Testing for dice control at craps
Stewart N. Ethier · 2025
Read Testing for dice control at craps by Stewart N. Ethier (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-13158.txt.
Introduction
Stewart N Ethier, a solo author, asks how to test a gambling claim in a 2025 paper on craps. Some players say that setting the dice and throwing with care can sway the results and beat the house. A fair test needs a clear model of what such control would look like in data.
Two models from the gambling literature are used, each with a dial for the level of control. Four test scores are proposed and compared: the share of sevens, the share of pass line wins, the average length of a hand, and a ratio test on hand lengths. The setup can test both no control at all and control below a set level.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Stewart N. Ethier |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 75 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-13158
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Testing for dice control at craps Stewart N. Ethier Abstract Dice control involves “setting” the dice and then throwing them carefully, in the hope of influencing the outcomes and gaining an advantage at craps. How does one test for this ability? To specify the alternative hypothesis, we need a statistical model of dice control. Two have been suggested in the gambling literature, namely the Smith–Scott model and the Wong–Shackleford model. Both models are parameterized by θ ∈ [ 0 , 1 ] \theta\in[0,1] , which measures the shooter’s level of control. We propose and compare four test statistics: (a) the sample proportion of 7s; (b) the sample proportion of pass-line wins; (c) the sample mean of hand-length observations; and (d) the likelihood ratio statistic for a hand-length sample. We want to test H 0 : θ = 0 H_{0}:\theta=0 (no control) versus H 1 : θ > 0 H_{1}:\theta>0 (some control). We also want to test H 0 : θ ≤ θ 0 H_{0}:\theta\leq\theta_{0} versus H 1 : θ > θ 0 H_{1}:\theta>\theta_{0} , where θ 0 \theta_{0} is the “break-even point.” For the tests considered we estimate the power, either by normal approximation or by simulation. Keywords : craps; dice control; statistical modeling; hypothesis testing; sample-proportion test; sample-mean test; likelihood ratio test; power. 1 Introduction The idea of dice control as a legal method of advantage play at casino craps is almost as old as the game itself. See the classic text How to Control Fair Dice (c. 1922). One approach is to “set” the dice and then attempt to throw them on-axis, to prevent two opposite faces of each die from appearing face up when the dice come to rest. Complicating this is the requirement that the dice must bounce against the foam-rubber cushion at the opposite end of the table, which is not flat but rather covered with pyramid-shaped deflectors. Dice control is regarded by the casino industry much as ESP is regarded by the psychology profession — as a myth. Yet there are those who claim to be successful dice controllers. Some write books (Kononenko, 1998; Sharpshooter, 2002; Scoblete, 2003, 2015; Scoblete and Dominator, 2010; Dominator, 2024) and some offer seminars/workshops ( https://www.goldentouchcraps.com ; https://www.dicecoach.com ). How can we assess the reliability of such claims? A well-publicized challenge was held in 2004 intended to demonstrate an ability to reduce the probability of a 7 (Wong, 2005, Chap. 8). The shooters were Stanford Wong and Little Joe Green and they threw the dice 500 times in a casino setting, obtaining 74 7s. Viewed as a test of the null hypothesis H_{0}:p(7)=1/6 versus the alternative hypothesis H_{1}:p(7)<1/6 , this resulted in a p -value of 0.144, which falls short of statistical significance. Scott and Smith (2019) attempted to show that a dice-throwing machine could exercise some control. They adopted what we refer to below as the AA set (both dice rotate about the axis through their 1 and 6 faces), and applied a chi-squared goodness-of-fit test to the resulting single-die frequencies. They failed to achieve statistical significance. This experiment may have been motivated by Diaconis, Holmes, and Montgomery (2007), who created a coin-tossing machine with perfect predictability. But clearly, controlling a coin toss caught in one’s hand is not the same thing as controlling a pair of dice thrown onto a craps table. Our aim here is to study statistical tests based on four relevant test statistics: (a) the sample proportion of 7s; (b) the sample proportion of pass-line wins; (c) the sample mean of hand-length observations; and (d) the likelihood ratio statistic for a hand-length sample. To explain these terms (pass line, hand length), we must briefly review the game of craps. The basic bet at craps is the pass-line bet . The initial roll is called the come-out roll . The bet is won if 7 or 11 appears (a natural ) and lost if 2, 3, or 12 appears (a craps number ). Any other number (4, 5, 6, 8, 9, or 10) becomes the point . Once a point has been established, subsequent rolls are called point rolls . If the point reappears before a 7 appears, the bet is won. If a 7 appears before the point reappears, the bet is lost. The latter event is called a seven-out . A winning pass-line bet pays 1 to 1. Once a pass-line bet is resolved, the next roll is a new come-out roll, and the process begins again. Under the assumption of fair dice and no control, the expected gain from a one-unit pass-line bet is -7/495 . The shooter is the player who rolls the dice. The shooter continues to roll until he or she sevens out, at which time the role of shooter is offered to the next player in clockwise order. The sequence of rolls by the shooter, from the initial come-out roll to the seven-out, is called the shooter’s hand . The length of the shooter’s hand is the number of rolls, inclusive of the initial come-out roll and the seven-out. That number is a random variable assuming values in \{2,3,4,\ldots\} . Under the assumption of fair dice and no control, its mean is 1671/196\approx 8.52551 and its variance is 1768701/38416\approx 46.0407 . To properly formulate a test based on any of the aforementioned statistics, we need a statistical model of dice control. Two such models have been suggested in the gambling literature, the Smith–Scott model (2018), which assumes an ability to roll the dice on-axis, and the Wong–Shackleford model (2005, 2023), which assumes an ability to roll the dice in a correlated way without favoring on-axis rolls. Both models are parameterized by \theta\in[0,1] , which measures the shooter’s level of control. A third statistical model was proposed by Grosjean (2009, p. 471). Here the probability of a 7 is \theta and the remaining probability mass accrues to the other 10 dice totals proportionally; more precisely, p(7,\theta)=\theta;\quad p(x,\theta)=(1-\theta)\frac{6-|x-7|}{30},\quad x\in\{2,3,4,5,6,8,9,10,11,12\}. Grosjean acknowledged that this model “may not be a proper representation of the physical mechanism for altering” the probability of a 7, and indeed, because it does not take dice setting explicitly into account, we regard it as lacking a plausible basis. The interpretation of \theta differs in our two models, so it may be useful to reparameterize the models with a parameter \eta that has the same interpretation in both, such as letting \eta be the expected gain from a one-unit pass-line bet. In that case, we want to test H_{0}:\eta=-7/495 (no control) versus H_{1}:\eta>-7/495 (some control). Alternatively, we may want to statistically demonstrate not just an ability to exercise some control but an ability to exercise control sufficient to provide an advantage at craps. In that case we require the composite H_{0}:\eta\leq 0 (control not sufficient to provide an advantage) versus H_{1}:\eta>0 (control sufficient to provide an advantage). A similar distinction was made in the context of testing for roulette-wheel bias (Ethier, 1982). We introduce the Smith–Scott model in Section 2 , arguing that its original formulation can be improved with a simple modification. Following a brief discussion of dice setting, we introduce the Wong–Shackleford model in Section 3 . In Section 4 we reparameterize both models so that