Towards an AI Observatory for the Nuclear Sector: A tool for anticipatory governance
Aditi Verma, Elizabeth Williams · 2025
Read Towards an AI Observatory for the Nuclear Sector: A tool for anticipatory governance by Aditi Verma, Elizabeth Williams (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-12358.txt.
Introduction
Artificial intelligence is seeping into nuclear research and operations faster than anyone is tracking its risks. Aditi Verma and Elizabeth Williams call for governing this spread before surprises force the issue. Their proposal has two parts. One is an anticipatory governance system for AI across the nuclear sector. The other is a global AI observatory to make that foresight real, watching what models are deployed where and for what.
The paper sketches the observatory's shape by borrowing from science and technology studies, public policy, and futures research. Safety, security, and safeguards consequences of embedded AI are the blind spot the observatory would illuminate. The authors argue a watching brief, held globally and early, beats scrambling after an incident in a sector where mistakes carry unusual weight.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Aditi Verma, Elizabeth Williams |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 28 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-12358
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Towards an AI Observatory for the Nuclear Sector: A tool for anticipatory governance Aditi Verma, Elizabeth Williams Abstract . AI models are rapidly becoming embedded in all aspects of nuclear energy research and work but the safety, security, and safeguards consequences of this embedding are not well understood. In this paper, we call for the creation of an anticipatory system of governance for AI in the nuclear sector as well as the creation of a global AI observatory as a means for operationalizing anticipatory governance. The paper explores the contours of the nuclear AI observatory and an anticipatory system of governance by drawing on work in science and technology studies, public policy, and foresight studies. † † journalyear: 2025 † † conference: April 26, 2025; Yokohama, Japan; † † ccs: Security and privacy Usability in security and privacy † † ccs: Human-centered computing HCI theory, concepts and models 1. Introduction For many countries, nuclear energy is seen as a key ingredient of low-carbon energy systems - a view that is contributing to significant growth in the nuclear sector worldwide. At the same time, a circular relationship between AI and nuclear energy is rapidly emerging in which AI energy demand is driving interest in new nuclear energy technologies and simultaneously AI models are themselves becoming rapidly embedded in all aspects of research and work in the nuclear sector. Though largely ‘safe’, nuclear energy technologies are nevertheless high-hazard technologies, and the embedding of AI in nuclear work and research, including its implications for safety, security, and safeguards, is not well understood. The safe operation of the existing reactor designs is the result of systems of safety and governance that are decades in the making and include extensive trial and error by organizations across the nuclear industry ( Meserve2009-dc ; Meserve2022-um ; Verma2021-qh ) , information sharing, training, and accreditation of operators and other professionals in the nuclear sector ( Miller2012-hw ; Rees2009-qp ) , creation of norms and a culture of safety ( Linde2005-uc ; Institute_of_Nuclear_Power_Operations2012-ml ) , the development of predictive models for understanding and mitigating modes of failure in reactor systems ( Verma2024-hn ) , and extensive oversight and governance by national regulatory agencies as well as, in some cases, self-regulators ( Rees2009-qp ) . The emergence and rapid embedding of AI in the nuclear sector (particularly at a time when new nuclear energy technologies are approaching deployment) has the potential to undermine the existing nuclear safety infrastructure by introducing new and unexpected modes of failure in existing and new reactor systems, creating unanticipated security and safeguards vulnerabilities, and deskilling operational, regulatory, and even research personnel. As noted, the potential implications of embedding AI in the nuclear sector are not well understood and only now are starting to be articulated by nuclear safety regulators around the world ( Canadian-Nuclear-Safety-Commission-UK-Office-for-Nuclear-Regulation-US-Nuclear-Regulatory-Commission2024-xo ) . Given these concerns, and the need to steward a safe embedding of AI in the nuclear sector even as we potentially transition to use new nuclear energy technologies, we propose to create an anticipatory system of governance for AI in the nuclear sector. This paper outlines our reasoning for proposing this approach to support appropriate use of AI in the nuclear sector. Many of the existing regulatory approaches for the nuclear sector stem from lessons learned from past nuclear accidents, such as Three Mile Island, Chernobyl, and Fukushima. Studies of such accidents have repeatedly demonstrated that complex and sometimes unpredictable or emergent combinations of technical, human, and organizational interactions and failures ( Dekker2011-gk ) often play a role (see ( Leveson2024 ) for a brief summary of several accidents and subsequent findings). History has taught us the impact of such accidents (even with no lives lost) is global and can include large scale displacements of humans, disruption of economic activity, impacts on energy prices and energy security, cancellation of nuclear construction projects, and reputational losses for the nuclear industry ( Kessides2012 ) . It is for this reason that an oft-repeated saying in the nuclear industry is that ”an accident anywhere is an accident everywhere” ( Unknown2005-cx ) . The nuclear power industry (and therefore, the energy industry as a whole) ebbs and flows with societal trust in nuclear energy systems; the vitality of the nuclear power industry is marked by periods of de-investment that are directly timed to nuclear accident-related headlines. The decisions on how the technical, human, and organizational elements of nuclear systems interact, and the institutional and normative environments in which they function, are made on different timescales, in many cases even decades before an accident occurs (a phenomenon referred to as ”slow disasters” which result from poor or deferred decision-making ( Knowles2014-oi ) ). At the Fukushima Daiichi site, for example, decisions about the height of the seawall, the placement of the emergency diesel generators, the design of the containment (and many other factors) were made before construction began, but all ultimately contributed to the severity of the accident. Decisions being made now concerning the integration of AI in the design, operation, and regulation of nuclear energy technologies, if not made carefully and in a well-considered manner, could potentially be contributory or even initiating factors to accidents in the future as well as security and safeguards vulnerabilities. All of this is to say that the consequences of AI adoption in nuclear energy systems, and the potential interaction of AI models with each other and with the human, organizational, institutional, and technical parts of the system have to be anticipated . Anticipatory governance, which has its roots in science and technology studies ( Guston2014-wi ) , administration and management ( Bachler2004-jq ) , and environmental studies and policy ( Gupta2002-dd ) , can be defined as the societal capacity to sense, synthesize, and act on a diverse set of signals, trends, and drivers to manage an emerging technology ( Guston2014-wi ; Smith2020-wb ) . This form of governance is proposed as a means of governing emergent technologies characterized as being both “high stakes and high uncertainty” for their likely use cases, and deliberately integrates local contexts, diverse knowledge systems, and interactions between social and technical systems of relevance to the technology being governed in its process ( foley2019 ) . The integration of AI in nuclear facilities represents the integration of two classes of technologies that may in their own right meet the “high stakes and high uncertainty” characteristics mentioned above. Appropriately identifying how to predict and manage future problems resulting from the integration of AI in nuclear contexts is therefore urgent — particularly when considering the possible significant expansion of the use of nuclear energy around the world driven, in a circular way, in large part by the energy needs of AI models themselves. At the last two COP conferences over 30 countries committed to tripling nuclear capacity by 2050 ( Gross2023-rz ; UnknownUnknown-zy ) (over and above the 400+ nuclear reactors that operate around the world today and the 60+ reactors under construction). An anticipatory system of governance is needed to navigate the potential risks and uncertainties of large-scale use and adoption of AI across an expanding nuclear sector. To demonstrate this, we will: discuss how AI is already being used or researched in