How to use Gaia parallaxes for stars with poor astrometric fits

Kareem El-Badry 1 · 2025

Read How to use Gaia parallaxes for stars with poor astrometric fits by Kareem El-Badry 1 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-11528.txt.

Introduction

Kareem El-Badry rescues the distances of the most interesting stars in the Gaia catalog from the waste bin. Stars whose astrometric fits look poor, flagged by a high error statistic called RUWE, are usually binaries, and their parallaxes are often dismissed as unreliable just when they matter most. His 2025 solo paper simulates Gaia's raw observations to measure how wrong those parallaxes really are.

The verdict is forgiving: the quoted uncertainties are too small by a factor between one and four. That factor can be predicted from things observers know: the error statistic itself, brightness, and the parallax. A simple formula inflates the uncertainties to honesty. Tests on stars with known orbits and on wide binaries confirm the repair. The same fix should serve the next two data releases, opening triples and tight or wide binaries to sound distance work.

Catalog record

CREATORKareem El-Badry 1
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE33 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-11528

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

How to use Gaia parallaxes for stars with poor astrometric fits Kareem El-Badry 1 Abstract Gaia parallax measurements for stars with poor astrometric fits – as evidenced by high renormalized unit weight error ( RUWE ) – are often assumed to be unreliable, but the extent and nature of their biases remain poorly quantified. High RUWE is usually a consequence of binarity or higher-order multiplicity, so the parallaxes of sources with high RUWE are often of greatest astrophysical interest. Using realistic simulations of Gaia epoch astrometry, we show that the parallax uncertainties of sources with elevated RUWE are underestimated by a factor that ranges from 1 to 4 and can be robustly predicted from observables. We derive an empirical prescription to inflate reported uncertainties based on a simple analytic function of RUWE , apparent magnitude, and parallax. We validate the correction using (a) single-star solutions for Gaia sources with known orbital solutions and (b) wide binaries containing one component with elevated RUWE . The same uncertainty corrections are expected to perform well in DR4 and DR5. Our results demonstrate that Gaia parallaxes for high- RUWE sources can still yield robust distance estimates if uncertainties are appropriately inflated, enabling distance constraints for triples, binaries with periods too long or too short to be fit astrometrically, and sources blended with neighboring sources. \defcitealias Shen2018S18 keywords astrometry – parallaxes – binaries 1 Introduction Data from the Gaia mission has enabled parallax measurements – and thus, distance constraints – for about 2 billion stars ( Gaia Collaboration et al., 2016 ; Gaia Collaboration et al., 2023a ) . For astrometrically well-behaved sources that are effectively single, motion on the plane of the sky can be fully described by a linear model with five free parameters: two positional coordinates, two proper motions, and parallax. The parallax is often the quantity of greatest interest, because it constrains the distance to the star ( Bailer-Jones, 2015 ; Luri et al., 2018 , e.g.) . Some Gaia sources have spurious parallax measurements. In this context, “spurious” does not necessarily mean that the parallax contains no useful information, but rather that the difference between the reported parallax and its true value significantly exceeds the reported uncertainty. The existence of such sources is manifest, for example, in the prevalence of sources with significantly negative parallaxes ( Rybizki et al., 2022 , e.g.) . Most spurious Gaia astrometric solutions are due to binaries and higher-order multiples. Binaries with detectable astrometric “wobble” on the sky – typically systems with orbital periods of months to years – lead to complicated motion of the photocenter that cannot be described by a five-parameter astrometric solution. Binaries with much longer orbital periods of centuries to millennia can similarly lead to spurious astrometric solutions, because blended light from a marginally resolved companion perturbs astrometric measurements ( Lindegren, 2022 , e.g.) . Physically unassociated close neighbors that are in the foreground or background of a source can have the same effect. Several parameters quantify the goodness of fit of Gaia five-parameter solutions. The most useful of these is RUWE (“renormalized unit weight error”) which approximately represents the reduced chi-squared, \chi_{\nu}^{2} , of the five-parameter astrometric solution ( Lindegren, 2018 ) . Several previous works have explored the utility of RUWE as diagnostic of spurious solutions and binary companions. Lindegren (2018) proposed that for Gaia DR2, a cut of RUWE <1.4 would retain most ‘‘good’’ solutions while filtering out most spurious ones. 1 1 1 For DR3, a threshold of RUWE <1.25 has been proposed to be more appropriate, though the exact threshold varies with sky position ( Penoyre et al., 2022a ) . Belokurov et al. (2020) showed that, at least for nearby sources, RUWE >1.4 primarily selects sources in regions of the color-magnitude diagram (CMD) where binaries are expected to be overrepresented. Penoyre et al. (2020) developed a framework to predict RUWE and other astrometric observables for binaries; Penoyre et al. (2022a) , Penoyre et al. (2022b) , and Korol et al. (2022) used this framework to infer properties of the local binary population from the observed RUWE distribution. Most recently, Castro-Ginard et al. (2024) developed a model to quantify the selection function of RUWE -based binary samples, while Kiefer et al. (2024) used RUWE to select candidate exoplanet hosts. It is frequently assumed in the literature that parallaxes for source with large RUWE (most commonly, RUWE >1.4 ) are unreliable. However, it has not been quantified how unreliable, and under what conditions such parallaxes still contain useful information. One might expect, for example, that larger RUWE values result in less reliable parallaxes, or that nearby sources with large RUWE are less affected than distant ones with the same RUWE . Sources with elevated RUWE are often of particular astrophysical interest: for example, binaries that receive spectroscopic solutions but not astrometric orbital solutions are likely to have large RUWE ( Thompson et al., 2019 ; El-Badry & Quataert, 2021 ; Yamaguchi et al., 2024 ; Wang et al., 2024 , e.g.) , and distance is often the key uncertainty in measuring the physical properties of these systems. Poor astrometric solutions as quantified by RUWE are quite common. This is unsurprising, since an order unity fraction of all Gaia sources are binaries. For example, 17% of Gaia DR3 sources in the Gaia Catalog of Nearby Stars ( Gaia Collaboration et al., 2021 ) have RUWE >1.4 , and 22% have RUWE >1.25 . It is thus desirable to understand how to interpret the parallaxes and uncertainties of such sources. In this work, we show that while sources with elevated RUWE have underestimated uncertainties, the magnitude of the difference between the best-fit and true parallax can be accurately predicted from observables. The parallaxes of such sources can thus in most cases still yield useful distance constraints. The rest of the paper is organized as follows. In Section 2 , we describe simulations of Gaia epoch astrometry and astrometric model fitting. Section 3 summarizes a series of controlled experiments designed to estimate the parallax bias that results from unmodeled noise in the epoch astrometry. In Section 3.2 , we present a simple analytic fitting function that captures the trends revealed in our simulations and can be used to inflate published Gaia parallax uncertainties for sources with large RUWE . We validate this function using binaries with astrometric orbits and resolved wide binaries in Section 4 . We discuss our results and conclude in Section 5 . 2 Description of the simulations We simulate astrometric orbits for binaries using the gaiamock 2 2 2 https://github.com/kareemelbadry/gaiamock model, which is described in detail by El-Badry et al. (2024) . gaiamock generates realistic 1D epoch astrometry for binaries or single stars from the Gaia scanning law, using an empirical noise model based on the residuals of well-behaved astrometric sources. It then fits the epoch astrometry with an astrometric model; here, we consider only the five-parameter single-star model. Following the Gaia convention, gaiamock inflates the astrometric uncertainties of sources with poor fits. This is accomplished by inflating all the epoch astrometry uncertainties, and the uncertainties of the astrometric parameters, by a constant c=\sqrt{\chi^{2}/\left[\nu\left(1-\frac{2}{9\nu}\right)^{3}\right]}\approx\sqrt{\chi_{\nu}^{2}} . Here \nu is the number of astrometric epoch measurements minus five

Read the complete text