How Accidental was Inflation?
and Keith A. Olive · 2025
Read How Accidental was Inflation? by and Keith A. Olive (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-12283.txt.
Introduction
Ignatios Antoniadis, John Ellis, Wenqi Ke, Dimitri V Nanopoulos, and Keith A Olive ask whether the universe's explosive first moment was a fine-tuning accident, in this 2025 paper. Microwave background data increasingly favor inflation models mimicking Starobinsky's R plus R-squared gravity. That model has a flaw: it needs the inflaton field to start at a large value, where effective field theory may break down and swampland arguments predict trouble.
The usual patch, no-scale supergravity, fits the data only by tuning a parameter to one part in a hundred thousand. The authors instead build the Starobinsky model inside string theory, where the deformation parameter is not chosen but calculated, and lands near the needed value anyway. Inside that range, some settings fit the combined Planck, ACT, and DESI data more comfortably, while the allowed field range stays tame. Inflation, they conclude, may be generic rather than accidental.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | and Keith A. Olive |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 60 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-12283
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
How Accidental was Inflation? and Keith A. Olive Abstract Data on the cosmic microwave background (CMB) are discriminating between different models of inflation, disfavoring simple monomial potentials whilst being consistent with models whose predictions resemble those of the Starobinsky R + R 2 R+R^{2} cosmological model. However, this model may suffer from theoretical problems, since it requires a large initial field value, threatening the validity of the effective field theory. This is quantified by the Swampland Distance Conjecture, which predicts the appearance of a tower of light states associated with an effective ultra-violet cutoff. This could be lower than the inflation scale for cases with an extended period of inflation, leading to an additional problem of initial conditions. No-scale supergravity models can reproduce the predictions of the Starobinsky model and accommodate the CMB data at the expense of fine-tuning of parameters at the level of 10 − 5 10^{-5} . Here, we propose a solution to this problem based on an explicit realisation of the Starobinsky model in string theory, where this ‘deformation’ parameter is calculable and takes a value of order of the one corresponding to the Starobinsky inflaton potential. Within this range, there are parameter values that accommodate more easily the combination of Planck, ACT and DESI BAO data, while also restricting the range of possible inflaton field values, thereby avoiding the swampland problem and predicting that the initial conditions for inflation compatible with the CMB data are generic. UMN–TH–4418/25, FTPI–MINN–25/03, KCL–PH–TH/2025-09, CERN–TH–2025-076 April 2025 1 Introduction Inflation plays a central role in the Standard Model of cosmology [ 1 ] . In addition to solving classic problems such as the horizon problem, the flatness problem and the isotropy problem (not to mention one of its original motivations, the magnetic monopole problem), inflation provides an explanation for the origin of the density fluctuations observable in the cosmic microwave background (CMB) that triggered the formation of astrophysical structures. CMB observations transformed inflation from an abstract phase of the Universe to a testable scientific theory. Indeed, observations of the spectral tilt, n_{s} , in the 2-point correlation function of the CMB anisotropy spectrum [ 2 , 3 ] , and limits on the tensor-to-scalar ratio, r [ 4 , 5 ] , have the power to exclude specific models of inflation while verifying predictions of others. The simplest models of inflation are based on a single monomial potential, as in chaotic inflation [ 6 ] . However as limits on the tensor-to scalar ratio have improved, these simple models could be excluded. On the other hand, as the precisions in the measurements of r and n_{s} have improved, the Starobinsky model [ 7 ] based on a quadratic modification of Einstein gravity, originally designed to avoid the initial singularity in Big Bang cosmology, has survived. In both chaotic inflation and in R+R^{2} gravity, there is only a single parameter, the inflaton self-coupling or the coefficient of the R^{2} term, that can be determined from experiment. In most other models, in addition to the overall scale of inflation, there is a relative coupling that must be adjusted so that some part of the scalar potential is sufficiently flat to provide slow-roll inflation with enough e -folds of expansion to resolve the classic cosmological problems. As discussed in [ 8 ] , this necessary tuning of couplings may appear accidental, but is often required in models constructed from supergravity models. Fine-tuning is a recurrent issue in scalar field theories, e.g., the Higgs sector of the Standard Model electroweak sector. While the inflation scale, M , is generally taken to be far greater than the electroweak scale, it is still much smaller than the Planck scale: M\sim 10^{-5}M_{P} 1 1 1 Here M_{P} is the reduced Planck mass, M_{P}=1/\sqrt{8\pi G_{N}} . . Just as supersymmetry was touted as a possible solution to the Higgs fine-tuning problem, the benefits of resolving the inflationary hierarchy with supersymmetry were advertized in [ 9 , 10 , 11 ] . The supersymmetrisation of R+R^{2} gravity still has a single parameter, but introduces an extra scalar degree of freedom and its supersymmetric partners, corresponding to the goldstino chiral supermultiplet and with it a tachyonic instability during inflation [ 12 , 13 ] . Stabilizing the sgoldstino requires an extension of the minimal model, introducing model dependence and extra parameters. The model dependence can be eliminated by imposing nonlinear supersymmetry, which amounts to integrating out massive degrees of freedom, or equivalently imposing a constraint that eliminates the scalar partner of the goldstino (sgoldstino) [ 14 ] . On the other hand, string theory comes to a rescue since, in the presence of the string dilaton, the sgoldstino instability is absent, at least in perturbation theory [ 15 , 16 ] . 2 2 2 Of course dilaton stabilisation is required, presumably as a result of nonperturbative effects and and/or discrete fluxes. The construction of the Starobinsky model in the context of no-scale supergravity is a modern example of accidental inflation. The earliest example of this type is based on a Wess-Zumino form for the superpotential [ 17 ] , which includes quadratic and cubic couplings. The Starobinsky potential arises exactly if the ratio of these couplings is precisely 2/3\sqrt{3} . As we discuss in more detail below, this fine-tuning must be respected to roughly 1 part in 10^{5} . Furthermore, even such small changes in the couplings, have a dramatic effect on the shape of the potential, affecting the derived value of n_{s} and the allowed range in the post-inflationary reheating temperature, T_{\rm RH} . The latter is also model-dependent, since it requires an input on how the inflaton couples to Standard Model fields, in contrast to the R+R^{2} model, 3 3 3 An elegant possibility is to identify the inflaton with the scalar partner of the right-handed neutrino (or of a linear combination of them) [ 19 , 20 , 21 ] . where this interaction arises from the universal coupling of the matter stress-tensor to the metric in the so-called Jordan frame, associated to the geometric description of the model (see for example [ 18 ] ). The Starobinsky model is very consistent with Planck data on r and n_{s} , which is the primary reason why so much attention has been focused on this model in the past few years. Recently the Atacama Cosmology Telescope (ACT) has released new results [ 22 ] that, when combined with Planck CMB data and DESI data on baryon acoustic oscillations (BAO), may indicate a somewhat larger value for n_{s} that puts pressure on the Starobinsky model at the 3\sigma level. 4 4 4 We note, however, that there are subtleties in the combination of these data sets that must be addressed before firm conclusions can be drawn (D. Scott, private communication). As we discuss below, these results can easily be accommodated with a slightly different accidental ratio of couplings in no-scale avatars of the Starobinsky model. In other models, such as a simple model of new inflation constructed from supergravity, a comparable shift in the couplings could cause the value of n_{s} to shift from being completely excluded ( >5\sigma ) to being in good agreement with data. Despite