Constraints on Generalized Gravity-Thermodynamic Cosmology from DESI DR2
Udit K. Tyagi, Sandeep Haridasu, Soumen Basak · 2025
Read Constraints on Generalized Gravity-Thermodynamic Cosmology from DESI DR2 by Udit K. Tyagi, Sandeep Haridasu, Soumen Basak (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-11308.txt.
Introduction
Tyagi, Haridasu, and Basak test a family of gravity-thermodynamics cosmologies against the newest sky surveys, in a 2025 paper. Their models generalize the entropy rule that links gravity with heat, adding three or four free parameters. In limiting cases the family reproduces several named entropy proposals from the literature.
The team implemented the models numerically and fit them with Bayesian methods. Data came from two supernova collections plus fresh baryon acoustic oscillation measures from the DESI survey. The fits favored the standard entropy rule, giving late-time behavior close to the standard cosmological model. A three-parameter version captured the dark energy pattern well enough; a fourth parameter added nothing. Head-to-head evidence strongly preferred plain standard cosmology over the whole family. The authors read this as a tightening noose around exotic entropy-based dark energy.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Udit K. Tyagi, Sandeep Haridasu, Soumen Basak |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 46 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-11308
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Constraints on Generalized Gravity-Thermodynamic Cosmology from DESI DR2 Udit K. Tyagi, Sandeep Haridasu, Soumen Basak Abstract We explore the cosmological implications of generalized entropic models within the framework of Gravity–Thermodynamics (GT) approaches. These models, characterized by three or four additional free parameters, are designed to capture deviations from the standard Bekenstein–Hawking entropy and can reproduce well-known entropic formulations, including Tsallis, Rényi, Sharma–Mittal, Barrow, Kaniadakis, and Loop Quantum Gravity entropies in various analytical limits. We implement the corresponding cosmological models using a fully numerical GT approach to constrain the model parameters and to study the evolution of the dark energy equation of state as a function of the scale factor. Our Bayesian analysis, which incorporates the Pantheon+ and DESy5 supernovae data alongside the recently released DESI-DR2/DR1 Baryon Acoustic Oscillation (BAO) measurements, shows that the data favor the standard Bekenstein–Hawking entropy, leading to a Λ \Lambda CDM-like late-time behavior. In this context, the three-parameter ( 𝒮 3 \mathcal{S}_{3} ) entropic model appears to be sufficient to capture the observed dark energy phenomenology. Furthermore, a direct comparison of the Bayesian evidence indicates that the three-parameter model is preferred over the four-parameter ( 𝒮 4 \mathcal{S}_{4} ) variant by a factor of Δ log ℬ ∼ − 6 \Delta\log\mathcal{B}\sim-6 , while the GT approach as a whole is significantly disfavored relative to the Λ \Lambda CDM model with at least Δ log ℬ ∼ − 8 \Delta\log\mathcal{B}\sim-8 ( 𝒮 3 \mathcal{S}_{3} ) to Δ log ℬ ∼ − 13 \Delta\log\mathcal{B}\sim-13 ( 𝒮 4 \mathcal{S}_{4} ), when using the DESy5 and DESI-DR2 datasets. I Introduction The standard Bekenstein–Hawking (BH) entropy has long served as a cornerstone in our understanding of black hole thermodynamics. According to this foundational framework, a black hole’s entropy is proportional to its horizon area Hawking 1975 ; Bekenstein 1973 ; Bardeen et al. 1973 ; Bekenstein 1994a . When first proposed, this result was considered anomalous, since the entropy of conventional thermodynamic systems typically scales with volume rather than surface area. Over the years, this unique non-extensive property of black holes, along with its deep connection to strongly quantum-entangled d -dimensional systems, has been extensively studied Tsallis and Cirto 2013 ; Zhang 2015 ; Zhang 2017 ; Majhi 2017 ; Chunaksorn et al. 2025 ; Tsallis 2020 ; Elizalde et al. 2025 . More recently, numerous generalizations of the BH entropy have been proposed Nojiri et al. 2021 ; Elizalde et al. 2025 ; Nojiri et al. 2023a . These extended formulations incorporate non-extensive statistical frameworks into conventional thermodynamics. Notable examples include Tsallis entropy Tsallis 1988 , Rényi entropy Rényi 1960 , Barrow entropy Barrow 2020 , Sharma–Mittal entropy Sharma and Mittal 1975 ; Sharma and Mittal 1977 , Kaniadakis entropy Kaniadakis 2005 , and entropies inspired by Loop Quantum Gravity Czinner and Iguchi 2016 ; Majhi 2017 ; Mejrhit and Ennadifi 2019 ; Liu 2022 . For a detailed discussion, see Nojiri et al. 2022a ; Nojiri et al. 2023b ; Nojiri et al. 2024a . Despite their diverse formulations, these extended entropy models share universal characteristics: they reduce to the standard BH entropy under specific limiting conditions and exhibit monotonic growth with respect to the BH variable Nojiri et al. 2021 ; Nojiri et al. 2022b . This universal behavior suggests the potential existence of a unified entropy framework that encompasses all these models. In recent works Odintsov et al. 2023 ; Odintsov and Paul 2024 ; Nojiri et al. 2024a ; Nojiri et al. 2022b ; Bolotin and Yanovsky 2023 ; Nojiri et al. 2021 , unified frameworks have been proposed that combine various entropy models into a single formulation, known as the ”Four-Parameter Entropy.” This generalized entropy, governed by four free parameters, is capable of reproducing all the aforementioned entropy forms in particular limits. Moreover, the Four-Parameter Entropy can be further reduced to a Three-Parameter Entropy, which encompasses most entropy models except Kaniadakis entropy Odintsov et al. 2023 . Since its inception, this unified framework has been extensively studied for its cosmological implications Nojiri et al. 2022b ; Elizalde et al. 2025 . Notably, it has been demonstrated in Nojiri et al. 2022b that entropic cosmology based on these generalized entropy models offers a unified description of the universe’s evolution from an early inflationary phase, characterized by a quasi–de Sitter expansion ending near 58 e-folds, to a late-time dark energy–dominated era consistent with recent Planck data Aghanim et al. 2020a . In a separate study, Odintsov et al. 2023 examined the transition from inflation to reheating, showing that the entropic energy density drives inflation and decays smoothly into relativistic particles during reheating. The inclusion of entropic parameters facilitates a seamless evolution of the Hubble parameter, transitioning from the inflationary quasi–de Sitter phase to a power-law reheating phase characterized by a constant equation-of-state parameter. The entropic models discussed above have been widely applied in constructing cosmological models Odintsov et al. 2023 ; Leon et al. 2021a ; Naeem and Bibi 2024 ; Saridakis et al. 2018 ; Nojiri et al. 2022a ; Nakarachinda et al. 2023 ; Fazlollahi 2023 ; Kord Zangeneh and Sheykhi 2023 ; Salehi 2023 ; Nojiri et al. 2022c ; Nojiri et al. 2019 ; Nojiri et al. 2022b ; Odintsov and Paul 2023 ; Nojiri et al. 2022d ; Nojiri et al. 2023c ; Nojiri et al. 2024b ; Manoharan 2024 ; Manoharan et al. 2023 . These models draw inspiration from black hole thermodynamics by extending its principles to the cosmological horizon. Two primary frameworks are used to construct such models: the Holographic Principle Bousso 2000 ; Bousso 2002 ; Li 2004 ; Wang et al. 2017a ; Abdalla and Correa-Borbonet 2002 ; Susskind 1995 ; Corianò and Frampton 2019 ; Granda 2011 and the Gravity–Thermodynamics Principle Jacobson 1995 ; Cai and Kim 2005 ; Padmanabhan 2005 ; Padmanabhan 2010 . Both methods rely on drawing an analogy between the black hole event horizon and the cosmological horizon to reveal the thermodynamic properties of spacetime. However, different entropy formulations could potentially yield distinct cosmological predictions, raising the important question: which entropy, and by extension, which model, is most favored by the observational data? In our previous work Tyagi et al. 2024 , we demonstrated that cosmological models derived from the Holographic Principle (see also Li et al. 2024 ; Li and Wang 2024 for a recent discussion) achieve marginally better Bayesian evidence when compared to those constructed using the Gravity-Thermodynamics Principle. Following which, in this work we further test the Gravity-Thermodynamic approach’s viability 1 1 1 See also Carroll and Remmen 2016 for a discussion on the limitations of the GT approach, where it has been suggested that it cannot provide a consistent description the entropy. utilizing the most-recent late-time data. To address this, we adopt the Gravity–Thermodynamics (GT) Principle to construct cosmological models based on the generalized Four-Parameter Entropy and its reduced Three-Parameter form. As an added advantage, the generalized entropy formalism allows one to perform model selection without having to rely on testing each model individually against the data, which is in turn one of our primary motive. Also, given the more recent Baryon Acoustic Oscillation (BAO) data from DESI-DR2 Abdul Karim et al.