The Lifetime of the Covid Memorial Wall: Modelling with Collections Demography, Social Media Data and Citizen Science

Josep Grau-Bové, Mara Cruz, Pakhee Kumar · 2025

Read The Lifetime of the Covid Memorial Wall: Modelling with Collections Demography, Social Media Data and Citizen Science by Josep Grau-Bové, Mara Cruz, Pakhee Kumar (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-11196.txt.

Introduction

Josep Grau-Bové, Mara Cruz, and Pakhee Kumar modeled the survival of London's National Covid Memorial Wall in 2025. The wall carries hundreds of thousands of hand-painted red hearts, one for each life lost, and the original paint fades fast. Volunteers were repainting at a pace that could not hold, and switching to a better paint raises its own planning questions. The study asks what maintenance rate would keep the memorial looking cared for.

Borrowing collections demography, a framework from museum conservation, and feeding it with citizen science observations and social media data, the authors ran agent-based simulations that carry all the measured uncertainties forward. Even with better paint, some hundreds of hearts a week must be repainted to hold a stable share in good condition. The work shows heritage decisions can rest on explicit modeling rather than hope.

Catalog record

CREATORJosep Grau-Bové, Mara Cruz, Pakhee Kumar
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE45 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-11196

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The Lifetime of the Covid Memorial Wall: Modelling with Collections Demography, Social Media Data and Citizen Science Josep Grau-Bové, Mara Cruz, Pakhee Kumar Abstract The National Covid Memorial Wall in London, featuring over 240,000 hand-painted red hearts, faces significant conservation challenges due to the rapid fading of the paint. This study evaluates the transition to a better-quality paint and its implications for the wall’s long-term preservation. The rapid fading of the initial materials required an unsustainable repainting rate, burdening volunteers. Lifetime simulations based on a collections demography framework suggest that repainting efforts must continue at a rate of some hundreds of hearts per week to maintain a stable percentage of hearts in good condition. This finding highlights the need for a sustainable management strategy that includes regular maintenance or further reduction of the fading rate. Methodologically, this study demonstrates the feasibility of using a collections demography approach, supported by citizen science and social media data, to inform heritage management decisions. An agent-based simulation is used to propagate the multiple uncertainties measured. The methodology provides a robust basis for modeling and decision-making, even in a case like this, where reliance on publicly available images and volunteer-collected data introduces variability. Future studies could improve data within a citizen science framework by inviting public submissions, using on-site calibration charts, and increasing volunteer involvement for longitudinal data collection. This research illustrates the flexibility of the collections demography framework, firstly by showing its applicability to an outdoor monument, which is very different from the published case studies, and secondly by demonstrating how it can work even with low-quality data. keywords collections demography, memorial, fading, lifetimes 1 Introduction This paper argues that collections demography can be effectively applied to outdoor monuments using low-cost data from citizen science and social media. The National Covid Memorial Wall, located opposite the Houses of Parliament in London, has two main conservation concerns: preventing its hearts from fading and finding a long-term sustainable management strategy. These two concerns are related, because the expense of maintenance depends on the rate of fading. With more than 240,000 red hearts painted on it, the memorial stands as a visual tribute to the lives lost during the pandemic. Each heart in the mural symbolises a human loss directly attributed to COVID-19 in the United Kingdom National Covid Memorial Wall 2024 . Currently, due to weathering, the hearts are losing their red colour, which is noticeable along the entire memorial wall. The process of paint fading entails a weakening of colour saturation due to light exposure or chemical reactions, such as those caused by sunlight or rain Weyer et al. 2015 . Understanding the lifetime of the painted hearts is of special interest to the volunteers currently managing and fighting for the preservation of the wall. Each week, a group of volunteers from the Covid-19 Bereaved Families for Justice meet to repaint the hearts that have faded due to environmental factors Booth 2021 . This work is significant, as it requires substantial efforts given the large number of hearts and the size of the wall. Therefore, in this paper, we follow a heritage science modelling approach to examine the ageing process and how different management strategies results in future rates of fading of the Covid Memorial Wall. Heritage collections can be defined by a lifetime Strlič et al. 2013 . The concept of ‘collections demography’, which was introduced by Strlič et al. Strlič 2013 , involves the systematic study of the ageing of collections. Within this framework, collections are treated as populations of objects, wherein the focus is on assessing how different pre-existing conditions and preventive measures impact their lifetimes Duran-Casablancas et al. 2021 . This approach demonstrates significant potential as a tool to support decision-making in heritage practice, as evidenced by the work of Duran-Casablancas et al. Duran-Casablancas et al. 2024 , which explores archival collections using agent-based modelling. In addition, recent policy developments, specially in relation to Cultural Capital in the UK, are emphasizing the benefits of extending damage modelling to different heritage assets Sagger and Bezzano 2024 . However, the application of collections demography to new collection types is limited by the resources, data and time that are required. The basic steps of this framework (which are reviewed in section 3 , and are modelling change, understanding values, surveying collections, and predicting lifetimes) have mostly been conducted within the context of funded academic research projects. Collections demography, as described in the existing literature, requires extensive data, both on the nature of chemical change and on the condition of the collection under study. Therefore, the complexity of the collections demography framework is a significant constraint on a method that has a great potential to inform decision-making in the heritage field. This paper challenges this limitation by presenting a comprehensive collections demography workflow, conducted at no cost by using mostly publicly available data and citizen science (CS). In simplified terms, CS involves the participation of nonexperts in scientific research Haklay 2013 . Participation in CS projects enables individuals to contribute to science through their intellectual efforts and knowledge, or by providing resources Serrano et al. 2014 . A related concept is Crowdsourcing, an umbrella term for a variety of approaches in which a large group of people perform small tasks in order to achieve a collective goal. Numerous studies have demonstrated the adaptability of CS and crow sourcing to different scales and subjects of study many fields, including heritage, for example by monitoring threatened heritage sites Brigham et al. 2022 , counting birds to understand population dynamics during a pandemic Coldren 2022 , classifying galaxies Raddick et al. 2019 or measuring light pollution at night Nugent 2017 , to cite some examples. The prominence of the National Covid Memorial Wall, and the wide availability of photographs of the hearts in social media, present an ideal scenario for developing a low-cost collections demography workflow than can inform its management. In addition to being a highly visible public monument, the physical properties of the wall are also well-suited to collections demography. It hosts a “collection” of hundreds of thousands of hearts, with similar properties, and which age in a similar way. The ageing process, fading, can easily be measured with a clear metric, colour. The time-scale of fading is such that short, multiple-month experiments can capture change. It also benefits from the involvement of a highly motivated group of volunteers who are eager to collaborate with scientists and actively explore various preservation strategies during the research period. Therefore, this paper aims to: • present a complete low-cost collections demography workflow that relies on CS and social media; • study, through the case of the National Covid Memorial Wall, the benefits and limitations of this approach; and • use the resulting model to examine possible management scenarios for the National Covid Memorial Wall. After providing an overview of the memorial and the fading process of its painted hearts, the paper details the methodology behind the fading measurements, including data collection, image calibration, and citizen science experiments. The research then explores the acceptability of fading through surveys and introduces a series of agent-based models to evaluate various management strategies for the memorial. The paper concludes by analysing the effectiveness

Read the complete text