Characterizing physical and logical errors in a transversal CNOT via cycle error reconstruction

Nicholas Fazio, Robert Freund, Debankan Sannamoth, Alex Steiner, Christian D. Marciniak, Manuel Rispler, Robin Harper, Thomas Monz, Joseph Emerson, Stephen D. Bartlett · 2025

Read Characterizing physical and logical errors in a transversal CNOT via cycle error reconstruction by Nicholas Fazio, Robert Freund, Debankan Sannamoth, Alex Steiner, Christian D. Marciniak, Manuel Rispler, Robin Harper, Thomas Monz, Joseph Emerson, Stephen D. Bartlett (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-11980.txt.

Introduction

Nicholas Fazio and nine co-authors report a new way to measure errors in a quantum computer, in a paper from twenty twenty-five. Their test case is a key two-qubit operation used in logic built to resist errors. The work ran on a sixteen-qubit register in a trapped-ion machine.

Their method rebuilds the error pattern of a full cycle of operations. It can spot errors that depend on context, so those errors can be eased. It also shows how single gates behave inside larger logical operations. The team says the method can predict how well error correction will work, and can tell fixable errors from those that cannot be fixed.

Catalog record

CREATORNicholas Fazio, Robert Freund, Debankan Sannamoth, Alex Steiner, Christian D. Marciniak, Manuel Rispler, Robin Harper, Thomas Monz, Joseph Emerson, Stephen D. Bartlett
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE76 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-11980

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Characterizing physical and logical errors in a transversal CNOT via cycle error reconstruction Nicholas Fazio, Robert Freund, Debankan Sannamoth, Alex Steiner, Christian D. Marciniak, Manuel Rispler, Robin Harper, Thomas Monz, Joseph Emerson, Stephen D. Bartlett Abstract The development of prototype quantum information processors has progressed to a stage where small instances of logical qubit systems perform better than the best of their physical constituents. Advancing towards fault-tolerant quantum computing will require an understanding of the underlying error mechanisms in logical primitives as they relate to the performance of quantum error correction. In this work we demonstrate the novel capability to characterize the physical error properties relevant to fault-tolerant operations via cycle error reconstruction . We illustrate this diagnostic capability for a transversal cnot , a prototypical component of quantum logical operations, in a 16-qubit register of a trapped-ion quantum computer. Our error characterization technique offers three key capabilities: (i) identifying context-dependent physical layer errors, enabling their mitigation; (ii) contextualizing component gates in the environment of logical operators, validating the performance differences in terms of characterized component-level physics, and (iii) providing a scalable method for predicting quantum error correction performance using pertinent error terms, differentiating correctable versus uncorrectable physical layer errors. The methods with which our results are obtained have scalable resource requirements that can be extended with moderate overhead to capture overall logical performance in increasingly large and complex systems. I Introduction It is widely believed that a quantum computer will need to employ quantum error correction (QEC) in order to operate at sufficient scale to run algorithms of practical interest Beverland et al. 2022 ; Dalzell et al. 2023 . The goal of realizing a fault-tolerant, digital quantum computer has recently seen great experimental progress in different hardware platforms employing QEC from the first universal fault-tolerant gate sets Postler et al. 2022 , encoded logical circuits Bluvstein et al. 2024 , beyond-break-even magic state generation Gupta et al. 2024 , to operation of codes where logical state preparation and quantum memories perform better than the best unencoded constituent qubits Reichardt et al. 2024 ; Acharya et al. 2025 . These early demonstrations of QEC have motivated the need for new characterization tools, to verify the functionality of QEC and to validate the fault-tolerant operation of logical components. A significant challenge for any such tool is in how to characterize logical devices at a scale reaching tens or hundreds of physical qubits. Early quantum characterization, verification, and validation (QCVV) techniques such as randomized benchmarking Emerson et al. 2005 ; Magesan et al. 2011 ; Magesan et al. 2012 , process tomography Weinstein et al. 2004 and gate set tomography Blume-Kohout et al. 2013 ; Nielsen et al. 2021 have been applied primarily on the smallest building blocks of quantum circuits or provide highly condensed information for larger blocks. Recently, several techniques have emerged that are based on the idea of characterizing blocks of quantum operations such as layers or cycles of parallel operations across many qubits to extract representative error descriptions that account for crosstalk and idling errors Erhard et al. 2019 ; Carignan-Dugas et al. 2023 ; Hockings et al. 2025 . These techniques deliver a flexible error characterization framework based on a resource cost versus information gain tradeoff, enabling QCVV for intermediate- to large-scale quantum systems that includes both component characterization and full-system characterization methods suitable for current devices. Characterizing logical operations and their errors has been studied in the literature, for example by promoting physical layer techniques to encoded variants Wagner et al. 2023 . The transition from physical layers to logical layers is not trivial since logical qubits and the QEC machinery needed for them can generate violations of common error-model assumptions for current QCVV techniques Ceasura et al. 2022 . Encoded qubits possess features that are not dominant or are altogether absent on the physical layer such as repeated stabilizer readout via mid-circuit measurements, and future operations conditioned on the outcomes of earlier measurements. While recent proposals have made progress on benchmarking these features Govia et al. 2023 ; Zhang et al. 2025 ; Hines and Proctor 2024 ; Harper et al. 2025 , to what extent useful information can be gained about logical performance across physical layers remains a central challenge for QCVV of error-corrected systems. In this work we apply cycle error reconstruction (CER) Carignan-Dugas et al. 2023 , a method for scalably reconstructing error characteristics, to characterize a logical primitive. Specifically, we demonstrate this characterization method for a transversal cnot on a pair of logical qubits realized with the 7-qubit Steane code Steane 1996 implemented on a trapped-ion quantum computer Pogorelov et al. 2021 ; Postler et al. 2022 ; Postler et al. 2024 . We theoretically develop and experimentally demonstrate three principal applications of this new ‘error characterization for QEC’ capability: (i) We demonstrate the effectiveness of CER to obtain detailed and statistically precise information about the error characteristics for quantum gate operations relevant to the successful execution of fault-tolerant logic. We optimize the resources required under an adjustable tradeoff between resource cost and information gain so that we can acquire accurate multi-qubit correlated Pauli error rates across a large array of qubits on a short time-frame for our experimental platform. (ii) With the data obtained from CER, we validate detailed error models for describing multi-physical-qubit systems in the context of logical operations. We demonstrate how the overall noise characteristics of the transversal cnot are well understood in terms of the noise characteristics obtained via CER from individual (physical) cnot s together with well-characterized idling error rates. (iii) We demonstrate the predictive capacity of the CER approach by bounding the logical fidelity based on the learned errors. We extend the graphical noise model framework based on the Gibbs random field framework Harper et al. 2020 ; Harper and Flammia 2023 to account for the action of the transversal CNOT, and show that low Hamming weight CER data can be used to construct a global error model for the physical process. With our CER data, we use our global error model to predict and classify correctable versus uncorrectable error contributions of the transversal cnot under quantum error correction. In this study we focus on illustrating these capabilities in the context of a layer of transversal gate operations performed in a 16-qubit array of trapped ions, expecting that this approach will be applicable to broader contexts by adapting the global error models as appropriate to the specific logical gate and fault-tolerant architecture. The manuscript is structured as follows: We begin in Sec. II with an overview of CER, focusing on the practical aspects – including required resources – involved with executing a suite of experiments. We briefly outline the experimental platform in Sec. III . The main results of this work are presented in Sec. IV : We apply CER to both individual physical cnot s as well as the transversal cnot , providing detailed error information of both the individual component gates and the overall transversal operation. We use this CER data to validate our error model, demonstrating that component-level characterization together with simple device physics can be used to predict system-level characteristics. We also show how CER data together with a

Read the complete text