Lowering the Cost of Diamond Open Access Journals

2025

Read Lowering the Cost of Diamond Open Access Journals (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-10424.txt.

Introduction

Scholarly journals that charge neither authors nor readers can run on a tiny budget, Joppe Bos and Kevin McCurley argue in a 2025 paper. The catalog record lists no creator, while the head names both authors. Many societies struggle to adapt to this diamond open access model, and cost is often cited as a main barrier to making the switch.

The authors built a publishing workflow that minimizes human labor, plus software to run it, and launched a journal on that system. Their estimated cost is about seven hundred dollars per year, plus about a dollar per article and a few minutes of volunteer labor per article. Two factors helped: authors in their field use LaTeX, and volunteers built and run the system. The software is open source.

Catalog record

YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE21 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-10424

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Lowering the Cost of Diamond Open Access Journals Abstract Many scholarly societies face challenges in adapting their publishing to an open access model where neither authors nor readers pay any fees. Some have argued that one of the main barriers is the actual cost of publishing. The goal of this paper is to show that the actual costs can be extremely low while still maintaining scholarly quality. We accomplish this by designing a journal publishing workflow that minimizes the amount of required human labor. We recently built a software system for this and launched a journal using the system, and we estimate our cost to publish this journal is approximately $705 per year, plus $1 per article and about 10 minutes of volunteer labor per article for the editorial processing. We benefited from two factors, namely the fact that authors in our discipline use L a T e X to prepare their manuscripts, and we had volunteer labor to develop software and run the journal. We have made most of this software open source in the hopes that it can help others. \license CC-by \addauthor [orcid=0000-0003-1010-8157, [email protected],inst=1]Joppe W. Bos \addauthor [orcid=0000-0001-7890-5430, inst=2, [email protected]]Kevin S. McCurley \addaffiliation [country=Belgium,ror=0268h4j55]NXP Semiconductors \addaffiliation [country=USA]Self {textabstract} Many scholarly societies face challenges in adapting their publishing to an open access model where neither authors nor readers pay any fees. Some have argued that one of the main barriers is the actual cost of publishing. The goal of this paper is to show that the actual costs can be extremely low while still maintaining scholarly quality. We accomplish this by building a journal publishing workflow that minimizes the amount of required human labor. We recently built a software system for this and launched a journal using the system, and we estimate estimate our cost to publish this journal is approximately $705 per year, plus $1 per article and about 10 minutes of volunteer labor per article. We benefited from two factors, namely the fact that authors in our discipline use LaTeX to prepare their manuscripts, and we had volunteer labor to develop software and run the journal. We have made most of this software open source in the hopes that it can help others. 1 Introduction This paper reports on the experience of launching a diamond open access journal on behalf of an international scholarly society in mathematics, computer science and engineering. The journal that we refer to is called Communications in Cryptology (CiC), 1 1 1 See https://cic.iacr.org/ and is published by the International Association for Cryptologic Research (IACR). As of this date, the journal has published four issues with 137 articles, and subsequent issues are expected on a quarterly basis. The work behind this paper started almost ten years ago, when a group of IACR members first proposed a new peer-reviewed journal with the goals of rapid publication, open access, and minimal cost. The society was already publishing a traditional journal, two journals which operate as a journal/conference hybrid, and conference proceedings for five annual conferences. The society also runs a preprint server at https://eprint.iacr.org that publishes about 2100 articles per year. The new journal aims to fill a gap in the society’s publishing portfolio by offering a scalable publication venue to cope with the rapid growth in our community. In the last twenty years there has been increasing pressure for scholarly societies to move toward open access models in which articles are free for anyone to read. This has resulted in a shift from the previous subscription-based models to a model in which the cost of publishing is born by other parties. It has also caused increased scrutiny on the actual costs associated with publishing. Some scholarly societies use publishing as a means to raise funds for other activities. For example, the American Mathematical Society states that “The revenue it generates helps support our other professional activities” [ AMS ] . In contrast, the IACR raises very little revenue through publishing, and is funded mostly be membership fees and attendance at conferences. The IACR is a relatively small society, with approximately 3000 members and annual revenue of approximately $2M per year. IACR pays no staff salaries, although they pay small amounts to contractors for web software development and accounting services. Almost all activities are carried out by volunteers, and while this is perhaps unusual, it is not unheard of. For example, a survey [ acls2017 ] in 2017 showed that among member societies of the American Council of Learned Societies in humanities and social sciences, 15% had only a volunteer part-time executive director and 59% had annual revenue of under $1M. One study on 1,619 diamond open access journals [ diamondstudy2 , Findings, p. 8] found that “60% of OA diamond journals depend on volunteers to carry out their work, with 86% reporting either a high or medium reliance on them”. The same survey found that 53% of diamond open access journals are run on less that 1 FTE for their operations. This trend toward scholar-led publishing will be made easier if the need for human labor is kept to an absolute minimum. A recent history of publishing at the Royal Society [ royalsociety ] noted that “…by the turn of the millennium, staff salaries, overheads and relating costs had replaced printing and typesetting as the largest component of journal publishing expenditure at the Royal Society.” In 2004 it was reported that peer review and copy editing amounted to “42% of the publishing staff costs” [ historyfyfe , p. 574] . This highlights the fact that human labor is probably the most important factor in controlling costs of publishing. Over the last 150 years, labor-saving technologies have revolutionized industries through the industrial revolution and the information revolution. We believe that this change is now taking hold in the area of scholarly publishing, and one of our goals in designing the workflow for our new journal was that it should use technology to reduce the amount of human labor required. Not only will this keep costs down, but it can also reduce “burnout” by volunteers [ seismica2023 ] . In this paper we share our experience to create a diamond open access journal which aims to dramatically reduce the amount of human labor by automating the journal publishing workflow as much as possible. This resulted in an total cost of $705 per year plus $1 per published paper for our society. 2 Requirements of the new journal In planning for the launch of any new journal, the first step should be to gather the set of requirements and evaluate options. One crucial requirement for us was to have the journal follow the diamond open access model, in which no fees are paid to publish or read the journal. This necessitates that we keep costs down as much as possible. Aside from the obvious requirements of high scholarly quality, we also wanted to allow ourselves flexibility to innovate in the highest standards of peer review, copy editing, and indexing. Requirements may vary from one discipline to another, but some requirements like metadata collection and facilitating indexing by third parties are fairly universal. In this section we will not cover all requirements that we need to fulfill,

Read the complete text