino experiment, and the method links nuclear and materials physics in a fresh way.

Catalog record

CREATORAndrea Casale, Angelo Esposito, Guido Menichetti, Valentina Tozzini
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE62 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-13259

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The β \beta -decay spectrum of Tritiated graphene: combining nuclear quantum mechanics with Density Functional Theory Andrea Casale, Angelo Esposito, Guido Menichetti, Valentina Tozzini Abstract We present the results of a multi-methodological study aimed at investigating the interaction between graphene and Tritium during its β \beta -decay to Helium, under different levels of loading and geometrical configurations. We combine Density Functional Theory (DFT), to evaluate the interaction potentials, with calculations of the decay rate, in order to study the consequences that the presence of the substrate has on the β \beta -decay spectrum of Tritium. We determine the shape of the event rate, accounting for the effects of (part of) the corresponding condensed matter degrees of freedom. In the context of future neutrino experiments, our results provide important information aimed at the optimization of hosting material, as well as the determination of the physics reach. Furthermore, our work outlines a novel theoretical and computational scheme to address a question at the boundary between high and low energy physics. This requires non-conventional declinations of DFT combined with full quantum treatments of the nuclear configuration involved in the decay process. I Introduction Of all the known fundamental particles, neutrinos are arguably the most elusive ones, mostly because they couple to the rest of ordinary matter only via weak interactions, which, at low energies, are extremely feeble. Moreover, while within the renormalizable part of the Standard Model they are exactly massless, the experimental observation of the oscillations between their three flavors (i.e. electronic, muonic and tauonic), indeed imply that they do carry mass Fukuda et al. 1998 ; Ahmad et al. 2001 ; Ahmad et al. 2002 ; de Salas et al. 2021 ; Esteban et al. 2020 ; Capozzi et al. 2021 . These masses, however, are still unknown, both in their absolute value (i.e., the mass of the lightest neutrino), and in their ordering (i.e., whether the lightest neutrino is mostly within the electronic or tauonic family). A possible way to measure these properties is by looking at the spectrum of the electrons emitted by \beta -decay processes of unstable nuclei. Among them, a notable instance is that of the decay of Tritium, \displaystyle{\rm T}\to{{}^{3}}{\rm He}+e+\bar{\nu}_{e}\,, (1) which produces an electron, an anti-neutrino and a Helium nucleus. The shape of the spectrum for values of the electron’s energy close to the maximum allowed one — the so-called end-point — is the most sensitive to the neutrino masses, which can then in principle be inferred from its precise measurement. The Tritium lifetime of about 12 years, and its relatively low energy end-point of 18.6 keV, makes it particularly amenable to this aim, motivating a series of Tritium \beta -decay experiments ( Robertson et al. 1991 ; Kawakami et al. 1991 ; Holzschuh et al. 1992 ; Stoeffl and Decman 1995 , e.g.,) . The current best laboratory bound on the neutrino (effective) mass has been set by the KATRIN experiment, which obtained m_{\nu}<0.45 eV, using gaseous molecular Tritium Aker et al. 2019 ; Aker et al. 2022 ; Aker et al. 2024 . Other proposed projects like PTOLEMY Betti et al. 2019a ; Betti et al. 2019b ; Apponi et al. 2022a ; Apponi et al. 2022b ; Farino et al. 2025 or Project8 Esfahani et al. 2022 ; Ashtari Esfahani et al. 2023 aim at improving this bound by employing Tritium in different forms. In particular, PTOLEMY plans to distribute it on a solid substrate, with the advantage of achieving extremely high concentrations, thus maximizing the number of observed events. Albeit with additional difficulties, a similar strategy could also allow the detection of the elusive cosmic neutrino background, via the neutrino capture process Weinberg 1962 ; Cocco et al. 2007 ; Betti et al. 2019b , i.e., \displaystyle\nu_{e}+{\rm T}\to{{}^{3}}{\rm He}+e\,. (2) The substrate of choice has been identified as graphene, whose capability of covalently binding Hydrogen Camiola et al. 2015 in almost 1:1 stoichiometry with Carbon was recently demonstrated for nanoporous samples, displaying up to 90\% loading Betti et al. 2022 . Moreover, its low dimensional nature allows to minimize uncontrolled energy losses for the outgoing electron Apponi et al. 2024 . Thanks to this, the project has the potentiality of reaching an unprecedented sensitivity to the effective neutrino mass (see, e.g., Betti et al. 2019b for an estimate). Figure 1: Scheme of the theoretical framework and calculations performed in this work. Panel (a): Calculation of the matrix element between initial and final states to evaluate the decay rate spectrum. Panel (b): DFT calculation of the Tritium potential on graphene in the initial ground state. Panel (c): Sudden approximation for the calculation of the potential felt by Helium just after the decay. Panel (d): DFT calculation of the electronic relaxation via the Kohn-Sham (KS) scheme. Panel (e): Born-Oppenheimer dynamics (BO-MD) of the system after the electronic relaxation. The electronic relaxation and the vibrational excitations generated after the decay might be used to calculate further distortions to the event rate as well as, potentially, to analyze the signals generated in the substrate by the decay events. In order to determine the possible experimental reach, it is however crucial to understand the effects that solid state phenomena have on the \beta -process. These can be essentially classified in two: (i) by localizing Tritium in the vicinity of a Carbon site, its wave function will not be a simple momentum eigenstate anymore, and (ii) the degrees of freedom of the substrate will now actively participate to the reaction. This affects the electron spectrum, making it qualitatively different from the one predicted for the process in vacuum. Together with the high energy resolution expected for PTOLEMY, this introduces conceptual and practical challenges for both the neutrino mass measurement, and for the detection of cosmic neutrinos Cheipesh et al. 2021 ; Nussinov and Nussinov 2022 ; Tan and Cheianov 2024 ; Apponi et al. 2022b ; Cavoto et al. 2023 . From the theoretical point of view, understanding the effects of the substrate on the energy spectra involves combining, in unconventional ways, very different theoretical approaches and numerical techniques, as those used in two domains which are typically considered as separated: the high energy domain of elementary particles and the low energy domain of solid state physics Menichetti et al. 2025 . This can be understood considering the temporal sequence of events depicted in Fig. 1 . The evaluation of the spectrum involves the calculation of the matrix element between the initial state and the state just after the decay (panel (a)). The state before the decay can be considered as an electronic ground state of Tritium (panel (b)), a configuration that has been well characterized within the last decades Delfino et al. 2024 ; Bellucci and Tozzini 2020 ; Camiola et al. 2015 . In particular, the theoretical studies usually rely on Density Functional Theory (DFT), capable to accurately determine the structural, electronic and dynamical properties of graphene in interaction with other elements Rossi et al. 2015 ; Cavallucci et al. 2019 , and, therefore, the potential felt by Tritium on graphene. In light of this, here we use the standard DFT scheme Kohn and Sham 1965 ; Baroni et al. 2001 , based on

Read the complete text