A Review of Stop-and-Go Traffic Wave Suppression Strategies: Variable Speed Limit vs. Jam-Absorption Driving

Zhengbing He, Jorge Laval, Yu Han, Andreas Hegyi, Ryosuke Nishi, Cathy Wu · 2025

Read A Review of Stop-and-Go Traffic Wave Suppression Strategies: Variable Speed Limit vs. Jam-Absorption Driving by Zhengbing He, Jorge Laval, Yu Han, Andreas Hegyi, Ryosuke Nishi, Cathy Wu (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-11372.txt.

Introduction

Zhengbing He and co-authors review in 2025 two ways to calm stop-and-go waves on freeways. These waves are rolling jams that travel backward through traffic and waste fuel, time, and safety. One method sets changing speed limits ahead of the wave. The other, called jam-absorption driving, has a few cars drive in a way that soaks up the jam.

The two fields grew apart despite shared roots. The review sums up twenty years of work in each and then bridges them. It compares their traffic models, data needs, and field tests, and names open problems. The authors hope each side can borrow the other's strengths to clear roads faster.

Catalog record

CREATORZhengbing He, Jorge Laval, Yu Han, Andreas Hegyi, Ryosuke Nishi, Cathy Wu
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE62 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-11372

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A Review of Stop-and-Go Traffic Wave Suppression Strategies: Variable Speed Limit vs. Jam-Absorption Driving Zhengbing He, Jorge Laval, Yu Han, Andreas Hegyi, Ryosuke Nishi, Cathy Wu Abstract The main form of freeway traffic congestion is the familiar stop-and-go wave, characterized by wide moving jams that propagate indefinitely upstream provided enough traffic demand. They cause severe, long-lasting adverse effects, such as reduced traffic efficiency, increased driving risks, and higher vehicle emissions. This underscores the crucial importance of artificial intervention in the propagation of stop-and-go waves. Over the past two decades, two prominent strategies for stop-and-go wave suppression have emerged: variable speed limit (VSL) and jam-absorption driving (JAD). Although they share similar research motivations, objectives, and theoretical foundations, the development of these strategies has remained relatively disconnected. To synthesize fragmented advances and drive the field forward, this paper first provides a comprehensive review of the achievements in the stop-and-go wave suppression-oriented VSL and JAD, respectively. It then focuses on bridging the two areas and identifying research opportunities from the following perspectives: fundamental diagrams, secondary waves, generalizability, traffic state estimation and prediction, robustness to randomness, scenarios for strategy validation, and field tests and practical deployment. We expect that through this review, one area can effectively address its limitations by identifying and leveraging the strengths of the other, thus promoting the overall research goal of freeway stop-and-go wave suppression. I Introduction I-A Stop-and-Go Waves on Freeways While driving through freeway stop-and-go traffic, vehicles alternate between accelerating and decelerating, resulting in adverse effects, such as reduced traffic efficiency and longer travel times [ 1 , 2 ] , significant fuel consumption and increased emissions [ 3 , 4 ] , and a substantial increase in the risk of traffic accidents [ 5 , 6 ] . As shown in Figure 1 , stop-and-go waves (also referred to as wide moving jams or traffic oscillations) are a common form of traffic congestion on freeways worldwide. In the time-space diagrams of traffic speed, a stop-and-go wave appears as a striped low-speed region propagating upstream, against the direction of traffic flow. Physically, on the freeway, a stop-and-go wave is essentially a backward-moving queue with an approximately constant queue length. As vehicles traverse these queues, they typically undergo a sequence of deceleration, low-speed cruising or even standstill, followed by acceleration. The main features of stop-and-go waves are as follows. Stop-and-go waves propagate against the traffic direction at a speed of 10 \sim 20 km/h, i.e., the slope of the waves in the time-space diagram or backward-moving speed of the queues [ 7 , 8 , 9 , 10 , 11 , 12 ] . Depending on the speed of vehicles within a moving queue, the discharge rate (i.e., the outflow rate of the moving queue) can be up to 25% lower than the capacity [ 13 ] . It is common to observe that stop-and-go waves propagate upstream while maintaining their structure even tens of kilometers [ 14 , 15 , 16 , 17 ] , severely impacting both traffic and the environment. As shown in Figure 1 (e), some stop-and-go waves propagate upstream for as far as 50 km. Fig. 1: Global observations on freeway stop-and-go waves. The striped low-speed regions propagating upstream against the direction of traffic flow are referred to as stop-and-go waves. (a) Nashville, TN, USA: 6.7 km (sourced from [ 17 ] ); (b) Osaka City, Japan: 2 km (sourced from [ 18 ] ); (c) California, USA: 0.6 km (sourced from [ 19 ] ); (d) Rotterdam, Netherlands: 23 km (sourced from [ 20 ] ); (e) Florida, USA: 190 km (sourced from [ 16 ] ); (f) London, UK: 18 km (sourced from [ 14 ] ). I-B Stop-and-Go Wave Suppression Strategies There are mainly two types of freeway traffic control strategies that were proposed to dissipate stop-and-go waves. One strategy is to control traffic by disseminating variable speed limits (VSL), and the other is based on a dedicated vehicle to perform jam-absorption driving (JAD). VSL is typically disseminated through variable message signs (VMS) installed on gantries along the freeway. To ensure the effectiveness of an advanced VSL algorithm, a series of gantries is usually required, with the distance between two gantries commonly being about 500 \sim 1000 meters, as seen in the Netherlands [ 21 ] and the United States [ 22 ] . JAD is a driving strategy that guides a dedicated vehicle to perform “slow-in” and “fast-out” actions before being captured by a stop-and-go wave. Ideally, it can hold and guide all vehicles behind to approach an upcoming wave as planned, thereby achieving the goal of stop-and-go wave suppression. The two types of strategies have many similarities, such as the goal, affected object, as well as theoretical and methodological questions (see Table I ). In particular, both share the same underlying logic, i.e., attempting to suppress stop-and-go waves by reducing the inflow. In contrast, the primary differences arise from the control object: one strategy presents VSL via VMS, while the other employs a dedicated vehicle (see Table II ). As claimed by JAD literature, compared to VSL, JAD offers several advantages, such as requiring significantly less investment due to the absence of infrastructure construction and providing greater flexibility since VSL must be disseminated through fixed gantries and VMS. TABLE I: Similarities between VSL and JAD. Aspect Details Goal Suppressing stop-and-go waves Affected object Traffic flow Underlying logic Reducing inflow Theoretical question (1) Can stop-and-go waves be suppressed? (2) Will secondary waves be triggered? Methodological question (1) When to activate the strategy? (2) How to implement the strategy? TABLE II: Differences between VSL and JAD. Aspect Details VSL JAD Main object of control Speed limit Vehicle Feature of control object Continuous in time, Continuous in time, discrete in space space and value and value Control source Outside traffic † Inside traffic ‡ Difficulty of execution Low High Flexibility of execution Low High Flexibility of deployment Low High Cost of deployment High Low 1 \dagger VSL acts on the traffic flow from outside the flow itself. 2 \ddagger The JAD vehicle acts within the traffic flow as an integral part of it. I-C Motivation Despite many similarities, particularly in goals, underlying logic, and research questions, a disconnection between the two areas is observed, as evidenced by the following two examples. • Among the selected VSL and JAD papers identified as representative works, none of the VSL papers cite JAD studies, even though, as we will show later, a trend toward incorporating connected and automated vehicles (CAVs) into VSL is observed. In contrast, JAD papers tend to reference VSL works, albeit not comprehensively (Figure 2 ). • In VSL papers the term “shock wave” is predominantly used, whereas JAD papers more commonly use “stop-and-go wave” or “oscillation.” Although these terms describe similar types of traffic jams, the differences in terminology may lead to difficulties in discovering each other’s work through search engines. Fig. 2: Citations among the selected VSL and JAD papers. The VSL papers cite other VSL papers 29 times, and the JAD papers cite other JAD papers 27 times. While the JAD papers cite VSL papers 20 times, no VSL papers have cited the JAD papers. The disconnection results in

Read the complete text