Similarity Constrained CC2 for Efficient Coupled Cluster Nonadiabatic Dynamics

Leo Stoll, Sara Angelico, Eirik F. Kjønstad, Henrik Koch · 2025

Read Similarity Constrained CC2 for Efficient Coupled Cluster Nonadiabatic Dynamics by Leo Stoll, Sara Angelico, Eirik F. Kjønstad, Henrik Koch (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-11157.txt.

Introduction

Leo Stoll and co-authors fix a chemistry simulation flaw in a 2025 paper. Coupled cluster methods predict molecular energies with high accuracy. Excited molecules, though, pass through crossing points where two states swap character. There, the standard method spits out impossible complex energies, which blocks simulations of light driven motion.

A constrained cousin of the method avoids that failure but costs more. The new model brings the fix to the cheaper CC2 level while keeping its favorable scaling. Crossing points then show the right shape and real energies. Tests on a small acid and on thymine, a DNA letter, display the crossings as they should look.

Catalog record

CREATORLeo Stoll, Sara Angelico, Eirik F. Kjønstad, Henrik Koch
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE32 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-11157

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Similarity Constrained CC2 for Efficient Coupled Cluster Nonadiabatic Dynamics Leo Stoll, Sara Angelico, Eirik F. Kjønstad, Henrik Koch Abstract Despite their high accuracy, standard coupled cluster models cannot be used for nonadiabatic molecular dynamics simulations because they yield unphysical complex excitation energies at conical intersections between same-symmetry excited states. On the other hand, similarity constrained coupled cluster theory has enabled the application of coupled cluster theory in such dynamics simulations. Here, we present a similarity constrained perturbative doubles (SCC2) model with same-symmetry excited-state conical intersections that exhibit correct topography, topology, and real excitation energies. This is achieved while retaining the favorable computational scaling of the standard CC2 model. We illustrate the model for conical intersections in hypofluorous acid and thymine, and compare its performance with other methods. The results demonstrate that conical intersections between excited states can be described correctly and efficiently at the SCC2 level. We therefore expect that the SCC2 model will enable coupled cluster nonadiabatic dynamics simulations for large molecular systems. † † affiliation: Department of Chemistry, Norwegian University of Science and Technology, Trondheim, Norway † † email: [email protected] † † suppinfo: T 1 Introduction Conical intersections have been shown to play a pivotal role in the excited state dynamics of most molecular systems, both through theoretical studies Zhu and Yarkony 2016 ; Matsika and Krause 2011 and experiments using pump-probe techniques. Stolow 2003 These intersections facilitate internal conversion as an ultra-fast relaxation process, typically occurring tens to hundreds of femtoseconds after excitation of the system. Domcke et al. 2004 When a molecular system approaches a conical intersection, the nuclear and electronic motions become coupled, and the Born-Oppenheimer approximation breaks down. This necessitates the use of nonadiabatic dynamics simulation methods to model the time evolution of the system. Curchod and Martínez 2018 Such methods rely on a balanced treatment of all electronic states involved in the dynamics, and are sensitive to the accuracy of the applied electronic structure model. Mai and González 2020 Coupled cluster (CC) methods are among the most accurate electronic structure methods broadly available in quantum chemistry software. Bartlett and Musiał 2007 Despite their generally steep computational scaling, they have found a wide range of applications where a highly accurate description of the electronic structure is required. In excited states, both static and dynamic correlation can be treated effectively through equation of motion (EOM-CC) Stanton and Bartlett 1993 or linear response Koch and Jørgensen 1990 coupled cluster theory. Within the coupled cluster hierarchy, the second order approximate coupled cluster singles and doubles model (CC2) Christiansen et al. 1995 provides a unique trade-off between comparatively fast computation times and treatment of electron correlation. Loos et al. 2020 For systems dominated by a single excited configuration, the CC2 model typically provides equilibrium- and excited state energies with errors of few tenths of an eV. Loos et al. 2020 ; Schreiber et al. 2008 When using medium-sized basis-sets, CC2 may be applied to systems of hundreds of atoms in single-point calculations. This balance between accuracy and low computational cost makes the CC2 model an especially attractive choice for coupled cluster nonadiabatic dynamics simulations. However, already two decades ago, Hättig Hättig 2005 pointed out that the non-Hermitian effective Hamiltonian of coupled cluster theory may produce unphysical artifacts (such as complex energies) in the description of conical intersections between excited states. For calculations at equilibrium geometries, such artifacts are typically avoided, but they are rapidly encountered when the excited state potential energy surfaces are explored in nonadiabatic dynamics simulations. The appearance of complex excitation energies in close proximity to conical intersections between excited states of the same symmetry has been documented Köhn and Tajti 2007 ; Kjønstad et al. 2017 ; Kjønstad et al. 2024 ; Plasser et al. 2014 ; Fleig et al. 2007 not only for CC2, but also for the coupled cluster singles and doubles (CCSD) Purvis and Bartlett 1982 and the coupled cluster singles, doubles and triples (CCSDT) Noga and Bartlett 1987 ; Noga and Bartlett 1988 models. Because of the abundance of conical intersections and their key role in excited state dynamics, the flawed description provided by standard coupled cluster methods has historically hindered their successful application in nonadiabatic dynamics simulations. Hättig 2005 Specifically, the CC2 model failed in dynamics simulations on adenine due to the appearance of complex excitation energies. Plasser et al. 2014 Over the last decade, the development of similarity constrained coupled cluster (SCC) Kjønstad and Koch 2017 theory has addressed the issues of standard coupled cluster models at conical intersections. These efforts recently led to the successful application of the similarity constrained coupled cluster singles and doubles model (SCCSD) Kjønstad and Koch 2019 in nonadiabatic dynamics simulations on thymine, where standard CCSD encounters unphysical artifacts. Kjønstad et al. 2024 Nonetheless, the steep computational cost of the SCCSD model, which scales as O(N^{6}) with the number of molecular orbitals (MOs) N , limits the size of system that can be studied. Therefore, in this work, we present a similarity constrained coupled cluster method which scales as O(N^{5}) . This SCC2 method maintains the accuracy of CC2 and is expected to enable coupled cluster nonadiabatic dynamics simulations for larger systems. 2 Theory The coupled cluster wave function is defined as |\text{CC}\rangle=\text{exp}({T})|\text{HF}\rangle, (1) where the cluster operator, T=\sum_{\mu>0}t_{\mu}\tau_{\mu}, (2) is a sum of excitation operators \tau_{\mu} weighted by the cluster amplitudes t_{\mu} . The excitation operators act on the reference state, usually the Hartree-Fock state |\text{HF}\rangle , to produce excited configurations |\mu\rangle . We let \mu=0 refer to the reference state, corresponding to \tau_{0}=1 and |0\rangle=|\text{HF}\rangle . Similarly, \mu_{1} and \mu_{2} refer to single and double excitations from the reference state. Here we will restrict ourselves to singlet spin-adapted coupled cluster models, where the \tau_{\mu} are restricted to singlet excitations. Helgaker et al. 2014 With the similarity transformed Hamiltonian defined as \bar{H}=\text{exp}({-T})H\text{exp}({T}), (3) the cluster amplitudes are determined by the amplitude equations \Omega_{\mu}=\langle\mu|\bar{H}|\text{HF}\rangle=0\hskip 20.0pt\mu>0, (4) and the coupled cluster energy is determined as E_{0}=\langle\text{HF}|\bar{H}|\text{HF}\rangle. (5) The excited states can be obtained by equation of motion coupled cluster (EOM-CC) Stanton and Bartlett 1993 theory. Right and left excited states, |R^{k}\rangle and \langle L^{k}| , are expanded as \displaystyle|R^{k}\rangle \displaystyle=\sum_{\mu\geq 0}\text{exp}({T})|\mu\rangle r_{\mu}^{k} (6) \displaystyle\langle L^{k}| \displaystyle=\sum_{\mu\geq 0}\langle\mu|\text{exp}({-T})l_{\mu}^{k} and are required to be biorthonormal, that is, \langle L^{k}|R^{l}\rangle=\delta_{kl} . The left and right EOM-CC expansion coefficients, l_{\mu}^{k} and r_{\mu}^{k} , referred to as the excited state amplitudes, and the excitation energies \omega_{k} , are determined by the non-symmetric eigenvalue problem ( Helgaker et al. 2014 ) \displaystyle\mathbf{A}\mathbf{r}^{k} \displaystyle=\omega_{k}\mathbf{r}^{k} (7) \displaystyle\mathbf{A}^{T}\mathbf{l}^{k} \displaystyle=\omega_{k}\mathbf{l}^{k}, where \mathbf{l}^{k} and \mathbf{r}^{k} exclude the ground state contributions l^{k}_{0} and r^{k}_{0} . The matrix \mathbf{A} is the coupled cluster Jacobian, given by A_{\mu\nu}=\langle\mu|[\bar{H},\tau_{\nu}]|\text{HF}\rangle\hskip 15.0pt\mu,\nu>0. (8) The coupled cluster Jacobian matrix enters the matrix representation of the similarity transformed Hamiltonian \bar{H} in the basis \{|\mu\rangle|\mu\geq 0\} , \mathbf{\bar{H}}=\begin{pmatrix}E_{0}&\mathbf{\eta}^{T}\\ \mathbf{0}&\mathbf{A}+E_{0}\mathbf{I}\end{pmatrix}, (9) where the reference column (the first column) corresponds to the energy E_{0} and amplitude equations \mathbf{\Omega}=\mathbf{0} , which are assumed to be solved. From the eigenvalue equation associated with this matrix, and the requirement of biorthogonality, the ground state contributions to the excited states can be determined as \displaystyle r^{k}_{0} \displaystyle=\frac{\mathbf{\eta}^{T}\mathbf{r}^{k}}{\omega_{k}} (10) \displaystyle l^{k}_{0} \displaystyle=0, where \eta_{\nu}=\langle\text{HF}|[\bar{H},\tau_{\nu}]|\text{HF}\rangle. (11) By truncating the cluster operator in eqn

Read the complete text