Modeling the Thermal Structure of a Protoplanetary Disk Using Multiband Flux-Limited Diffusion Approximation

Ya. N. Pavlyuchenkov*, V. V. Akimkin · 2025

Read Modeling the Thermal Structure of a Protoplanetary Disk Using Multiband Flux-Limited Diffusion Approximation by Ya. N. Pavlyuchenkov*, V. V. Akimkin (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-10220.txt.

Introduction

Pavlyuchenkov and Akimkin refine a model of heat in young planet-forming disks, in a 2025 paper. Such disks are flat rings of gas and dust around new stars. Their heat map sets where ice and rock form. The base model spreads radiation by a diffusion trick and treats starlight apart. Averaging light traits over all wavelengths, though, blurs the heat map.

The new model splits star and disk light into bands, each with its own traits. Its heat profile across the disk then bends in slope like top-grade Monte Carlo runs show. It also catches vertical heat shifts near the midplane that the old model missed. Settling times shrink, a fact modelers of young disks must heed.

Catalog record

CREATORYa. N. Pavlyuchenkov*, V. V. Akimkin
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE43 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-10220

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Modeling the Thermal Structure of a Protoplanetary Disk Using Multiband Flux-Limited Diffusion Approximation Ya. N. Pavlyuchenkov*, V. V. Akimkin Abstract This work continues the analysis of the model for calculating the thermal structure of an axisymmetric protoplanetary disk, initiated in the paper by Pavlyuchenkov (2024) . The model is based on the well-known Flux-Limited Diffusion (FLD) approximation with separate calculation of heating by direct stellar radiation (hereinafter referred to as the FLD s method). In addition to the previously described FLD s model with wavelength-averaged opacities, we present a multiband model mFLD s , where the spectrum of thermal radiation is divided into several frequency bands. The model is based on an implicit finite-difference scheme for the equations of thermal radiation diffusion, which reduces to a system of linear algebraic equations written in hypermatrix form. A modified Gauss method for inverting the sparse hypermatrix of the original system of linear equations is proposed. The simulation results described in the article show that the midplane radial temperature profile obtained with the mFLD s method has a variable slope in accordance with the reference Monte Carlo radiative transfer simulations. The mFLD s model also qualitatively reproduces the non-isothermality of the temperature distribution along the angular coordinate near the midplane, which is not provided by the FLD s method. However, quantitative differences remain between the reference temperature values and the results of mFLD s . These differences are likely due to the diffusive nature of the FLD approximation. It is also shown that the characteristic times for the disk to reach thermal equilibrium within the mFLD s model can be significantly shorter than in FLD s . This property should be taken into account when modeling non-stationary processes in protoplanetary disks within FLD-based models. 1 Introduction Star formation is accompanied by the formation of circumstellar protoplanetary disks, the evolution of which ultimately leads to the emergence of planets. The physical processes governing the evolution of protoplanetary disks are extremely diverse, and many of them depend on the thermal structure of the disk. The temperature distribution in the disk also affects its observable properties in the infrared range. The rates of heating and cooling processes determine the development of a number of instabilities in protoplanetary disks: gravitational, convective, thermal, vertical shear instability, baroclinic, pulsational (convective overstability), and others, see, for example, reviews by Armitage (2015) ; Lesur et al. (2023) . Due to the variety of processes and the mathematical complexity of the problem, the calculation of the self-consistent temperature structure of the disk and its thermal evolution is generally carried out using numerical modeling. Significant progress has been made in the development and use of numerical methods for modeling radiation transfer in astrophysical problems in general and in application to circumstellar disks in particular, see e.g. Teyssier & Commerçon (2019) ; Wünsch (2024) . However, many aspects of the methods used and their areas of application have not been fully analyzed. The choice of a method for calculating thermal evolution in dynamic problems, where not only accuracy but also speed is important, remains a relevant task. In the work by Pavlyuchenkov (2024) (hereinafter referred to as Paper I), the FLD s model for calculating the non-stationary thermal structure of a protoplanetary disk in an axisymmetric approximation was illustrated in detail. It is based on the widely used approach of separating the radiation field into stellar and intrinsic thermal radiation of the medium. Heating by stellar radiation was calculated using a ray-tracing method, and the well-known Flux-Limited Diffusion (FLD) approximation was used to describe thermal radiation ( Levermore & Pomraning, 1981 ) . A comparison of the calculation of the stationary thermal structure of a protoplanetary disk within FLD s with more accurate calculations based on the accelerated \Lambda -iteration method ( Pavlyuchenkov et al., 2012 ) showed that the FLD s method excellently reproduces the temperature in the upper and near-surface layers of the disk, but in the disk midplane, it may differ from the exact solution, both in the slope of the radial profile and in its normalization. The temperature distribution from FLD s in the disk’s interior (i.e., in the region optically thick to stellar radiation) turned out to be close to isothermal in the vertical direction, which also does not agree with the results of the exact calculation. In Paper I, it was suggested that these differences are related to the diffusive nature of the FLD approximation, but the aspect related to the use of wavelength-integrated FLD equations was not analyzed. Indeed, in the implemented FLD s method, the values of the radiation energy density E , averaged over the entire spectrum, as well as the spectrum-averaged absorption coefficients (so-called Planck and Rosseland opacities), were used to describe thermal radiation. Meanwhile, in the work by Dullemond (2002) , within the framework of a 1+1D model of a protoplanetary disk, it was shown that the use of spectrum-averaged opacities leads to an isothermal temperature distribution in the vertical direction near the midplane. The need to move to a more accurate approximation led to the development of methods based on FLD or M1 closure theory, in which the spectrum of thermal radiation is divided into several intervals, see, for example, van der Holst et al. (2011) ; Vaytet et al. (2012) . However, the use of such methods for modeling the evolution of protoplanetary disks is still rare and requires more thorough analysis. In this article, we continue the analysis of the FLD method for modeling the thermal structure of a protoplanetary disk by implementing its multiband version, which we will henceforth refer to as mFLD s . 2 Method Description 2.1 Non-stationary Equations of Thermal Evolution and Radiation Diffusion Before proceeding to the description of the mFLD s method, let us recall the main equations of the basic FLD s method from Paper I: \displaystyle\rho c_{\rm V}\frac{\partial T}{\partial t} \displaystyle= \displaystyle c\alpha\left(E-aT^{4}\right)+S (1) \displaystyle\frac{\partial E}{\partial t} \displaystyle= \displaystyle-c\alpha\left(E-aT^{4}\right)+\hat{\Lambda}E, (2) where \rho is the density of the gas-dust medium, c_{\rm V} is the specific heat capacity of the medium [erg K -1 g -1 ], c is the speed of light, \alpha [cm -1 ] is the spectrum-averaged absorption coefficient of thermal radiation (excluding scattering, per unit volume of the gas-dust medium), a is the radiation density constant, S [erg cm -3 s -1 ] is the heating rate by stellar radiation, T is the temperature of the medium, and E is the energy density of thermal radiation. Equation ( 1 ) describes the change in the thermal energy density of the medium as a result of the absorption and re-emission of thermal radiation (terms c\alpha E and c\alpha aT^{4} , respectively), as well as due to the absorption of direct stellar radiation, determined by the function S . Equation ( 2 ) is a moment equation of radiation transfer and describes the change in the energy density of radiation as a result of the absorption and re-emission of thermal radiation, as well as due to the spatial diffusion of thermal radiation, represented by the operator \hat{\Lambda}E . It is assumed that the main heat capacity of the medium is due to the gas, and the opacity is due to dust. It

Read the complete text