Size-Frequency Distribution of Terrestrial Leftover Planetesimals and S-complex Implanted Asteroids
Rogerio Deienno, André Izidoro, David Nesvorný, William F. Bottke, Fernando Roig, Simone Marchi · 2025
Read Size-Frequency Distribution of Terrestrial Leftover Planetesimals and S-complex Implanted Asteroids by Rogerio Deienno, André Izidoro, David Nesvorný, William F. Bottke, Fernando Roig, Simone Marchi (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-11405.txt.
Introduction
Some asteroids in the main belt carry chemical fingerprints of the Earth's neighborhood, as if they were born near the Sun and exiled outward. Rogerio Deienno and co-authors test that exile story in a 2025 simulation study. They ask whether planting leftover planet-building blocks into the belt reproduces the sizes of the asteroids seen today.
Their code follows growth and breakage of planetesimals while the terrestrial planets assemble. The team varied the starting mass spread, the lifetime of the gas disk, and the initial size slope. By the end, the leftover populations matched the observed size distribution of the implanted family closely across the 100-to-400-kilometer range. The match supports the picture of inner-born asteroids scattered into the belt.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Rogerio Deienno, André Izidoro, David Nesvorný, William F. Bottke, Fernando Roig, Simone Marchi |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 39 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-11405
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Size-Frequency Distribution of Terrestrial Leftover Planetesimals and S-complex Implanted Asteroids Rogerio Deienno, André Izidoro, David Nesvorný, William F. Bottke, Fernando Roig, Simone Marchi Abstract The isotopic composition of meteorites linked to S-complex asteroids has been used to suggest that these asteroids originated in the terrestrial planet’s region, i.e., within 1.5 au, and later got implanted into the main asteroid belt (MAB). Dynamical models of planet formation support this view. Yet, it remains to be demonstrated whether the currently observed size-frequency distribution (SFD) of S-complex bodies in the MAB can be reproduced via this implantation process. Here we studied the evolution of the SFD of planetesimals during the accretion of terrestrial planets with the code LIPAD self-consistently accounting for growth and fragmentation of planetesimals. In our simulations we vary the initial surface density of planetesimals, the gaseous disk lifetime, and the power slope of the initial planetesimals’ SFD. We compared the final SFDs of leftover planetesimals in the terrestrial planet region with the SFD of observed S-complex MAB objects (D > > 100km). We found that the SFDs of our planetesimal populations and that of S-complex MAB objects show very similar cumulative power index (i.e., q ≈ \approx 3.15 in N( > > D) ∝ ~\propto D -q ) for slopes in the diameter range 100 km < < D < < 400 km by the end of our simulations. Our results support the hypothesis of S-complex MAB implantation from the terrestrial planet forming region, assuming implantation is size-independent, and implies that implantation efficiency is smaller than 𝒪 \mathcal{O} (10 -2 –10 -4 ) to avoid over-implantation of (4) Vesta-sized objects or larger. I Introduction The MAB is known for having a small total mass ( {\rm\approx 5\times 10^{-4}} Earth masses 0.05 lunar masses) and for being primarily composed of S- and C-complex taxonomic class bodies [ 38 , 70 , 31 , e.g.] . Isotopic measurements from meteorites suggest C-complex bodies, many which are water/volatile-rich [ 86 , 13 , 17 , e.g.,] , are likely to have originated exterior to Jupiter’s orbit, whereas S-complex bodies, most which are relatively water/volatile-poor [ 51 , 13 , 17 , e.g.,] , come from the inner solar system [ 31 ] . The MAB’s low mass and taxonomic mixing 1 1 1 Characterized by the large dominance of S-complex bodies in the inner main belt, large C-complex bodies dominating the outer main belt, and a mix of both groups in the central main belt. strongly constrain formation models. Some models suggest the MAB was originally much more massive than it is today and later depleted due to the effects of a potential early giant planet migration [ 91 ] or orbital instabilities [ 21 ] . A key caveat against models invoking a massive MAB was pointed out in a new study by Deienno et al. [26] who demonstrated that the primordial MAB mass had to be no larger than \approx 4 times its current mass. A relatively massive MAB would have led to the formation of many large (D > 500 km) bodies in MAB that are not observed today and would have likely survived any subsequent depletion over the history of the solar system [ 26 ] . In contrast, the idea that the MAB was originally empty [ 81 , 82 ] or had a low initial mass [ 46 , 49 , 25 , 26 , 11 ] remains a viable and appealing hypothesis given its present-day low mass. In this view, the modern MAB would have formed primarily through the limited implantation of S- and C-complex asteroids that were scattered from their different source regions, i.e., the inner and outer solar system [ 81 , 82 , 24 , 25 , 26 , 63 , 73 , 1 , 44 , 45 ] . C-complex bodies are thought to have been scattered inwards and implanted predominantly in the central and outer MAB early in the solar system’s history, during the giant planet growth phase, when gas was still present in the protoplanetary disk. As Jupiter/Saturn grew and migrated, it would have scattered some planetesimals inward toward the Sun. Gas drag then acted to remove these objects from giant planets’ crossing orbits, allowing some of them to become trapped in the MAB. The terrestrial planets (having relatively low masses compared to growing gas giant planets) were not capable of gravitationally scattering objects from the inner solar system regions ( a< 1.5 au) into the MAB during the nebular gas phase. This holds true even if scattering occurred near the very end of the gas nebula phase, when the gas density was relatively low and its damping effect on scattered objects was potentially weaker. Therefore, unless considering the possibility of large-scale radial gas-driven migration of Jupiter and Saturn through the inner solar system [ 91 ] , the implantation of S-complex objects from the terrestrial planet region likely occurred after the dissipation of the solar nebula, and it may have been facilitated by additional processes as the giant planets’ orbital instability [ 23 , 21 , 1 , 44 ] . The bottom line is that, if we consider that implantation of S-complex bodies into the MAB was indeed necessary [ 26 , e.g., in case the MAB was originally low mass, or even empty;] and that Jupiter and Saturn never coursed through the inner solar system [ 91 ] , such implantation occurred relatively later in time than those of C-complex bodies. The initially empty or low mass MAB hypothesis is supported by recent models suggesting our solar system formed out off concentric rings of planetesimals at various radial distances around the Sun [ 58 , 43 , 67 , 73 ] . These models are motivated in part by the distinct isotopic compositions of non-carbonaceous (NC) and carbonaceous (CC) solar system materials [e.g., 92 , 55 , 71 , 14 , the so-called NC-CC isotopic dichotomy] . Under this framework, some models suggest that the terrestrial planets formed from a ring of material centered at 1 AU [ 40 , 43 , 67 ] and that the S-complex population in the MAB samples material from this region [ 82 , 44 ] . An open question arising from these scenarios is whether the SFD of the MAB components can be explained either by the implantation [ 91 , 82 , 44 , e.g.,] or local collisional growth [ 15 , 18 , e.g.,] of S- and C-complex asteroids. Here we focus on the former. Existing simulations modeling the implantation of planetesimals into the MAB have generally overlooked the effects of imperfect accretion and the long-term collisional evolution of planetesimals when comparing the implanted population to present-day observations. Collisional modeling work shows that the power law slope of the MAB’s SFD for objects 100 km \leq D \leq 400 km in diameter does not meaningfully change over solar system history [ 4 , see also Bottke et al. [5] , Morbidelli et al. [68] , Bottke et al. [8] ] . Based on that, Bottke et al. [4] concluded that the power law slope in this size range is a fossil of that population’s primordial SFD. This result