Solving the Phase Problem of Diffraction: X-ray Standing Waves Imaging on Bismuthene/SiC(0001)
Niclas Tilgner, Susanne Wolff, Serguei Soubatch, Tien-Lin Lee, Fabian Göhler, F. Stefan Tautz, Thomas Seyller, Philip Schädlich, Christian Kumpf · 2025
Read Solving the Phase Problem of Diffraction: X-ray Standing Waves Imaging on Bismuthene/SiC(0001) by Niclas Tilgner, Susanne Wolff, Serguei Soubatch, Tien-Lin Lee, Fabian Göhler, F. Stefan Tautz, Thomas Seyller, Philip Schädlich, Christian Kumpf (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-11413.txt.
Introduction
Niclas Tilgner led a large team imaging a thin bismuth layer in a 2025 paper. Diffraction methods normally lose the phase of scattered waves, which blocks a full picture of a sample. A standing wave method using X-rays gets around that loss. The team applied it to a two-atom-thick material prized for its quantum effects.
The bismuth layer sits between a silicon carbide base and a graphene sheet. Imaging showed that adding hydrogen shifts where the bismuth atoms sit under the graphene. One of three silicon bonds per cell takes up the hydrogen, and that small shift creates the layer's signature band pattern. The work shows the method can settle key structural questions directly.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Niclas Tilgner, Susanne Wolff, Serguei Soubatch, Tien-Lin Lee, Fabian Göhler, F. Stefan Tautz, Thomas Seyller, Philip Schädlich, Christian Kumpf |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 42 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-11413
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Solving the Phase Problem of Diffraction: X-ray Standing Waves Imaging on Bismuthene/SiC(0001) Niclas Tilgner, Susanne Wolff, Serguei Soubatch, Tien-Lin Lee, Fabian Göhler, F. Stefan Tautz, Thomas Seyller, Philip Schädlich, Christian Kumpf Abstract The phase retrieval problem is a fundamental shortcoming of all diffraction-based methods, arising from the inability to measure the phase of scattered waves. The (normal incidence) X-ray standing wave (NIXSW) technique circumvents this issue by introducing a (Bragg-generated) X-ray standing wave field throughout the sample, relative to which any atomic species can be localized by probing its fluorescence or photoelectron yield. In essence, in a single measurement the complex scattering factor (i.e., its amplitude and phase) corresponding to the used Bragg reflection is determined. Performing this for multiple Bragg reflections enables one to reconstruct the scattering density of the sample in three dimensions, straightforwardly as the Fourier sum of all measured (complex) scattering factors. Here, we utilize this technique to reveal the structural key features involved in the formation of the quantum spin Hall insulator bismuthene on silicon carbide. In this prominent example, the two-dimensional Bi layer is confined between a 4H-SiC substrate crystal and an epitaxial graphene layer. The key finding is a change in the adsorption site of the Bi atoms underneath the graphene upon hydrogenation, caused by the H-saturation of one (out of three) Si dangling bonds per unit cell. This structural change, clearly revealed by our NIXSW imaging experiment, is the key feature leading to the formation of the characteristic band structure of the 2D bismuthene honeycomb. \KOMAoption captionstableheading, figuresignature, nooneline, bottombeside, outerbeside Keywords: X-ray standing wave imaging, phase problem of diffraction techniques, bismuthene, graphene 1 Introduction Resolving the structure of surfaces, interfaces and thin films at the atomic scale is a fundamental prerequisite for understanding the properties and functionalities of almost any physical system or device. Prominent examples in this context are stacks of two-dimensional materials and van der Waals heterostructures, in particular novel materials with emerging properties, which are in the focus of intense research since the discovery of graphene about two decades ago. For the detailed structure determination in this (and many other) fields, various diffraction methods play a crucial role. However, it is well known that any diffraction experiment suffers from the fact that it can only determine the amplitudes of the scattering factors, since the measured intensities represent the absolute squares of the complex scattering factors, while the phases are lost. If amplitudes and phases of the structure factors were available, a simple and straightforward Fourier-backtransformation would be possible, resolving the atomic structure of the system in unrivaled clearness, without the necessity of any structural model refinement, and hence without the remaining uncertainty of whether or not the unique “best structure” has been found in the refinement. While in the past significant effort was invested in developing suitable workarounds for the phase problem, such as ab initio approaches (so called “direct methods”) [ 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 ] or the Patterson method [ 5 ] , there is one very elegant way of determining amplitudes and phases of the scattered waves in crystalline samples, namely the (Normal Incidence) X-ray Standing Waves ((NI)XSW) technique [ 6 , 7 , 8 , 9 , 10 ] . This technique exploits the interference pattern created by incident and Bragg reflected X-rays, which represents a standing wave field with a period corresponding to the Bragg plane spacing of the used reflection. The atoms within the structure can then be localized with respect to this standing wave field, since they absorb differently strong from the standing wave depending on their positions. The absorption yield is detected via photoelectrons or fluorescence. The NIXSW method, as described so far, allows the localization of the atomic species in one dimension, namely perpendicular to the Bragg planes used to generate the standing wave, that is the direction of the scattering vector \boldsymbol{H}= ( hkl ). In most of the recent NIXSW based studies on atomic and molecular adsorbates at surfaces and on 2D material heterostacks [ 11 , 12 , 13 , 14 , 15 ] , a reflection normal to the surface was used, in order to investigate vertical distances between adsorbates or layers and the substrate. These vertical distances were then interpreted in terms of bonding distances, revealing valuable insights into the nature of chemical interactions at surfaces (e.g., covalent or van der Waals). In some favorable cases it was possible to obtain also some lateral information, by utilizing reflections with a scattering vector not normal to the surface. This allows, e.g., to determine adsorption sites through triangulation [ 16 , 17 , 18 ] . However, this technique is often not feasible, in particular for systems with different surface terminations or multiple adsorption sites. Nonetheless, the fundamental brilliance of this approach is the fact that every single of these “one dimensional” NIXSW measurements on the scattering vector \boldsymbol{H} in fact provides two parameters, namely amplitude and phase of the \boldsymbol{H}^{\text{th}} (complex) structure factor \mathcal{F}_{\boldsymbol{H}} of that atomic species, the absorption yield of which was recorded. Since the structure factor \mathcal{F}_{\boldsymbol{H}} in turn represents the \boldsymbol{H}^{\text{th}} Fourier component of the three-dimensional atomic distribution [ 19 , 9 ] , a sufficiently complete set of individual NIXSW measurements on different (inequivalent) Bragg reflections \boldsymbol{H} opens the way to a Fourier analysis of the data. Hence, the atomic density in the crystal can be reconstructed, simply by calculating the Fourier sum of all experimentally available structure factors. This Fourier-based reconstruction is called “NIXSW imaging”, since it represents a model-free approach yielding a three-dimensional image of the atomic arrangement within the unit cell with sub-Angstrom resolution [ 20 , 19 , 9 ] . NIXSW imaging is capable of revealing intricate structural details in cases when conventional diffraction or microscopy methods may struggle to yield sufficient information, as we will demonstrate for the prominent example of bismuthene on SiC in the following. Note that, although this technique was suggested more than two decades ago [ 19 ] , it was hardly used owing to the fact that in-vacuum high-precision goniometers for reliable and reproducible sample orientation are required, but were not available until recently. In this paper, we report an NIXSW imaging experiment on a 2D heterostack consisting of a graphene layer on an intercalated Bi layer on 4H-SiC(0001), a system which at present attracts highest interest in the 2D materials community since it is discussed to form the 2D material bismuthene, a potential quantum spin Hall insulator. And in fact, the structural results we obtain in our study allowed us to identify the structural key feature that turns the intercalated Bi layer into 2D bismuthene. Contemporary research on confinement heteroepitaxy of Bi beneath epitaxial graphene on SiC(0001) identified two different Bi phases that are formed by intercalation of the graphene buffer layer [ 21 , 13 ] (which is often entitled zeroth layer graphene (ZLG) since it is hybridized with the substrate [ 22 , 23 , 24 ] ). In the intercalation process performed by Bi deposition on the sample surface and sequential annealing at elevated temperatures, at first the Bi α phase is formed with monolayer coverage and, in relation to the substrate’s