Searching for Bloch wave packets with (almost) definite momentum direction

Arseni Goussev, Gregory V. Morozov · 2025

Read Searching for Bloch wave packets with (almost) definite momentum direction by Arseni Goussev, Gregory V. Morozov (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-12489.txt.

Introduction

Arseni Goussev and Gregory Morozov examine how packets of quantum waves move through a repeating landscape in a 2025 physics paper. A particle in a periodic setting travels in Bloch waves, which can glide without fading, much like free particles. The authors ask whether such a packet can keep a nearly fixed direction of motion, as free packets do.

The question matters for a planned hunt for quantum backflow. In backflow, a particle's chance of being found drifts against its own direction of motion, a strange effect never yet seen in the lab. Solid-state systems are candidate platforms for the hunt. Whether Bloch packets hold their direction well enough shapes how such an experiment should be designed.

Catalog record

CREATORArseni Goussev, Gregory V. Morozov
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE46 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-12489

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Searching for Bloch wave packets with (almost) definite momentum direction Arseni Goussev, Gregory V. Morozov Abstract The motion of a quantum particle in a one-dimensional periodic potential can be described in terms of Bloch wave packets. Like free-particle wave packets, they can propagate without attenuation. Here, we examine this similarity more closely by investigating whether Bloch wave packets can maintain a definite – or nearly definite – momentum direction, a property inherent to free-particle wave packets. This question is particularly relevant to the feasibility of using solid-state-based systems in the search for the first experimental realization of quantum backflow, a quantum interference effect in which a particle’s probability density flows in a direction opposite to its momentum. I Introduction When a quantum particle moves through a periodic potential, its behavior differs fundamentally from that of a classical particle. According to the celebrated Bloch theory, a perfectly periodic potential becomes effectively transparent to a quantum matter wave of suitable energy, allowing it to propagate “without attenuation because of the coherent constructive interference of the scattered waves” Ashcroft and Mermin 1976 . As Kittel states it, “matter waves can propagate freely in a periodic structure,” and “Bloch functions can be assembled into wave packets to represent electrons that propagate freely through the potential field of the ion cores” Kittel 2004 . This free-particle-like motion of an electron through the periodic potential of a crystal is crucial for understanding the electrical properties of solids, such as the emergence of ballistic transport in mesoscopic systems Holcomb 1999 ; Jalabert 2016 . The resemblance between quantum particle propagation in periodic potentials and in free space suggests that mesoscopic systems could be used to explore quantum backflow -- a classically impossible effect in which the probability density of a particle moves in a direction opposite to its momentum 1 1 1 The body of literature on quantum backflow is substantial, and a full review is beyond our scope. Some of the key theoretical developments can be found in Refs. Bracken and Melloy 1994 ; Eveson et al. 2005 ; Berry 2010 . For an accessible introduction, we refer the reader to Ref. Yearsley and Halliwell 2013 , while Refs. Bracken 2021 ; Barbier and Goussev 2025 provide a comprehensive list of more recent advancements in the field. . Quantum backflow is typically considered for a free particle on a line. The particle is prepared in a quantum state with a definite momentum direction, assumed to be positive for concreteness. Since free-space evolution conserves the momentum direction, any measurement of the particle’s momentum at a later time is guaranteed to yield a positive value, albeit of a random magnitude. Quantum backflow then manifests as the emergence of a negative probability current at certain points in space and time, meaning that despite having positive momentum, the particle can locally move in the negative direction. Although quantum backflow was first recognized as a distinct phenomenon over three decades ago Bracken and Melloy 1994 , it has yet to be experimentally demonstrated. Significant progress has been achieved in laboratory studies of its optical analog Eliezer et al. 2020 ; Daniel et al. 2022 ; Ghosh et al. 2023 ; Zhang et al. 2025 , but no experiment has successfully observed quantum backflow with massive particles, such as electrons or atoms. (An experimental scheme utilizing Bose-Einstein condensates was proposed in Refs. Palmero et al. 2013 ; Mardonov et al. 2014 , but to our knowledge, it has never been realized in a laboratory.) The challenge lies in the fact that quantum backflow is inherently weak – according to theory, less than 4\% of the total probability can be transported against the particle’s momentum Bracken and Melloy 1994 ; Eveson et al. 2005 ; Penz et al. 2006 – as well as in the exotic nature of the theoretical backflow-maximizing state, which is spatially unbounded and has infinite mean energy Yearsley et al. 2012 . (Some of these difficulties can be mitigated by considering quantum backflow in a circular geometry Goussev 2021 .) Identifying favorable physical systems is therefore crucial for making the first experimental observation of the effect possible, as well as for exploring potential technological applications. A promising approach to realizing quantum backflow experimentally is to use electrically charged particles moving along an effectively one-dimensional channel, as proposed in Ref. Bracken and Melloy 1994 . Since the electric current is proportional to the probability current, detecting a current (divided by charge) flowing opposite to the particle’s momentum would serve as experimental confirmation of quantum backflow. In this regard, an electronic wave packet propagating ballistically through a mesoscopic quantum wire presents an appealing experimental scenario. This raises a crucial question: does the dynamics of an electron in the periodic potential of a crystal lattice allow for time-dependent states with positive momentum, which are essential for accessing quantum backflow physics? In other words, do there exist normalizable superpositions of Bloch waves – henceforth referred to as Bloch wave packets – whose momentum maintains a definite direction at all times? If not, what is the highest possible probability that a momentum measurement performed on a Bloch wave packet yields a positive value? Moreover, does this probability remain constant, or does it change in time as the particle moves through the crystal? These questions are the focus of the present study. While the properties of stationary Bloch waves in one-dimensional periodic potentials have been extensively studied Cottey 1971 ; Eastham 1973 ; Morozov and Sprung 2011 ; Ruz-Cuen and Gutiérrez-Vega 2021 , time-dependent Bloch wave packets have received relatively little attention. Nonetheless, some important differences between the motion of Bloch wave packets and that of free particles have been investigated. Kroemer first observed that the propagation of a single-band Bloch wave packet with a narrow quasi-momentum distribution is not uniform but rather “similar to the motion of a caterpillar”: the wave packet undergoes periodic shape variations superimposed on an average velocity, equal to the group velocity Kroemer 1975 . The origin of these shape variations was later elucidated by Churchill, who showed that a narrow-quasi-momentum wave packet can be expressed as a discrete superposition of “subpackets” with distinct but constant shapes, all propagating at the same group velocity while having different phase velocities Churchill 1977a . Additional insights and methods for analyzing the instantaneous shape, position, and velocity of various features of Bloch wave packet envelopes are discussed in Refs. Churchill 1977b ; Churchill and Holmstrom 1987 . In this paper, we identify and explore another key difference between Bloch wave packets and free-particle wave packets: unlike the latter, the former cannot maintain a definite momentum direction. Specifically, we show that Bloch wave packets composed of Bloch waves from a single allowed energy band can never have a definite momentum direction, even instantaneously. In contrast, those involving multiple energy bands may attain a definite direction at certain times but cannot maintain it indefinitely. Then, considering the case of a cosine potential, we examine how its amplitude affects the maximum probability of the particle’s momentum being positive. Overall, our findings suggest that a quantum particle in a one-dimensional periodic potential – such as an electron in a ballistic quantum wire – is not an ideal

Read the complete text