Study on charmonium(-like) mesons within a diabatic approach
Zi-Zhao Zhang, Rong Li, Bo-Chao Liu · 2025
Read Study on charmonium(-like) mesons within a diabatic approach by Zi-Zhao Zhang, Rong Li, Bo-Chao Liu (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-12149.txt.
Introduction
Zi-Zhao Zhang, Rong Li, and Bo-Chao Liu study charmonium like mesons in a 2025 physics paper. These heavy particles contain a charm quark and antiquark, and some states do not fit the conventional picture. A diabatic approach can describe ordinary and exotic states in one framework.
Using a more realistic potential with spin dependent forces, they compute the spectrum below a set energy. Masses align well with experimental data. They also give the probability that each state is a simple quark pair versus a meson pair. Several famous states show significant molecular components, and two states are matched to expected conventional levels.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Zi-Zhao Zhang, Rong Li, Bo-Chao Liu |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 39 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-12149
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Study on charmonium(-like) mesons within a diabatic approach Zi-Zhao Zhang, Rong Li, Bo-Chao Liu Abstract In this work, we study the charmonium(-like) spectrum below 4.1 GeV using the diabatic approach, which offers a unified description of conventional and unconventional heavy meson states. Compared to previous studies, we consider a more realistic c c ¯ c\bar{c} potential with including the spin-dependent interactions, which allows us to obtain more states and get more insights on the charmonium spectrum. Based on our calculation, we obtain the masses of the charmonium spectrum which align with the experimental data well. We also present the probabilities of finding various components, i.e. c c ¯ c\bar{c} or meson-meson pair, in those states. Our results support the arguments that the χ c 1 ( 3872 ) \chi_{c1}(3872) , ψ ( 4040 ) \psi(4040) and χ c 2 ( 3930 ) \chi_{c2}(3930) have significant molecular components. In addition, our calculations show that the χ c 0 ( 3860 ) \chi_{c0}(3860) and ψ ( 3770 ) \psi(3770) can be looked as the candidates for the charmonium states χ c 0 ( 2 P ) \chi_{c0}(2P) and ψ ( 1 D ) \psi(1D) , respectively. I Introduction Studies on charmonium(-like) states play a significant role in understanding how quarks constitute hadrons, which is closely related to the non-perturbative behavior of strong interactions. Since the discovery of the first charmonium meson J/\psi Aubert et al. 1974 ; Augustin et al. 1974 in 1974, a series of charmonium mesons, such as \psi(3686) Abrams et al. 1974 , \chi_{c0}(1P) Biddick et al. 1977 , \chi_{c2}(1P) Whitaker et al. 1976 and others Tanenbaum et al. 1975 ; Partridge et al. 1980 were successively discovered in experiments. To understand the properties of these states, various potential models were proposed to describe the interactions between quarks Eichten et al. 1978 ; Voloshin 2008 . Among them, the Cornell potential Eichten et al. 1975 is widely adopted to predict and interpret the charmonium spectrum. While the Cornell potential is rather successful in describing the low lying charmonium states, its predictions for many highly excited states are still controversial and not well identified in experiments. At the same time, in the past two decades, a series of charmonium-like states called XYZ states have been discovered experimentally Brambilla et al. 2020 , whose masses differ significantly from the predictions of the potential model Barnes et al. 2005 . Some of them clearly do not fit with the conventional q\bar{q} picture of meson state(see Refs. Guo et al. 2018 ; Ji et al. 2023 ; Hanhart and Klempt 2020 ; Chen et al. 2023 for recent reviews). For the newly discovered charmoinum-like states, a special feature is that the masses of many states lie very close to some meson pair thresholds, which have caused the arguments on their molecular natures. In general, for higher excited states the closeness to the open charm thresholds may significantly affect the charmonium spectrum through the virtual meson loop. To describe these states, it is then necessary to take into account such coupled-channel effects. Along this line, various approaches were developed Li et al. 2009 ; Kalashnikova 2005 ; Eichten et al. 1978 ; Pennington and Wilson 2007 ; Ono and Törnqvist 1984 . One solution is to introduce the adiabatic approximation. The adiabatic approximation, also known as the Born-Oppenheimer (B-O) approximation, was initially developed to describe molecular systems Born and Heisenberg 1985 and has since found extensive applications in molecular and atomic physics as well as meson states in QCD Bali 2001 ; Castella 2022 . While, the B-O approximation relies on two key assumptions: the adiabatic approximation and the single-channel approximation Bruschini and González 2020 ; Lebed and Martinez 2022 ; Lebed and Martinez 2024 . As mentioned above, for charmonium states being close to the open flavor meson-meson threshold, the mixing between the Q\bar{Q} and meson-meson configurations cannot be ignored, which challenges the validity of the single-channel approximation assumed in the B-O approximation. In this case, the system should be described by a set of coupled-channel Schrödinger equations containing non-adiabatic coupling terms (NACTs) Baer 2006 , which in practice are difficult to solve Bruschini and González 2020 . To overcome the problems, it is required to generalize the B-O approximation and adopt the so-called diabatic formalism. The diabatic formalism has many advantages. Firstly, in this approach the dynamics is described by a diabatic potential matrix, which in principle can be calculated directly in lattice QCD and provides a non-perturbative method to take into account the mixing of different configurations. Therefore, it offers a way to study the heavy quarkonium(-like) states based on the first principles or models inspired by the Lattice QCD results. In practice, once the diabatic potential matrix is determined, one may use numerical methods to solve the coupled-channel Schrödinger equation to obtain the solution of the system. In addition, by choosing appropriate expansion basis, it is possible to make the wave function components correspond to a pure Q\overline{Q} state or the meson-meson state. In this way, the physical meaning of each channel is intuitive, which makes it more convenient to analyze the results. In previous studies Bruschini and González 2020 ; Bruschini and González 2021 , the authors apply the diabatic approach to study quarkonium spectrum with masses below 4.1 GeV. With using Cornell potential to describe the c\overline{c} interaction, they calculated the charmonium meson spectrums of 0^{++} , 1^{++} , 2^{++} and 1^{--} states. However, in their works the spin-dependent interaction between heavy quarks was not considered. The absence of spin dependent terms prevented the authors from exploring the fine and hyperfine structures in the charmonium spectrum, which is however important for a complete and accurate understanding on the charmonium spectrum. In this work, we extend the works in Refs. Bruschini and González 2020 ; Bruschini and González 2021 by further considering the spin-dependent interactions between the c\overline{c} , which cause the fine and hyperfine splittings of the chamonium mesons. By solving the coupled-channel Schrödinger equations, we get the masses of charmonium spectrum below 4.1 GeV and the probabilities of finding c\bar{c} or various meson pair components in those states. Comparing to the results without considering the spin-dependent interactions, we can now obtain more states to compare with experimental data. Furthermore, it also leads to a better description of lower lying states in the charmonium spectrum. Since this formalism provides a unified description of both conventional and unconventional heavy meson states, we can calculate and describe the states like the \chi_{c0}(3860) , for which there are still disputes on their natures Petrov 2005 ; Yu et al. 2018 . Through analyzing the probability of different configurations, we can explore whether a state is a conventional state or not. Hence, our results may provide new insights on some controversial charmonium(-like) states. This paper is organized as follows. In Section II we review the formalism of the diabatic approach which is developed from the B-O approximation. In Section III, we construct the potential matrix of the system with considering spin-dependent terms. In Section IV, we apply the diabatic approach to study the charmonium spectrum and discuss