Spin stiffnesses and stability of magnetic order in the lightly doped two-dimensional Hubbard model

Demetrio Vilardi, Pietro M. Bonetti, Walter Metzner · 2025

Read Spin stiffnesses and stability of magnetic order in the lightly doped two-dimensional Hubbard model by Demetrio Vilardi, Pietro M. Bonetti, Walter Metzner (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-12191.txt.

Introduction

Demetrio Vilardi, Pietro Bonetti, and Walter Metzner study magnetic order in a classic model of electron systems, in this 2025 paper. The model is the two-dimensional Hubbard model, lightly doped away from half filling. The question is whether magnetic patterns survive quantum shaking, and how stiff they are against twisting.

Working from a standard approximation for spin response, the trio map two ground states: a Néel pattern on the electron-doped side and a spiral pattern on the hole-doped side. The Néel stiffness falls gently with doping. The spiral stiffnesses drop sharply at half filling, with one falling to zero before creeping back. Warmth shifts the boundary and smooths the jumps. Their verdict: the electron-doped side likely keeps its order, while the hole-doped spiral probably melts into a disordered state with a spin gap.

Catalog record

CREATORDemetrio Vilardi, Pietro M. Bonetti, Walter Metzner
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE68 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-12191

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Spin stiffnesses and stability of magnetic order in the lightly doped two-dimensional Hubbard model Demetrio Vilardi, Pietro M. Bonetti, Walter Metzner Abstract We analyze the density dependence of the spin stiffnesses and the stability of magnetic order with respect to quantum fluctuations in the two-dimensional Hubbard model close to half-filling. The stiffnesses are computed from the spin susceptibility obtained from a random phase approximation in a magnetically ordered state. For a sizable next-to-nearest neighbor hopping amplitude and a moderate Hubbard interaction, the mean-field ground state is a Néel antiferromagnet in the electron doped regime at and above half-filling, and a planar circular spiral state in the hole doped regime below half-filling. Upon electron doping, the Néel stiffness decreases smoothly and not very steeply. By contrast, the in-plane and out-of-plane stiffnesses in the spiral state drop abruptly at half-filling. The out-of-plane stiffness even drops to zero, and then increases again very slowly upon increasing hole doping. At finite temperatures, the Néel-to-spiral transition is shifted into the hole doped regime, the stiffnesses are continuous functions of the density, and they vanish at the transition. For small hole doping, the spin stiffnesses describe the quantum fluctuations only in a small momentum range, which shrinks to zero upon approaching half-filling. Using the above results, we show that the quantum ground state of the lightly electron doped Hubbard model remains Néel ordered, while quantum fluctuations probably destroy the spiral long-range order in the hole doped regime, giving rise to a quantum disordered state with a spin gap. I Introduction The two-dimensional Hubbard model has attracted much interest as a minimal model capturing the most salient properties of the valence electrons moving in the copper-oxide planes of cuprate high-temperature superconductors Anderson 1987 ; Zhang and Rice 1988 . Inspite of remarkable progress in the development of quantum many-body methods over the past decades, only small fractions of the phase diagram of the 2D Hubbard model have been firmly established Arovas et al. 2022 ; Qin et al. 2022 . In case of pure nearest neighbor hopping, the ground state is doubtlessly a Néel ordered antiferromagnet at half-filling Qin et al. 2016 , for any interaction strength, and a collinear spin-charge stripe state at the special densities n=1\pm\frac{1}{8} for sufficiently strong interactions Qin et al. 2020 . In presence of hopping amplitudes beyond nearest neighbors, the Néel order at half-filling sets in only above a certain critical interaction strength. At sufficiently weak coupling the ground state of the 2D Hubbard model is a d-wave superconductor in a broad density range around half-filling Neumayr and Metzner 2003 ; Raghu et al. 2010 ; Metzner et al. 2012 . Besides the special cases just mentioned, there are no conclusive results on magnetic order in the ground state of the 2D Hubbard model away from half-filling. Exact numerical methods are limited to relatively small finite size lattices. Monte Carlo methods are severely limited by the notorious sign problem. From approximate methods, such as Hartree-Fock theory, dynamical mean-field theory and its cluster extensions, and the functional renormalization group, essentially three types of magnetic order emerged as plausible candidates: Néel order Lin and Hirsch 1987 ; Hofstetter and Vollhardt 1998 ; Langmann and Wallin 2007 ; Chubukov and Frenkel 1992 ; Igoshev et al. 2010 ; Yamase et al. 2016 , planar circular spiral order Shraiman and Siggia 1989 ; Dombre 1990 ; Frésard et al. 1991 ; Shraiman and Siggia 1992 ; Chubukov and Frenkel 1992 ; Chubukov and Musaelian 1995 ; Kotov and Sushkov 2004 ; Igoshev et al. 2010 ; Igoshev et al. 2015 ; Yamase et al. 2016 ; Bonetti et al. 2020 ; Goremykin and Katanin 2023 , and collinear spin-charge stripe order Schulz 1989 ; Zaanen and Gunnarsson 1989 ; Machida 1989 ; Poilblanc and Rice 1989 ; Schulz 1990 ; Kato et al. 1990 ; Seibold et al. 1998 ; Fleck et al. 2000 ; Fleck et al. 2001 ; Raczkowski and Assaad 2010 ; Timirgazin et al. 2012 ; Peters and Kawakami 2014 ; Zheng et al. 2017 . In a recent comprehensive Hartree-Fock study of the two-dimensional Hubbard model at a moderate interaction strength these three states indeed covered almost the entire magnetic phase diagram Scholle et al. 2023 . A more complex state with non-collinear planar magnetic order was found in a narrow density regime between spiral and stripe order Scholle et al. 2024 . Messy states in an intermediate regime between spiral order and a magnetic phase with domain walls have been observed previously in a Hartree-Fock study of a three-band Hubbard model Chiciak et al. 2018 . Away from half-filling, the magnetic order may coexist with superconductivity Reiss et al. 2007 ; Wang et al. 2014 ; Yamase et al. 2016 ; Lichtenstein and Katsnelson 2000 ; Capone and Kotliar 2006 ; Aichhorn et al. 2006 ; Kancharla et al. 2008 ; Zheng and Chan 2016 ; Xu et al. 2024 . At finite temperatures, magnetic order is rigorously excluded by the Mermin-Wagner theorem Mermin and Wagner 1966 : the SU(2) spin symmetry of the Hubbard model cannot be spontaneously broken in two dimensions. In the ground state, instead, quantum fluctuations of the order parameter reduce the magnetic order found in mean-field theories, but not necessarily to zero. The impact of low energy quantum fluctuations can be analyzed within a non-linear sigma model for the transverse fluctuations of the order parameter Auerbach 1994 . The key parameters in this model are the spin stiffnesses, which parametrize the energy of long wavelength fluctuations. In a spiral state one needs to distinguish spin stiffnesses related to in-plane and out-of-plane fluctuations Bonetti and Metzner 2022a . The non-linear sigma model maintains a magnetically ordered state for sufficiently large stiffnesses, and yields a quantum disordered state for small stiffnesses. Mean-field spin stiffnesses also play an important role in SU(2) gauge theories of the pseudogap phase in cuprates at finite temperatures Bonetti and Metzner 2022b ; Goremykin and Katanin 2024 ; Vasiliou et al. 2024 ; Bultinck 2024 . In this article we compute the spin stiffnesses for the lightly doped Hubbard model with a moderate interaction strength within mean-field theory. We include a sizable next-to-nearest neighbor hopping amplitude, which, in the context of cuprates, is more realistic than the Hubbard model with pure nearest neighbor hopping. The mean-field ground state then exhibits Néel order in a density range at and above half-filling, and spiral order below half-filling. While the stiffness evolves continuously as a function of density on the electron doped side ( n>1 ), there are discontinuous drops at half-filling to strongly reduced values upon hole doping ( n<1 ). The spatial out-of-plane stiffness of the spiral state even vanishes upon approaching half-filling from below. We derive a number of analytic results for the wave vector of the spiral state at low hole doping, and for the size of the stiffness drops. We also present and analyze results for the stiffnesses at finite temperatures. Finally, we apply our results for the stiffnesses to address the issue of stability of the magnetically ordered ground state with respect to quantum fluctuations of the order parameter. From the well established fact of Néel order at half-filling

Read the complete text