Amplitudes and partial wave unitarity bounds

Luigi C. Bresciani, Gabriele Levati, Paride Paradisi · 2025

Read Amplitudes and partial wave unitarity bounds by Luigi C. Bresciani, Gabriele Levati, Paride Paradisi (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-12855.txt.

Introduction

Luigi Bresciani, Gabriele Levati, and Paride Paradisi develop unitarity bounds for scattering in a 2025 paper. Spinor-helicity tools form the base of their formalism. Standard bounds struggle with many-particle and high-spin cases.

Processes with two or more particles on each side are covered. Theories with spin two or higher, such as gravity models, are included. The authors stress how these bounds pair with positivity bounds. Together they fence in the allowed space of effective theories. Future colliders make the many-particle cases practical, not just formal. Readers get sharper limits for judging new physics proposals.

Catalog record

CREATORLuigi C. Bresciani, Gabriele Levati, Paride Paradisi
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE61 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-12855

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Amplitudes and partial wave unitarity bounds Luigi C. Bresciani, Gabriele Levati, Paride Paradisi Abstract We develop a formalism, based on spinor-helicity techniques, to generalize the formulation of partial wave unitarity bounds. We discuss unitarity bounds for N → M N\to M (with N , M ≥ 2 N,M\geq 2 ) scattering processes—relevant for high-energy future colliders—and spin-2 or higher-spin theories—relevant for effective field theories of gravity—that are not approachable by standard methods. Moreover, we emphasize the power and complementarity of positivity and partial wave unitarity bounds to constrain the parameter space of effective field theories. Introduction. New interactions of nature can be probed through a wide variety of experimental tests, encompassing direct searches of new particles at high-energy colliders, indirect signals in low-energy precision measurements, as well as cosmological observations. On the theoretical side, perturbative unitarity—relying on the properties of the scattering S -matrix—provides an independent and complementary way to infer upper limits on the strength of such interactions, irrespectively of any experimental information. Generally, unitarity violation signals the breakdown of the low-energy description of a theory which can be restored by introducing new degrees of freedom or a new strong dynamics at the scale where unitarity is broken. In the past, unitarity bounds for the WW scattering process led to the famous no-lose Higgs theorem, which implied an upper bound on the Higgs boson mass below the TeV scale [ 1 , 2 ] . Such a theoretical prediction was of paramount importance in motivating the construction of the LHC at CERN. More recently, unitarity bounds have been extensively discussed in the literature to assess the range of validity of Effective Field Theories (EFTs) [ 3 , 4 , 5 , 6 ] . Indeed, non-renormalizable interactions generate scattering amplitudes growing with energy, thus leading to unitarity violation at some large energy scale. As a result, a correct interpretation of experimental data, such as those inherent to tails of kinematical distributions, has to be necessarily supplemented by unitarity bounds. The standard way of implementing unitarity bounds relies on 2\to 2 scatterings of particles with helicities h_{i} and proceeds in two steps: i) expansion of the helicity amplitudes into partial waves a_{h_{i}}^{J} with fixed total angular momentum J by means of the Wigner rotation matrix [ 7 ] and ii) diagonalization of the partial wave scattering matrix. In this coupled channel analysis, the most stringent limit is then obtained by imposing the partial wave unitarity bound |a_{h_{i}}^{J}|_{\rm max}\lesssim 1 on the largest eigenvalue. Although very popular, the above method suffers from two serious shortcomings which significantly reduce its regime of applicability. On the one hand, partial wave decompositions are known only for 2\to 2 processes. However, since in many cases 2\to N (with N>2 ) amplitudes show a faster growth with energy than 2\to 2 amplitudes, unitarity bounds from 2\to N processes are expected to dominate at high energies, which can be probed at future colliders such as FCC-ee [ 8 ] or a high-energy Muon Collider [ 9 ] . On the other hand, even in the 2\to 2 case, a standard partial wave decomposition for spin-2 or higher-spin theories—relevant for EFTs of gravity—is impracticable given the difficulty in evaluating the amplitudes via Feynman rules. In this respect, on-shell methods—which proved to be very efficient to capture ultraviolet quantum effects of EFTs [ 10 , 11 , 12 , 13 , 14 , 15 , 16 , 17 , 18 , 19 , 20 , 21 , 22 ] —seem to be the ideal tool also to probe possible unitarity violations of EFTs at high energies. The primary goal of this Letter is to generalize the formulation of partial wave unitarity bounds in order to overcome the above shortcomings. In particular, we elaborate on a vectorial formalism [ 23 ] , based on the spinor-helicity formalism [ 24 ] , which will allow us to determine the amplitude basis thanks to the amplitude-operator correspondence [ 25 , 26 , 27 , 28 ] . As a result, we find the generalization of the Wigner rotation matrix entering the partial wave expansion of N\to M scattering amplitudes. This will enable us to set the most stringent partial wave unitarity bounds on those EFT interactions that generate contact 2\to 3 scattering amplitudes. Furthermore, working in a Minkowski background, we discuss partial wave unitarity bounds for EFTs of gravity and higher-spin theories, which have been conjectured to be connected to weakly coupled conformal field theories through the AdS/CFT correspondence [ 29 ] . The recent direct observation of gravitational waves from merging black holes opens the possibility of probing the theory of gravity in the strong regime at an unprecedented level. It is therefore very interesting to explore which EFT extensions of gravity could be detected. In this respect, our work serves as an important guide for exploring viable models that are consistent with first principles of quantum field theory. As an interesting byproduct of our study, we analyze for the first time the complementarity and interplay of positivity bounds [ 30 ] —stemming from the analyticity and causality of scattering amplitudes—and partial wave unitarity bounds. The resulting constraints will be of utmost importance to connect experimental data at colliders to fundamental properties of EFTs. Examples include the possibility to use the above bounds as a prior in statistical interpretations and to design phenomenological studies to test positivity and partial wave unitarity bounds at colliders. Generalized partial wave unitarity bounds. The partial wave analysis allows one to project a generic amplitude \ket{\mathcal{A}_{i\to f}} onto a kinematic basis \ket{\mathcal{B}^{J}_{i\to f}} with definite angular momentum J as follows \ket{\mathcal{A}_{i\to f}}=\sum_{J}a^{J}_{i\to f}\ket{\mathcal{B}^{J}_{i\to f}}\,, (1) where a^{J}_{i\to f} are the partial wave coefficients. The fundamental building blocks of such a decomposition are the Poincaré Clebsch-Gordan coefficients \mathcal{C}_{\mathcal{I}\to*}^{J,h} defined as [ 23 ] \langle{P,J,h|\mathcal{I}}\rangle=\mathcal{C}_{\mathcal{I}\to*}^{J,h}\,\delta^{(4)}\!\left(P-\sum_{i\in\mathcal{I}}p_{i}\right)\!\,, (2) namely the overlap between the multiparticle state \ket{\mathcal{I}} and the Poincaré irreducible multiparticle state \ket{P,J,h} , where h denotes the helicity. The coefficients \mathcal{C}_{\mathcal{I}\to*}^{J,h} can be seen as elements of the complex vector space V_{\mathcal{I}\to*} , i.e. , \ket{\mathcal{C}_{\mathcal{I}\to*}^{J,h}}\in V_{\mathcal{I}\to*} , and, correspondingly, the angular momentum basis elements are given by \ket{\mathcal{B}^{J}_{i\to f}}=\sum_{h}\ket{\mathcal{C}_{i\to*}^{J,h}}\otimes\ket{\mathcal{C}_{*\to f}^{J,h}}\in V_{i\to f}\,, (3) where \ket{\mathcal{C}^{J,h}_{*\to\mathcal{I}}}=\ket{(\mathcal{C}^{J,h}_{\mathcal{I}\to*})^{*}}\in V_{\ast\to\mathcal{I}} and V_{i\to f}=V_{i\to*}\otimes V_{*\to f} . The partial wave coefficients a_{i\to f}^{J} can then be conveniently obtained by extending the inner product in V_{\mathcal{I}\to*} [ 31 ] to the vector space V_{i\to f} as follows \displaystyle a_{i\to f}^{J} \displaystyle=\frac{1}{2J+1}\langle\mathcal{B}^{J}_{i\to f}|\mathcal{A}_{i\to f}\rangle \displaystyle=\frac{1}{2J+1}\int\text{d}\Phi_{i}\,\text{d}\Phi_{f}\,\mathcal{A}_{i\to f}\left(\mathcal{B}^{J}_{i\to f}\right)^{*}\,, (4) where \text{d}\Phi_{\mathcal{I}} refers to the Lorentz invariant phase space measure associated with \ket{\mathcal{I}} 1 1 1 Explicit parameterizations for the n -body phase space in terms of spinor-helicity variables are available in [ 58 , 59 , 60 , 61 , 11 ] . . Notice that we crucially chose the basis normalization \langle\mathcal{B}^{J}_{i\to f}|\mathcal{B}^{J^{\prime}}_{i\to f}\rangle=(2J+1)\delta^{JJ^{\prime}} in order to obtain the partial wave unitarity bounds in the standard form. Indeed, this choice implies \int\text{d}\Phi_{X}\,\ket{\mathcal{B}^{J}_{i\to X}}\otimes\ket{\mathcal{B}_{X\to f}^{J^{\prime}}}=\ket{\mathcal{B}_{i\to f}^{J}}\delta^{JJ^{\prime}}\,, (5) which, when applied to the generalized optical theorem \ket{\mathcal{A}_{i\to f}}-\ket{\mathcal{A}_{f\to i}^{*}}=i\sum_{X}\int\text{d}\Phi_{X}\,\ket{\mathcal{A}_{i\to X}}\otimes\ket{\mathcal{A}_{f\to X}^{*}} (6) leads to a_{i\to f}^{J}-\left(a_{f\to i}^{J}\right)^{*}=i\sum_{X}a_{i\to X}^{J}\left(a_{f\to X}^{J}\right)^{*} (7) and, in turn, to the partial wave unitarity bounds \displaystyle\left|\real a_{i\to i}^{J}\right|\leq 1\,,~~~~0\leq\imaginary a_{i\to i}^{J}\leq 2\,,~~~~\left|a^{J}_{i\to f}\right|\leq 1\,, (8) where i\neq f . In practice, the determination

Read the complete text