Power Line Communication vs. Talkative Power Conversion: A Benchmarking Study
Peter A. Hoeher, Yang Leng, Maximilian Mewis, Rongwu Zhu · 2025
Read Power Line Communication vs. Talkative Power Conversion: A Benchmarking Study by Peter A. Hoeher, Yang Leng, Maximilian Mewis, Rongwu Zhu (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-12015.txt.
Introduction
Peter A Hoeher and co-authors benchmark, in a 2025 paper, two ways of sending data over the same wires that carry electric power. Merging energy delivery with communication is a growing feature of smart grids and connected power systems. The older approach, power line communication, bolts separate transmitters and receivers onto the lines. The newer one, talkative power conversion, builds the talking ability straight into the power converters themselves.
The authors lay out the technical roots and uses of both, then weigh their strengths and bottlenecks side by side. Bolt-on systems ride on mature gear but add hardware at every node. Built-in systems promise tighter integration, at the cost of harder design problems. The paper closes with research directions meant to close the gap between the two camps and guide future grid designs.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Peter A. Hoeher, Yang Leng, Maximilian Mewis, Rongwu Zhu |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 29 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-12015
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Power Line Communication vs. Talkative Power Conversion: A Benchmarking Study Peter A. Hoeher, Yang Leng, Maximilian Mewis, Rongwu Zhu Abstract The convergence of energy transmission and data communication has become a key feature of decentralized energy systems across a broad spectrum of voltage/power ranges, including smart grid applications and cyber-physical power systems. This paper compares two distinct approaches: Power Line Communications (PLC) and Talkative Power Conversion (TPC). While PLC leverages existing power infrastructure for data transmission by using external data transmitters and receivers, TPC integrates communication capabilities directly into power electronic converters. We present their technical foundations and applications, benchmark their strengths and bottlenecks, and outline future research directions regarding TPC that could bridge the gap between power and communication technologies. I Introduction Modern energy systems demand seamless integration of power delivery and data transfer to support network intelligence, device interoperability, data and energy flow, and energy efficiency – both in wireline and wireless applications. Conventional approaches often treat power and communication as separate domains, but simultaneous information and power transfer techniques like Power Line Communication (PLC) and Talkative Power Conversion (TPC) bridge this gap [ 1 ] . PLC exploits power lines as data channels, whereas TPC uses power converters as dual-purpose devices for energy conversion and information modulation [ 2 , 3 ] . This paper targets professionals in the fields of power electronics (PE) and communication engineering (COM) who wish to gain a deeper understanding of the fundamentals and a comparison of PLC and TPC. PLC has been designed “for the grid and through the grid” [ 4 ] . In PLC, simultaneous information and power transfer is achieved by superimposing a modulated carrier signal onto an existing power line [ 5 , 6 ] . In most PLC standards, rate-adaptive high-order multicarrier modulation schemes are used. Besides power lines, some PLC standards are applicable to twisted pairs and coax cables as well. Digital signal processing (DSP) and amplification are implemented in external modems that are connected to the power line by inductive or capacitive coupling [ 7 ] . Narrowband PLC systems are widely applied for grid telemetry, load control, and automated meter reading. On the other side, broadband PLC systems are popular for home/industrial automation, broadband Internet and infotainment, as they offer data rates up to the Gbps range. TPC introduces a paradigm shift where power converters not only regulate energy flow but also embed data signals within power waveforms [ 1 ] . This is achieved through joint power/data modulation techniques that enable converters to “talk” by superimposing a communication signal onto the direct current (DC) or alternating current (AC) waveform delivered by a switched-mode power electronics converter (PEC). Originally, TPC has been proposed for grid applications [ 8 ] . Later, “power talk” [ 2 ] and “talkative power” [ 3 ] have been extended to battery management systems, electrical machine systems, wireless charging, and optical applications (e. g., visible light communication) [ 1 ] . TPC technology is low-cost, reliable, and sustainable, as no additional PE components are to be used. In recent years, there has been a consistent increase in the number of publications related to TPC aspects [ 9 , 10 , 11 , 12 , 13 , 14 ] . Although PLC is widely used worldwide and TPC is approaching maturity after about a decade of research, a solid comparison is apparently lacking. Moreover, TPC is not well known in the communications community, although its roots are in PE and COM engineering [ 8 , 2 ] . This paper intends to fill the gap. Our main contributions are summarized as follows: • We provide a comprehensive comparison between PLC and TPC, evaluating their respective advantages, limitations, and potential applications in modern electrical networks. • We suggest a roadmap for future research directions at all layers. Among the proposals is a hybrid PLC-TPC system, which is being introduced here for the first time. Besides PLC and TPC, many other simultaneous information and power transfer schemes have been invented, particularly for low-power applications. These include bus systems (e. g., CAN, PROFIBUS, HyperTransport, InfiniBand, Thunderbolt), Power over Ethernet (PoE), wireless charging, and wireless powered networks [ 15 ] . These options are beyond the scope of our benchmarking study on PLC and TPC, however. II Introduction to Power Line Communication TABLE I: Key parameters of selected narrowband PLC standards (top) and broadband PLC standards (bottom). Name Spectrum Max. data rate (PHY) Technology Application notes PRIME 42–89 kHz (CENELEC A) 128.6 kbps OFDM (FFT-based) Smart metering (Europe) G3-PLC 10–490 kHz (FCC) 300 kbps OFDM (ROBO mode) Global smart grid IEEE 1901.2 10–490 kHz (FCC/CENELEC) 500 kbps OFDM/FSK Smart grid/utility networks IEC 61334 typ. 10-100 kHz (CENELEC A) 2.4 kbps - 4.8 kbps Spread-FSK Utility automation HomePlug AV 2-30 MHz 200 Mbps OFDM (FFT-based) Home networking HomePlug AV2 2-86 MHz 1.5 Gbps (MIMO) OFDM (FFT-based) High-speed networking HomePlug GP 2-30 MHz 10 Mbps OFDM (FFT-based) Smart grid/IoT ITU-T G.hn 2-200 MHz (PL), 350-2850 MHz (coax) 1-2 Gbps OFDM (FFT-based) Multi-media (power line/coax) IEEE 1901 FFT 2-50 MHz 500 Mbps OFDM (FFT-based) Interoperable broadband IEEE 1901 HD-PLC 2-50 MHz 420 Mbps OFDM (Wavelet-based) Industrial/robust communication II-A Operating Principle of PLC PLC technology utilizes the existing electrical power grid as a communication medium by injecting high-frequency modulated signals onto the grid [ 5 ] . This approach enables bidirectional data transmission without requiring dedicated wiring infrastructure, see Fig. 1 , making it a cost-effective solution for smart grid applications, home automation, and broadband access. A critical component of PLC systems is the coupling mechanism, which facilitates the interface between external communication devices and the power line. Inductive or capacitive coupling methods are commonly employed for this purpose. Inductive coupling uses magnetic fields to transfer signals via transformers or coils. Capacitive coupling, on the other hand, leverages electric fields through coupling capacitors. Both methods require careful circuit design to ensure impedance matching, minimize signal attenuation, and suppress interference from grid-connected equipment. The high-frequency modulated transmit signal superimposes the grid voltage. Most PLC systems have been deployed over the standard 50/60 Hz AC grid. However, there is a growing interest in PLC over DC networks, particularly for microgrids [ 6 ] . Applications such as in-vehicle grids are related to bus systems like the CAN bus, among others. Another relevant application involves the communication between plug-in electric vehicles and their respective charging infrastructures. Additionally, direct current is transmitted between solar panels and battery packs, for instance. To overcome the challenges posed by the frequency-selective nature of power line channels, modern PLC systems frequently adopt orthogonal frequency-division multiplexing (OFDM) [ 5 , 6 ] . OFDM divides the signal bandwidth into multiple orthogonal subcarriers, enabling robust data transmission in environments plagued by impulsive noise, frequency-selective attenuation, and narrowband interference. Adaptive bit-loading techniques further optimize spectral efficiency by dynamically assigning quaternary or higher-order modulation schemes to individual subcarriers. The utilization of multiple-input multiple-output (MIMO) processing has further enhanced PLC performance by exploiting the inherent multi-wire structure of power lines (e. g., live (L), neutral (N), and protective earth (PE)). Delta-style, T-style and star-style inductive couplers offer multiple input and output ports [ 7 ] . MIMO-PLC systems are able