Hawking evaporation and the fate of black holes in loop quantum gravity

Idrus Husin Belfaqih, Martin Bojowald, Suddhasattwa Brahma, Erick I. Duque · 2025

Read Hawking evaporation and the fate of black holes in loop quantum gravity by Idrus Husin Belfaqih, Martin Bojowald, Suddhasattwa Brahma, Erick I. Duque (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-11998.txt.

Introduction

Four authors work out how black holes evaporate inside loop quantum gravity, a theory that smooths out the singularities of the classic picture. A recent covariant version of the theory allows matter to be coupled to its black hole solutions while keeping the symmetry of general relativity intact. That opens the door to deriving Hawking radiation with quantum space-time effects included, by both the standard geometric route and a tunneling route.

Both routes confirm the radiation stays thermal. The Hawking temperature survives unchanged, and the low-energy absorption rates still scale with horizon area, while quantum geometry enters only through smaller corrections to the spectrum. The real shift comes at the end of evaporation. Counting the backreaction, the authors find first-principles evidence favoring a black-to-white hole transition over a stable remnant.

Catalog record

CREATORIdrus Husin Belfaqih, Martin Bojowald, Suddhasattwa Brahma, Erick I. Duque
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE32 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-11998

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Hawking evaporation and the fate of black holes in loop quantum gravity Idrus Husin Belfaqih, Martin Bojowald, Suddhasattwa Brahma, Erick I. Duque Abstract A recent covariant formulation, that includes non-perturbative effects from loop quantum gravity (LQG) as self-consistent effective models, has revealed the possibility of non-singular black hole solutions. The new framework makes it possible to couple scalar matter to such LQG black holes and derive Hawking radiation in the presence of quantum space-time effects while respecting general covariance. Standard methods to derive particle production both within the geometric optics approximation and the Parikh–Wilczek tunneling approach are therefore available and confirm the thermal nature of Hawking radiation. The covariant description of scale-dependent decreasing holonomy corrections maintains Hawking temperature as well as universality of the low-energy transmission coefficients, stating that the absorption rates are proportional to the horizon area at leading order. Quantum-geometry effects enter the thermal distribution only through sub-leading corrections in the greybody factors. Nevertheless, they do impact energy emission of the black hole and its final state in a crucial way regarding one of the main questions of black-hole evaporation: whether a black-to-white-hole transition, or a stable remnant, is preferred. For the first time, a first-principles derivation, based on a discussion of backreaction, finds evidence that points to the former outcome. Introduction : Hawking’s celebrated black-hole information loss paradox has been instrumental in fueling research in fundamental physics over the last half-century. A black hole, which forms when a sufficiently massive star collapses onto itself, has an event horizon that effectively isolates it from the rest of the universe. However, it was soon understood that, quantum-mechanically, black holes behave as thermal objects, emitting black-body radiation as viewed by an external observer. This observation immediately gives rise to a paradox. What happened to the pure state of the star whose collapse formed the black hole if, in the end, it completely evaporates by Hawking radiation? Two effects, ignored in Hawking’s calculation, can help resolve this question. First, backreaction of the radiation stress-energy tensor on the spacetime geometry, although small for large-mass black-holes, could become non-negligible at later stages of the evaporation process as the mass shrinks to zero. Secondly, at the final stage, backreaction alone is insufficient and quantum-gravity corrections must be considered. Since Hawking evaporation in classical spacetime ends at a singularity, complicating any discussion of backreaction effects on the shrinking black hole, potential regularization effects from quantum gravity, provided they are sufficiently well-understood and preserve a meaningful and covariant spacetime interpretation, may make it possible to address these questions. This is our primary motivation. Vacuum spherically-symmetric solutions of loop quantum gravity (LQG) have hinted at resolving the singularity at the core of black holes by a quantum ‘transition surface’ [ 1 , 2 , 3 ] . Nevertheless, self-consistent dynamical solutions must be examined to understand the fate of stellar collapse, and thus how the information-loss paradox is resolved in LQG. In this Letter, we study Hawking radiation from a covariant LQG black-hole model with scale-dependent decreasing holonomy functions, a refined version of what is commonly referred to as the \bar{\mu} -scheme [ 4 ] . While we recover a thermal distribution with the same asymptotic temperature as in general relativity, T_{\rm H}\sim 1/M , LQG parameters related to space-time discreteness affect the greybody factors, and hence, the emission rate. This new effect provides a mechanism for thermal stabilization and suggests, when taken in isolation, the formation of a remnant at a sub-Planckian mass. However, horizon fluctuations as well as new features of the quantum gravitational force at high density, that destabilize the system gravitationally, must also be taken into account. These crucial ingredients are derived from a covariant spacetime description of LQG modifications, combined with a qualitative discussion of backreaction in the presense of matter couplings, as well as implications of the uncertainty relation. The derived mass hierarchy of the three central effects — thermal stabilization, significant horizon fluctuations, and gravitational destabilization — shows that a black-to-white-hole transition is preferred in LQG over the formation of a remnant. Our conclusion requires a careful consideration of consistency conditions that have only recently become available for spacetime models including quantum-geometry corrections. To simplify the discussion, we use Planck units where c=\hbar=k_{\rm B}=G=1 . Effective LQG : Emergent modified gravity [ 5 , 6 ] is a Hamiltonian approach to gravity that incorporates spacetime not as a presupposed quantity but rather as an object derived (or emerging) from a set of covariance conditions. This key idea results in weaker assumptions on the basic setup of a gravitational system and evades previous no-go theorems about possible covariant realizations of central LQG effects. As a result, new theories are now available which, in particular, include modification functions in spherically symmetric models that play the role of holonomy corrections of LQG [ 6 , 3 ] . In the standard Schwarzschild gauge, solving the effective LQG equations of motion results in the line-element {\rm d}s^{2}=-f(x){\rm d}t^{2}+\frac{{\rm d}x^{2}}{h(x)f(x)}+x^{2}{\rm d}\Omega^{2} (1) where f(x)=1-2M/x , h(x)=1+\lambda(x)^{2}f(x) , and \lambda(x) is the holonomy function with classical limit \lambda\rightarrow 0 . Here, we restrict discussions to a decreasing function \lambda(x)=\sqrt{\Delta}/x where \Delta\propto\ell_{P}^{2} may be interpreted as a discreteness parameter in LQG, mimicking the traditional \bar{\mu} -scheme [ 4 ] . (The analysis for a general \lambda(x) can be found in [ 7 ] .) The line-element ( 1 ) preserves a horizon at the classical location x=2M=:x_{\rm H} . It contains an additional coordinate singularity at x=x_{\Delta}<x_{\rm H} defined as the solution to h(x_{\Delta})=0 and given by \displaystyle x_{\Delta}=3M\delta^{1/3}\frac{\left(1+\sqrt{1+\delta}\right)^{2/3}-\delta^{1/3}}{\left(1+\sqrt{1+\delta}\right)^{1/3}} (2) where \delta=\Delta/(27M^{2}) , such that x_{\Delta}(M)\approx(2M\Delta)^{1/3} for M\gg\sqrt{\Delta} . This expression can be thought of as the minimal areal radius for the vacuum solution which marks a reflection-symmetry surface 1 1 1 From now on, we refer to the transition surface by this name to be consistent with the conventions of [ 3 ] . joining the black hole to a white hole; see [ 3 ] for details. (Qualitatively, these properties are similar to the case of constant \lambda given earlier in [ 1 , 2 ] ; see also [ 8 ] .) A massless test scalar field can be minimally coupled to the holonomy-modified system such that its propagation follows the standard Klein–Gordon equation [ 9 , 10 , 11 ] \tilde{g}^{\mu\nu}\tilde{\nabla}_{\mu}\tilde{\nabla}_{\nu}\phi=0\,, (3) where the derivative operator \tilde{\nabla} is compatible with the modified background metric \tilde{g}_{\mu\nu} defined by ( 1 ). However, there are other couplings allowed by covariance, which may be relevant for effective descriptions of new quantum-gravity effects. We will show an example at the end of this letter. The importance of imposing strict covariance conditions in deriving the line-element ( 1 ) in LQG, and while coupling scalar matter to it, will also be seen in what follows. These are key new ingredients of our construction. Thermal distribution : Our first derivation determines tunneling rates for Hawking particles in the Parikh-Wilczek picture [ 12 ] . The metric is important because it may modify the potential and corresponding tunneling rates. We present details for a derivation with our emergent line-element in the appendix, but note one crucial feature here: In the metric coefficients, \lambda enters only through the function h(x) ,

Read the complete text