Discrimination-Free Insurance Pricing with Privatized Sensitive Attributes

Tianhe Zhang, Suhan Liu, Peng Shi · 2025

Read Discrimination-Free Insurance Pricing with Privatized Sensitive Attributes by Tianhe Zhang, Suhan Liu, Peng Shi (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-11775.txt.

Introduction

Insurance prices must not lean on traits like sex or race, directly or through proxies, yet privacy rules may hide those very traits from the insurer. Tianhe Zhang and co-authors solve the bind in a 2025 paper. The fair premium they target strips out both direct and indirect effects of the sensitive trait while keeping prices actuarially sound.

In their setup a trusted third party holds the trait in scrambled form, and the insurer estimates the fair price from the scrambled values alone. They handle both known and unknown scrambling strength, with guarantees for each. Tests on data show fair pricing is possible without ever seeing the trait.

Catalog record

CREATORTianhe Zhang, Suhan Liu, Peng Shi
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE84 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-11775

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Discrimination-Free Insurance Pricing with Privatized Sensitive Attributes Tianhe Zhang, Suhan Liu, Peng Shi Abstract Fairness has become an important concern in insurance pricing as insurers increasingly rely on machine learning models to predict expected losses. At the same time, regulatory and privacy constraints often restrict insurers’ ability to access or use sensitive attributes such as gender or race. Recent actuarial research addresses fairness in this context through the concept of the discrimination-free premium, which removes both the direct and indirect effects of sensitive attributes while preserving actuarial consistency. However, implementing this approach typically requires access to the sensitive attributes themselves, which may not be available in practice. This paper studies the estimation of discrimination-free insurance premiums when sensitive attributes are observed only in privatized or noise-perturbed form. We consider a multi-party data setting in which insurers observe non-sensitive attributes and outcomes, while a trusted third party holds privatized sensitive attributes generated through a privacy mechanism. Within this framework, we develop statistical methods for estimating discrimination-free premiums using only the privatized attributes. We study two settings of practical relevance: when the privacy mechanism is known and when its noise level is unknown. For both cases, we establish theoretical guarantees for the proposed estimators. Numerical experiments and empirical applications demonstrate that the proposed approach enables fair insurance pricing while respecting privacy and regulatory constraints. Keywords: Insurance pricing; Discrimination-free premium; Algorithmic fairness; Privacy-preserving learning; Noisy sensitive attributes 1 Introduction Fairness has become a growing concern in insurance pricing. Insurance premiums determine how risks and costs are allocated across individuals, placing fairness at the center of regulatory oversight and public trust in insurance markets. At the same time, insurance pricing increasingly relies on statistical and machine learning algorithms that analyze large volumes of data to predict expected losses ( Blier-Wong et al., 2020 ) . While these methods can improve predictive accuracy, they may also produce outcomes that disadvantage individuals or groups defined by protected characteristics such as gender, race, or ethnicity. As algorithmic decision-making becomes more prevalent, ensuring fairness in insurance pricing has become a key challenge for both regulators and insurers ( Charpentier, 2024 ) . This paper studies fair insurance pricing in settings where sensitive attributes are not directly observable. In practice, regulators impose restrictions on the use of sensitive attributes in insurance pricing. For example, Directive 2004/113/EC (“Gender Directive”) issued by the Council of the European Union prohibits insurers from using gender as a rating factor when pricing insurance products. More recently, the state of Colorado in the United States enacted Senate Bill (SB) 21-169, which prohibits unfair discrimination in insurance practices based on characteristics including race, national origin, religion, sex, sexual orientation, disability, and gender identity. Regulators have also raised concerns that complex predictive models may unintentionally encode discriminatory patterns through correlated variables or proxy relationships ( van Bekkum et al., 2025 ) . As a result, insurers often cannot directly access or use protected attributes when developing pricing models. The objective of this paper is to develop statistical methods that enable fair insurance pricing under such constraints while avoiding both direct and indirect discrimination. Fairness in insurance differs in important ways from fairness notions commonly studied in the machine learning literature. In the broader algorithmic fairness literature, several formal definitions have been proposed, including demographic parity, equalized odds, and predictive parity ( Dwork et al., 2012 ; Hardt et al., 2016 ; Zafar et al., 2017 ; Kusner et al., 2017 ) . These definitions focus on ensuring equitable outcomes across demographic groups in algorithmic decision-making systems. By contrast, insurance pricing traditionally follows the principle of actuarial fairness, under which premiums should reflect the expected cost associated with the insured risk ( Miller, 2009 ; Frees and Huang, 2023 ) . Accurate risk classification is therefore fundamental to maintaining financial sustainability and preventing unintended cross-subsidization across policyholders. Consequently, fairness considerations in insurance must be reconciled with the actuarial objective of accurately estimating expected losses. Recent work in actuarial science has addresses this tension through the concept of a discrimination-free premium. Lindholm et al. (2022) propose a causal framework for defining premiums that remove both the direct and indirect effects of sensitive attributes while preserving actuarial consistency. Under this framework, pricing rules are constructed so that sensitive attributes do not influence premiums at the individual level, either directly or through correlated proxy variables. In theory, this approach provides a principled way to incorporate fairness considerations into actuarial pricing models. In practice, however, implementing discrimination-free pricing is challenging under current regulatory and privacy constraints. Sensitive attributes are often unavailable during model development because access to such information is restricted or because only privatized or noise-perturbed versions of the attributes can be used. Yet implementing the discrimination-free premium typically requires knowledge of the sensitive attributes themselves. To overcome this practical limitation, we develop a statistical framework for estimating discrimination-free premiums when sensitive attributes are observed only through a privacy mechanism that introduces noise. Our work connects the actuarial literature on fair pricing with statistical methods for learning under corrupted or privatized data ( Warner, 1965 ; van der Maaten et al., 2013 ; Li et al., 2016 ) . To capture the institutional realities of modern insurance data ecosystems, we consider a multi-party learning framework in which insurers observe non-sensitive attributes and outcomes but do not observe the true sensitive attributes. Instead, privatized sensitive attributes are maintained by a trusted third party that facilitates model training. Such arrangements are increasingly common as insurers collaborate with external analytics vendors and data intermediaries to implement complex machine learning models while respecting privacy constraints. Within this framework, discrimination-free premiums can be estimated even when sensitive attributes are available only in noisy or privatized form. We examine two settings of practical interest. In the first, the trusted third party has full knowledge of the privacy mechanism generating the privatized attributes, including the noise rate. In the second, the privacy mechanism is known but the noise rate itself is unknown. The proposed method offers several advantages. First, it enables the construction of discrimination-free pricing models without requiring insurers to access sensitive attributes directly, thereby strengthening privacy protection. Second, the framework is flexible with respect to how sensitive attributes are collected and privatized, relying only on the availability of their privatized versions. Third, the proposed estimation procedures are straightforward to implement and come with formal statistical guarantees. The contributions of this paper are threefold. First, we develop a statistical method for estimating discrimination-free premiums when sensitive attributes are observed only through a privacy mechanism. Second, we establish theoretical guarantees for the proposed estimators under both known and unknown noise rates. Third, we demonstrate the empirical performance of the proposed approach and analyze the impact of noise-rate misspecification on pricing accuracy. The remainder of the paper is organized as follows. Section 2 reviews the related literature on fairness in machine learning and insurance pricing. Section 3 introduces the discrimination-free pricing rule and the trusted third-party framework underlying our theoretical development. Section 4 presents the proposed methodology for estimating discrimination-free premiums under both true and privatized sensitive attributes, together with statistical guarantees when the noise rate is known or unknown. Section 5 reports numerical experiments illustrating the main theoretical

Read the complete text