Turbulence Inhibits Planetesimal Formation in Class 0/I Disks Subject to Infall

Daniel Carrera, Abigail Davenport, Jacob B. Simon, Hans Baehr, Til Birnstiel, Cassandra Hall, David Rea, Sebastian Markus Stammler · 2025

Read Turbulence Inhibits Planetesimal Formation in Class 0/I Disks Subject to Infall by Daniel Carrera, Abigail Davenport, Jacob B. Simon, Hans Baehr, Til Birnstiel, Cassandra Hall, David Rea, Sebastian Markus Stammler (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-13246.txt.

Introduction

Daniel Carrera and co-authors ask whether the youngest planet-forming disks can build planetesimals, the roughly 100-kilometer blocks that grow into planets. Signs suggest planet building starts within the first million years, while fresh material still rains onto the disk. A recent idea holds that this infall pushes dust outward and piles it up at the water snowline, where the streaming instability might take hold. The team tests that idea with a disk model.

Across six model runs, the dust does drift outward and pile up at the snowline, and a second pile forms at the disk's expanding edge. No pile appears at the silicate line. Even so, modest turbulence leaves the dust far too thin at the midplane, at least ten times below what the instability needs. The authors suggest early planetesimals may need calmer angular momentum transport, such as disk winds, or a different formation route.

Catalog record

CREATORDaniel Carrera, Abigail Davenport, Jacob B. Simon, Hans Baehr, Til Birnstiel, Cassandra Hall, David Rea, Sebastian Markus Stammler
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE68 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-13246

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Turbulence Inhibits Planetesimal Formation in Class 0/I Disks Subject to Infall Daniel Carrera, Abigail Davenport, Jacob B. Simon, Hans Baehr, Til Birnstiel, Cassandra Hall, David Rea, Sebastian Markus Stammler Abstract There is growing evidence that planet formation begins early, within the ≲ 1 ​ Myr \lesssim 1{\rm Myr} Class 0/I phase, when infall dominates disk dynamics. Our goal is to determine if Class 0/I disks reach the conditions needed to form planetesimals ( ∼ 100 \sim 100 km planet building blocks) by the streaming instability (SI). We focus on a recent suggestion that early infall causes an “inflationary” phase in which dust grains are advected outward. We modified the DustPy code to build a 1D disk that includes dust evolution, infall, and heating and cooling sources. We ran six models and examined the implications for the SI, taking into account recent works on how the SI responds to external turbulence. In line with other works, we find that grains are advected outward, which leads to “advection-condensation-drift” loop that greatly enhances the dust density at the water snowline. However, we do not see this process at the silicate line. Instead, we find a new pile up at the edge of the expanding disk. However, despite these localized enhancements, even a modest amount of turbulence ( α = 10 − 3 \alpha=10^{-3} ) leaves planetesimal formation far out of reach. The midplane dust-to-gas ratio is at least an order of magnitude below the SI threshold, even taking into account recent results on how dust coagulation boosts the SI. For planetesimals to form in the Class 0/I phase may require a way to transport angular momentum without turbulence (e.g., disk winds) or a non-SI mechanism to form planetesimals. Journal: ApJ I Introduction Planetesimals are \sim 1-1,000 km bodies that are the building blocks of terrestrial planets and the cores of giant planets [ 36 , 37 ] . As such, they are key to understanding the properties and chemical compositions of planetary bodies [ 14 , 60 , 68 , e.g.,] . Despite their importance, the origin of planetesimals is arguably the largest gap in our understanding of planet formation. Theoretical models by Johansen et al. [32] and Cuzzi et al. [20] , together with evidence from the size frequency distribution of present-day asteroids and the cratering record of Vesta [ 59 ] , and the ubiquity of equal-size binaries in the Kuiper belt [ 67 , 27 ] lead to a growing consensus that planetesimals likely formed through the gravitational collapse of a dense cloud of mm-cm size particles, skipping across the intermediate sizes. Among the proposed mechanisms, the streaming instability [ 94 , 33 , 93 , SI,] has drawn the most attention in recent years. One recent success for the SI is the reproduction of the obliquity and angular momentum distributions of trans-Neptunian binaries [ 66 , 65 ] . However, many crucial challenges remain for the SI. The root problem is that the conditions needed to trigger the SI [ 10 , 92 , 42 , 43 ] seem to require larger grains and/or higher solid-to-gas ratios than predicted by dust evolution models. Carrera et al. [9] ’s attempt to reach the conditions for the SI through disk photo-evaporation only resulted in late formation of planetesimals (too late to form planets). Pressure bumps have long been considered promising locations for the SI [ 40 , e.g.,] , as they concentrate solids [ 87 , e.g.,] and reduce the radial pressure gradient, which is a key parameter for the SI [ 79 ] . While work by Carrera et al. [13] showed promising results in the case of relatively large particles, a follow-up study by Carrera & Simon [12] with smaller particles uncovered a new problem: Even if the conditions for the SI are nominally met in a pressure bump, planetesimals may still fail to form for small (possibly more realistic) particle sizes because the growth timescale of the SI may be longer than the crossing time of solids across the bump, at least in the case of pressure bumps that slow down the drifting particles without halting their drift completely. I.1 Streaming Instability in Class 0/I Disks? This paper is another attempt to find a realistic scenario in which a circumstellar disk triggers the SI to form planetesimals, inspired by recent work by Morbidelli et al. [58] , Marschall & Morbidelli [54] , and Estrada & Umurhan [26] . There is growing evidence that planet formation starts early. For one, Class II disks may not contain enough dust mass to reproduce the observed exoplanet population ( Manara et al. 51 but see Mulders et al. 61 and Liu et al. 46 ), suggesting that, at a minimum, the process of converting dust into planetesimals occurs in the Class 0/I stage. Furthermore, the ubiquity of dust rings in ALMA images suggests that giant planet cores also form early, if indeed these rings are the result of giant planets opening gaps along their orbits. Finally, within the context of our own solar system, there is meteoritic evidence that Jupiter’s core formed within the first 1 Myr of the birth of the solar nebula [ 39 , 22 ] . Recently, Morbidelli et al. [58] suggested a scenario in which planetesimals form, via the SI, during an early “inflationary” stage of a Class 0/I disk. The Class 0/I stage corresponds to the time when the star and disk are shrouded by a gas envelope, and infall from the envelope plays an important role in the disk dynamics. Morbidelli et al. [58] argue that, due to magnetic braking, the infall is deposited close to the central star, causing the disk to spread viscously. They built a simple 1D disk with a “two population” model for dust evolution [ 6 ] . They found that the gas outflow combines with condensation/sublimation and radial drift to produce a significant pile up of material. The proposed mechanism is that solids, as well as silicate and water vapor, are advected outward by the gas, cross the condensation line, form large solids, and then drift back in. Marschall & Morbidelli [54] also see this cyclical process, and additionally report a significant pile up of material. In contrast, earlier work [ 5 ] conducted 1D simulations of a protoplanetary disk with infall, following the solid-body rotation infall model of Shu [83] . While their models show regions where dust is advected outward, they do not report the cyclical process suggested by Morbidelli et al. [58] . More recently, Estrada & Umurhan [26] conducted their own investigation of the SI in a 1D disk, using a model of dust growth with multiple dust species, and found a nearly opposite result: the solid concentration, and especially the particle sizes, are not nearly high enough to meet any of the proposed criteria for the SI [ 10 , 92 , 42 , 43 ] . Why did these works reach opposite conclusions? The most notable difference between them is that Morbidelli et al. [58] and Marschall & Morbidelli [54] have an inflationary disk, but a simple treatment of dust growth, while Estrada & Umurhan [26] have a sophisticated model for dust growth,

Read the complete text