Differentiating Formation Models with New Dynamical Masses for the PDS 70 Protoplanets
David Trevascus, Sarah Blunt, Valentin Christiaens, Elisabeth Matthews, Iain Hammond, Wolfgang Brandner, Jason Wang, Sylvestre Lacour, Arthur Vigan, William O. Balmer, Mickael Bonnefoy, Remo Burn, Gaël Chauvin, Raffaele Gratton, Mathis Houllé, Sasha Hinkley, Jens Kammerer, Laura Kreidberg, Gabriel-D · 2025
Read Differentiating Formation Models with New Dynamical Masses for the PDS 70 Protoplanets by David Trevascus, Sarah Blunt, Valentin Christiaens, Elisabeth Matthews, Iain Hammond, Wolfgang Brandner, Jason Wang, Sylvestre Lacour, Arthur Vigan, William O. Balmer, Mickael Bonnefoy, Remo Burn, Gaël Chauvin, Raffaele Gratton, Mathis Houllé, Sasha Hinkley, Jens Kammerer, Laura Kreidberg, Gabriel-D (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-11210.txt.
Introduction
David Trevascus and a large team weigh two baby planets caught still forming around a young star. The planets, in the PDS 70 disk, are among the few ever photographed directly. How planets are born, hot or cold, changes how bright they should shine. Mass is the missing key to telling the stories apart.
New positions from a sharp infrared instrument on a major telescope tightened the planets' orbits. From those orbits come firm upper limits on each planet's mass. A third candidate planet was tested in the fit, but its orbits proved unstable. The limits rule out the coldest birth stories for both known planets. Each must have kept a set floor of heat after forming. The work sharpens a rare direct test of planet birth theory.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | David Trevascus, Sarah Blunt, Valentin Christiaens, Elisabeth Matthews, Iain Hammond, Wolfgang Brandner, Jason Wang, Sylvestre Lacour, Arthur Vigan, William O. Balmer, Mickael Bonnefoy, Remo Burn, Gaël Chauvin, Raffaele Gratton, Mathis Houllé, Sasha Hinkley, Jens Kammerer, Laura Kreidberg, Gabriel-D |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 54 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-11210
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Differentiating Formation Models with New Dynamical Masses for the PDS 70 Protoplanets David Trevascus, Sarah Blunt, Valentin Christiaens, Elisabeth Matthews, Iain Hammond, Wolfgang Brandner, Jason Wang, Sylvestre Lacour, Arthur Vigan, William O. Balmer, Mickael Bonnefoy, Remo Burn, Gaël Chauvin, Raffaele Gratton, Mathis Houllé, Sasha Hinkley, Jens Kammerer, Laura Kreidberg, Gabriel-Dominique Marleau, Dino Mesa, Gilles Otten, Mathias Nowak, Emily Rickman, Joel Sanchez-Bermudez, Jonas Sauter Abstract Hot- and cold-start planet formation models predict differing luminosities for the young, bright planets that direct imaging surveys are most sensitive to. However, precise mass estimates are required to distinguish between these models observationally. The presence of two directly imaged planets, PDS 70 b and c , in the PDS 70 protoplanetary disk provides us a unique opportunity for dynamical mass measurements, since the masses for these planets are currently poorly constrained. Fitting orbital parameters to new astrometry of these planets, taken with VLTI/GRAVITY in the K K band, we find 2 σ 2\sigma dynamical upper mass limits of 4.9 M Jup M_{\rm Jup} for b and 13.6 M Jup M_{\rm Jup} for c . Adding astrometry from the newly proposed planet candidate PDS 70 d into our model, we determine 2 σ 2\sigma dynamical upper mass limits of 5.3 M Jup M_{\rm Jup} , 7.5 M Jup M_{\rm Jup} and 2.2 M Jup M_{\rm Jup} for b , c , and the candidate d respectively. However, N N -body analysis of the orbits fit in this case suggest that the inclusion of d d makes the system unstable. Using the upper mass limits for b and c we rule out the coldest-start formation models for both planets, calculating minimum post-formation entropies ( S i S_{i} ) of 9.5 k B / baryon k_{\mathrm{B}}/\mathrm{baryon} and 8.4 k B / baryon k_{\mathrm{B}}/\mathrm{baryon} respectively. This places PDS 70 b and c on the growing list of directly-imaged planets inconsistent with cold-start formation. 1 Introduction The sensitivity of direct-imaging surveys is highly dependent on the assumed model of planet formation. Hot-start ( Baraffe et al., 2003 ; Phillips et al., 2020 , e.g.,) , warm-start ( Spiegel & Burrows, 2012 ; Linder et al., 2019 , e.g.,) , and cold-start ( Marley et al., 2007 ; Fortney et al., 2008 , e.g.,) planet evolution models all assume different post-formation entropies ( S_{i} ), leading to differing luminosity predictions for young planets \lessapprox 100 Myr old, which are the typical targets of these surveys. Planet masses are traditionally inferred from evolutionary models ( Bowler, 2016 , e.g.,) , but these mass estimates are often poorly constrained and dependent upon the choice of model. However, dynamical mass estimation can provide model-independent planet masses with much stronger constraints, such as for \beta Pic b and c ( Brandt et al., 2021a ) , HR 8799 e ( Brandt et al., 2021b ; Zurlo et al., 2022 ) and AF Lep b ( Balmer et al., 2024 ) . Moreover, precise dynamical mass estimates, in combination with planet ages and luminosities, can be used to constrain S_{i} for these planets and therefore rule out certain hot-, warm- or cold-start models ( Marleau & Cumming, 2014 ) . PDS 70 is a young ( 5.4\pm 1.0 Myr, Müller et al. 2018 ) system containing two directly-imaged planets, PDS 70 b ( Keppler et al., 2018 ) and PDS 70 c ( Haffert et al., 2019 ) , orbiting within a protoplanetary disk ( Riaud et al., 2006 ) . While the age of this system would allow us to differentiate between hot- and cold-start formation, these planets present a particular challenge for dynamical mass fitting, since the currently available astrometry covers a relatively small fraction of their total orbital periods. Wang et al. (2021) determined a 2\sigma upper mass limit for b of 10 M_{\rm Jup} , but were unable to constrain the mass of c within their uniform prior of 1–15 M_{\rm Jup} . Given its ability to achieve astrometric precisions down to 50 \upmu as ( GRAVITY Collaboration et al., 2017 ; GRAVITY Collaboration et al., 2020 ) , the GRAVITY instrument on the Very Large Telescope Interferometer (VLTI) is well placed to provide the precise relative astrometry necessary for dynamical mass estimates in exoplanetary systems ( Balmer et al., 2024 , e.g.,) . Recently, Christiaens et al. (2024) reported the detection of a point-like signal located near the outer edge of the PDS 70 inner disk compatible with the presence of a third protoplanet in the system. This new planet candidate, referred to from here as PDS 70 d , is consistent with similar features observed with VLT/SPHERE high-contrast imaging by Mesa et al. (2019) and re-reductions of VLT/SINFONI, VLT/NaCo and VLT/SPHERE imaging ( Hammond et al., 2025 ) . However, current observations do not eliminate the possibility that this signal belongs to a dusty feature of the protoplanetary disc. In this paper, we use new GRAVITY observations of PDS 70 b and c to fit orbital parameters to these planets, including updated dynamical mass estimates. The observations are described in Section 2 . In Section 3.1 we fit orbital parameters to a two-planet system described by astrometry from b and c only. In Section 3.2 we fit orbital parameters to a three-planet system described by astrometry from b , c and the candidate d . In Section 4 we use our dynamical mass estimates from both scenarios to constrain S_{i} for these planets, and determine which of the hot-, warm-, and cold-start evolutionary models are consistent with these masses. We discuss our results in Section 5 and our conclusions are given in Section 6 . 2 Observations and Data Reduction 2.1 GRAVITY Observations The new astrometric measurements presented in this paper were obtained between Jan 2021 and Feb 2022 with the GRAVITY instrument ( GRAVITY Collaboration et al., 2017 ) and the four 8m Unit Telescopes (UTs) of ESO’s VLTI. The star PDS 70 A itself served as the visual natural guide star for the adaptive optics and as the K -band fringe tracking reference source. We collected data using the K -band medium resolution mode ( R\approx 500 ). The observing set-up followed the strategy outlined in Nowak et al. (2020) and Wang et al. (2021) . Table 1 gives an overview on the observing dates, integration times on each planet, and atmospheric conditions. In our analysis (see Section 3 ) we combined this new data with GRAVITY astrometry from Wang et al. (2021) . Table 1: Observing log of the new GRAVITY astrometric measurements reported in this paper. MJD corresponds to the halftime of each observing sequence. 1 1 1 Notes. Date MJD Planet DIT/NDIT/NEXP Airmass Seeing \tau_{0} Proposal ID [arcsec] [ms] 2021-01-07 a aa a aa a Data of lower quality. This epoch has been ignored in the subsequent analysis. 59221.37 b 100s/4/3 1.20–1.38 0.70–1.21 4.6–6.4 1104.C-0651 2021-01-08 59222.34 c 100s/4/5 1.26–1.69 0.37–0.65 4.8–8.6 1104.C-0651 2021-03-28 59301.24 c 100s/4/4 1.05–1.09 0.66–0.94 3.8–5.0 105.209D 2021-03-29 59302.25 c 100s/4/4 1.04–1.07 0.42–0.56 5.4–7.1 105.209D 2021-04-03 59307.23 c 100s/4/4 1.04–1.08 0.48–0.76 4.1–7.1 105.209D 2021-05-29 59363.10 c 100s/4/8 1.04–1.08 0.48–0.98 3.3–6.3 105.209D 2021-05-31 59365.03 c 100s/4/4 1.07–1.17 0.59–0.79 2.4–4.8 105.209D 2022-02-21 59631.28 b 100s/4/12 1.05–1.53 0.57–1.41 1.9–9.1 1104.C-0651 2022-02-21 59631.28