Trials and Tribulations of Chemodynamical Tagging: Investigating the Recovery of Open Clusters in the Gaia DR3-GALAH DR4 Catalog Facilities: Hipergator

Nicholas A. Barth, David Mendez, Rana Ezzeddine, Yuxi(Lucy) Lu, Leslie M. Morales, Zachary R. Claytor, Jamie Tayar · 2025

Read Trials and Tribulations of Chemodynamical Tagging: Investigating the Recovery of Open Clusters in the Gaia DR3-GALAH DR4 Catalog Facilities: Hipergator by Nicholas A. Barth, David Mendez, Rana Ezzeddine, Yuxi(Lucy) Lu, Leslie M. Morales, Zachary R. Claytor, Jamie Tayar (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-11586.txt.

Introduction

Nicholas Barth and six co-authors test how well stars can be traced back to their birth clusters by their motion and their chemistry at once. Their paper is from two thousand twenty-five.

This tag method has been put forth as a strong tool, but its true worth is still in doubt. The team uses motion data from one big sky survey and chemistry data from the next. Their set holds known open clusters plus fake field stars. They run a boot-strap test of each mix of motion terms and element shares. Each mix is scored on how well it finds the true clusters back. The work weighs a hyped method on hard counts.

Catalog record

CREATORNicholas A. Barth, David Mendez, Rana Ezzeddine, Yuxi(Lucy) Lu, Leslie M. Morales, Zachary R. Claytor, Jamie Tayar
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE57 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-11586

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Trials and Tribulations of Chemodynamical Tagging: Investigating the Recovery of Open Clusters in the Gaia DR3-GALAH DR4 Catalog Facilities: Hipergator Nicholas A. Barth, David Mendez, Rana Ezzeddine, Yuxi(Lucy) Lu, Leslie M. Morales, Zachary R. Claytor, Jamie Tayar Abstract Chemodynamical tagging has been suggested as a powerful tool to trace stars back to their birth clusters. However, the efficacy of chemodynamical tagging as a means to recover individual stellar clusters is still under debate. In this study, we present a detailed investigation of chemodynamical tagging of open clusters using both dynamical and chemical data from the Gaia DR3 and GALAH DR4 surveys, respectively. Using a sample of open clusters and mock field stars, we conduct a bootstrap analysis to evaluate every unique combination of orbital components ( E , J R , J ϕ , J Z E,J_{R},J_{\phi},J_{Z} ) and chemical abundances ([X/Fe] for O, Na, Mg, Al, Si, K, Ca, Sc, Ti, Cr, Mn, Ni, Cu, Y, and Ba) on how well they recover open clusters when used as parameters in the clustering algorithm, HBDSCAN. We find that using primarily dynamical orbital parameters leads to the highest recovery rate of open cluster stars. Nevertheless, even employing the best performing parameter combinations leads to low open cluster recovery rates. We find that, in most cases, chemodynamical tagging of open clusters using blind clustering algorithms is not efficient, which is in line with previous theoretical and observational work. However, we show that the addition of cuts based on metallicity, age, and birth radii in order to reduce the size of the clustering catalog can marginally improve the recovery rate of open clusters. Galpy I Introduction The era of large photometric, spectroscopic, and astrometric surveys has significantly improved our understanding of how the Milky Way (MW) was formed and evolved to what we observe today. Using positions and velocities from photometric and astrometric surveys (e.g. Gaia Collaboration et al. 32 ), we have access to the dynamical information of millions of stars, while spectroscopic surveys (e.g. Zhao et al. 95 , Majewski et al. 56 , Buder et al. 13 ) provide detailed chemical abundances for hundreds of thousands of stars. Astronomers have long used chemodynamical properties, including the chemical abundances, as well as the Galactic orbital information, to partition the Milky Way into major overdensities, including thin and thick disc components, as well as substructures in the bulge and the inner and outer halo ( Hawkins et al. 39 , Bland-Hawthorn & Gerhard 10 ). Using these major overdensities is a form of weak chemodynamical tagging, where stars are categorized based on the Galactic environment in which they were formed ( Freeman & Bland-Hawthorn 31 , Casamiquela et al. 20 ). As new surveys came online and the number of stars with chemodynamical measurements began to grow, substructures within the major subdivisions of the Milky Way are now being recovered, including new globular clusters (e.g. Carretta et al. 19 , Schiavon et al. 81 , Chen et al. 21 ), open clusters (OCs) (e.g. De Silva et al. 25 , De Silva et al. 24 , Ting et al. 92 , Hunt & Reffert 42 ), stellar streams (e.g. Pompéia et al. 74 , Naidu et al. 66 , Hansen et al. 38 , Limberg et al. 50 ), and other unique stellar populations formed or accreted during the Milky Way’s dynamic history. This process of identifying stars that were born in the same formation events in the same systems is known as strong chemodynamical tagging ( Freeman & Bland-Hawthorn 31 , Casamiquela et al. 20 ). Strong chemical tagging has been shown to be a strong tool in identifying presently bound, tidal associations, however, using strong chemical tagging to recover structures that have been dispersed throughout the Galaxy since their initial formation has been shown to be challenging (e.g. Ting et al. 92 , Mitschang et al. 64 , Ting et al. 91 , Casamiquela et al. 20 ). The strength of strong chemical tagging is the assumption that star clusters are chemically homogeneous at birth, and preserve this chemical information even after the cluster has long since been physically associated (e.g. De Silva et al. 25 , Bovy 12 , Bertelli Motta et al. 3 ). We thus expect to be able to disentangle dispersed star clusters from large all-sky surveys based on their unique chemical signature. The use of OCs has been instrumental in testing the different methods of chemical tagging. Studies done by Mitschang et al. [64] and Blanco-Cuaresma et al. [9] used high-precision abundances to perform robust, blind clustering methods, empirical cluster probability functions and K-means++, respectively, which were applied to entire star catalogs, such as GALAH, APOGEE, or compiled observations from high-resolution instruments like NARVAL, HARPS, or UVES, without any prior restrictions based on the properties of known OCs ( Aurière 1 , Mayor et al. 59 , Dekker et al. 26 ). Blind clustering methods can assess how well known OCs can be recovered using chemical parameters and indicate if unknown OCs can be found using these methods. Other works have shown some success in recovering OCs using hierarchical clustering algorithms [ 87 ] , t-distributed stochastic neighbour embedding (t-SNE) visual identification [ 48 ] , and non-hierarchical clustering algorithms [ 33 ] . Using the APOGEE chemical abundances, Casamiquela et al. [20] showed that the overlap in the chemical signatures between OCs is large and hinders accurate grouping of real star clusters using unsupervised clustering techniques. Each of the aforementioned studies focused solely on identifying OCs in chemical space alone. In terms of their dynamics, star clusters that form in the MW disc tend to disperse over a few \sim 100 Myr, and it has been suggested that it is possible to trace back their formation sites using dynamics alone for young clusters [ 49 ] . Orbital actions can be calculated utilizing the kinematic data of a star, are conserved quantities under adiabatic changes to the underlying Galactic potential ( Binney & Tremaine 7 , Sanders & Binney 79 , Sanders & Binney 80 ). Since OC stars are born in the same location, their initial orbits are similar and therefore, for a potential which varies slowly enough the actions should remain similar long after the dissolution of the cluster. The goal of chemodynamical tagging is to combine both the chemical and dynamical information in order to classify stars to a unique formation site or event. One common way to test chemodynamical tagging is to attempt to recover stars in well-known OCs using clustering algorithms to distill large catalogs of stars into statistical groups using their dynamical and chemical properties, as OCs are still dynamically bound associations with homogeneous chemical abundances up to 0.02-0.03 dex ( De Silva et al. 25 , Liu et al. 51 , Bovy 12 ). By comparing the statistical group labels to the true labels of the OC stars, we can assess how well the clustering algorithm performed. Gaia kinematic data has paved the way for searching for OCs in the kinematic space, using positional and dynamical properties to identify OCs. Cantat-Gaudin et al. [18] , Cantat-Gaudin & Anders [16] use unsupervised membership assignment based on photometric and

Read the complete text