Correlations as a resource in molecular switches
Daniel Siciliano ‡, Rudi B. P. Pietsch ‡, Giovanni Spaventa, Susana F. Huelga, Martin B. Plenio · 2025
Read Correlations as a resource in molecular switches by Daniel Siciliano ‡, Rudi B. P. Pietsch ‡, Giovanni Spaventa, Susana F. Huelga, Martin B. Plenio (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-12202.txt.
Introduction
Light flips molecular switches, and linked switches may flip more cheaply than lone ones. Daniel Siciliano and co-authors measure that saving in a 2025 paper. Their frame treats the flipping process with the tools of quantum thermodynamics, which set cost floors without tracking every detail. Correlations between switches, both quantum and classical, are the variable under study.
The team shows in numbers how shared links raise the efficiency of the flip past the single-switch best. The gain holds across the mix of link types they test. The work also maps how quantum and classical links trade off in the process. Photo-switching sits under many biological light responses. The results hint at design rules for tiny light-driven machines.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Daniel Siciliano ‡, Rudi B. P. Pietsch ‡, Giovanni Spaventa, Susana F. Huelga, Martin B. Plenio |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 51 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-12202
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Correlations as a resource in molecular switches Daniel Siciliano ‡, Rudi B. P. Pietsch ‡, Giovanni Spaventa, Susana F. Huelga, Martin B. Plenio Abstract Photoisomerization, a photochemical process underlying many biological mechanisms, has been modeled recently within the quantum resource theory of thermodynamics. This approach has emerged as a promising tool for studying fundamental limitations to nanoscale processes independently of the microscopic details governing their dynamics. On the other hand, correlations between physical systems have been shown to play a crucial role in quantum thermodynamics by lowering the work cost of certain operations. Here, we explore quantitatively how correlations between multiple photoswitches can enhance the efficiency of photoisomerization beyond that attainable for single molecules. Furthermore, our analysis provides insights into the interplay between quantum and classical correlations in these transformations. Introduction – Nanoscale systems are in general rather difficult to analyze from a thermodynamical point of view, due to the complicated microscopic details that govern their dynamics, and due to their fundamentally out-of-equilibrium nature. However, a recent promising approach is that offered by Quantum Resource Theories (QRTs) coecke2016mathematical ; chitambar2019quantum , and in particular the formulations of thermodynamics that have emerged from them ruch1976principle ; ruch1978mixing ; janzing2000thermodynamic ; horodecki2013fundamental ; goold2016role ; lostaglio2019introductory ; ng2018resource . These frameworks can be used as a toolbox for the study of fundamental limitations to nanoscale processes that would otherwise be difficult to capture by solely relying on classical, equilibrium and macroscopic frameworks halpern2020fundamental ; spaventa2022capacity ; burkhard2023boosting ; tiwary2024quantum ; alyuruk2025thermodynamic . In particular, QRTs allow the analysis of a physical process on purely fundamental grounds, without providing a detailed description of the underlying microscopic theory that governs it, e.g. the specific environmental structure, the coupling strengths, etc. A notable example is that of photoisomerization, a photochemical process that is at the basis of human vision telegina2023isomerization , plays a key role in the primary steps of photosynthesis in plants, algae and bacteria croce2018light , and can also be artificially controlled for technological applications, such as the storage of solar energy, nanorobotics and optical data storage dattler2019design . Crucially, the microscopic details of the physics of photoisomerization are rather difficult to capture due to its non-equilibrium nature, its ultra-fast speed, the involvement of vibrational modes, and its very high quantum yield nogly2018retinal ; seidner1994microscopic ; seidner1995nonperturbative ; hahn2000quantum ; hahn2002ultrafast . For this reason, recent works halpern2020fundamental ; spaventa2022capacity ; burkhard2023boosting have deployed the resource theory of athermality to find fundamental limitations to the efficiency of photoisomerization, in a way that is independent of the microscopic details governing the dynamics. As already proposed and explored in those works and in DanielThesis ; RudiThesis , the photoisomerization yield of two molecules can improve over that of a single one, which makes it natural to ask how this advantage behaves for larger ensembles of molecules, and in particular how the N molecule solution approaches that found in the thermodynamic limit, via the standard second law of thermodynamics. Indeed, the role of correlations in quantum thermodynamics is nontrivial. On the one hand, the thermal state of a system might be correlated or not depending on the particular choice of Hamiltonian, implying that the resourcefulness of correlated states depends on the details of the system (e.g. thermal states of non-interacting systems do not exhibit correlations, therefore any correlated state will represent a resource). On the other hand, quantifying the impact of correlations on state conversion criteria is not straightforward, due to the interplay between this resource and others, such as energy and purity. Nevertheless, it has been proven that correlations can allow some thermodynamical protocols to be implemented at a lower work cost sapienza2019correlations . Here, we want to quantitatively explore the impact of correlations between different molecules on the efficiency of photoisomerization. We do so by explicitly computing the optimal photoisomerization yield in a many-molecule scenario under the assumption that the molecules end up in a correlated or uncorrelated state, and we compare the solutions. We find that (classical) correlations offer a significant boost in efficiency, and we can compute how this advantage scales with the number of molecules. Furthermore, we quantify the role of quantum correlations on the photoisomerization yield of two molecules and find a small advantage over classical correlations. Outline – The paper is organized as follows. First, we briefly introduce the resource theory of thermodynamics and the study of photoisomerization within this framework to fix the notation. Once the relevant quantities we want to study, such as the process yield, are defined, we analyze the role of correlations when two molecules undergo a photoisomerization process together. As we find that the yield increases compared to the single molecule case, we extend our analysis to the N -molecule scenario and the limit for which the number of molecules becomes large. Finally, we show that the same tools we developed to study the role of classical correlations can also be applied to coherence, and we briefly compare the effect of the two. Thermodynamics as a quantum resource theory – The framework of quantum resource theories (QRTs) allows the rigorous quantification of physical resources (such as quantum coherence, entanglement, non-Markovianity, etc.) and their interconversion. They provide a theoretical framework in which a set of operations (i.e. a subset of all quantum channels) are considered free , and any state that cannot be prepared via free operations is then singled out as a (static) resource , in the sense of facilitating a task inaccessible to the free set. Non-free states (or operations) can thus only be prepared (or implemented) at a cost, while on the other hand assisting processes that would be otherwise impossible or only attainable with a smaller fidelity. Historically, the first example of a resource theory is the theory of bipartite entanglement plenio2007introduction ; horodecki2009quantum , where the restriction to local operations and classical communication (LOCC) promotes entanglement to a resource, while separable states remain freely accessible. Analogously, quantum thermodynamics can be formulated as a resource theory in which both free states and operations are thermal ruch1976principle ; ruch1978mixing ; janzing2000thermodynamic ; horodecki2013fundamental ; goold2016role ; lostaglio2019introductory ; ng2018resource . Specifically, the resource theory of athermality is constructed as follows. Given a system S with Hamiltonian H_{S} , the following three elementary operations are allowed: (i) The system can be brought into contact with a thermal bath B at inverse temperature \beta , that is, we can freely deploy Gibbs states \tau=e^{-\beta H_{B}}/Z . (ii) We can perform any global unitary transformation U on S+B , as long as it is strictly energy preserving, i.e., \big[U,H_{S}+H_{B}\big]=0 . (iii) We are allowed to trace out subsystems, and in particular the entire bath B . As a result, the action of thermal operations ( \mathsf{TO} ) on a density operator \rho_{S} is then defined as \rho_{S}\,\xrightarrow{\,\,\mathsf{TO}\,\,}\,\Tr_{B}\,\big[U\,\rho_{S}\otimes\tau\,U^{\dagger}\big]\,. (1) Note that thermal operations preserve the Gibbs state of the system S , and furthermore they obey time-translation covariance (also called phase-covariance or U(1) -covariance), i.e. they commute with the free unitary evolution of the system: \mathcal{T}\circ\mathcal{U}_{t}=\mathcal{U}_{t}\circ\mathcal{T} for any \mathcal{T}\in\mathsf{TO} . The action of thermal operations on block-diagonal states in the energy eigenbasis can be fully characterized. The associated state conversion problem, i.e. deciding whether such a