Unleashing Expert Opinion from Social Media for Stock Prediction

Wanyun Zhou 1, Saizhuo Wang 2,3, Xiang Li 1, Yiyan Qi 3, Jian Guo 3, Xiaowen Chu 1 · 2025

Read Unleashing Expert Opinion from Social Media for Stock Prediction by Wanyun Zhou 1, Saizhuo Wang 2,3, Xiang Li 1, Yiyan Qi 3, Jian Guo 3, Xiaowen Chu 1 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-10078.txt.

Introduction

Wanyun Zhou and co-authors mine social media for stock signals in a 2025 paper. Price and company data are the usual inputs for predicting stock moves. Posts on platforms like StockTwits add a live stream of opinion, but most posts are noise and public mood alone predicts little. The team's claim is that a few posters do know something, and they can be found.

Their algorithm traces posters over time and keeps those whose calls are consistently right, plus a surprising group whose calls are consistently wrong in a usable way, the inverse experts. Filtering out the rest sharpened trend prediction over older expert-finding methods. The authors also note a limit shared by the whole approach: turning expert calls into a precise return forecast stays hard. The work shows signal hides in social noise.

Catalog record

CREATORWanyun Zhou 1, Saizhuo Wang 2,3, Xiang Li 1, Yiyan Qi 3, Jian Guo 3, Xiaowen Chu 1
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE71 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-10078

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Unleashing Expert Opinion from Social Media for Stock Prediction Wanyun Zhou 1, Saizhuo Wang 2,3, Xiang Li 1, Yiyan Qi 3, Jian Guo 3, Xiaowen Chu 1 Abstract While stock prediction task traditionally relies on volume-price and fundamental data to predict the return ratio or price movement trend, sentiment factors derived from social media platforms such as StockTwits offer a complementary and useful source of real-time market information. However, we find that most social media posts, along with the public sentiment they reflect, provide limited value for trading predictions due to their noisy nature. To tackle this, we propose a novel dynamic expert tracing algorithm that filters out non-informative posts and identifies both true and inverse experts whose consistent predictions can serve as valuable trading signals. Our approach achieves significant improvements over existing expert identification methods in stock trend prediction. However, when using binary expert predictions to predict the return ratio, similar to all other expert identification methods, our approach faces a common challenge of signal sparsity with expert signals cover only about 4% of all stock-day combinations in our dataset. To address this challenge, we propose a dual graph attention neural network that effectively propagates expert signals across related stocks, enabling accurate prediction of return ratios and significantly increasing signal coverage. Empirical results show that our propagated expert-based signals not only exhibit strong predictive power independently but also work synergistically with traditional financial features. These combined signals significantly outperform representative baseline models in all quant-related metrics including predictive accuracy, return metrics, and correlation metrics, resulting in more robust investment strategies. We hope this work inspires further research into leveraging social media data for enhancing quantitative investment strategies. The code can be seen in https://github.com/wanyunzh/DualGAT. I Introduction Quantitative investment research has traditionally relied on handcrafted features from volume-price data and fundamental indicators for stock prediction. Deep learning has significantly advanced this field by moving beyond manual feature engineering to learn complex patterns directly from raw data. Early sequence models such as LSTMs [ 1 , 2 ] and GRUs [ 3 , 4 ] were designed to capture temporal dependencies by using the financial time series, while subsequent developments introduced Transformer-based architectures [ 5 , 6 ] for enhanced sequence modeling and incorporated graph structures using GNNs to exploit inter-stock relations [ 7 , 8 , 9 ] . In recent years, there has been a growing focus on utilizing sentiment features derived from social media as a complementary information source for stock prediction [ 10 , 11 , 12 , 13 ] . Social media platforms for investment discussions have become increasingly influential in financial markets [ 14 , 15 ] . These platforms reflect real-time investor sentiment and demonstrate significant market-moving potential, exemplified by the GameStop short squeeze [ 16 ] that originated on social media and caused unprecedented volatility. Recognizing this potential, professional trading firms (e.g., WorldQuant) actively incorporate social media data into trading strategies for predictive signals [ 17 ] . Among all investment-related social media platforms, StockTwits [ 18 ] stands out as a specialized platform for investors to share stock insights. Each stock has its dedicated discussion thread where users post related messages. Additionally, StockTwits offers a unique advantage: users can explicitly label their posts as “Bullish” or “Bearish,” providing clear sentiment indicators for specific stocks. This self-labeling mechanism eliminates algorithmic sentiment analysis uncertainty and offers more reliable sentiment signals. Although StockTwits provides valuable self-labeled sentiment data and contains a vast amount of discussions, extracting useful trading signals for either stock movement trend or return ratio prediction from the raw social media data remains challenging due to its substantial noise. To demonstrate that most social media posts are noisy and non-informative for trading predictions, we collected all StockTwits posts from 2016 to 2023 and examined the relationship between public sentiment and subsequent stock price movements. We applied a native filter and aggregation method that identifies the dominant sentiment for each stock based on a threshold of posts and the intensity of the sentiment. Specifically, if the number of posts for a given stock exceeded 30 on a given day, and one sentiment (either bullish or bearish) dominated by more than 85%, we used that sentiment to predict the stock’s trend for the following day. As shown by the solid blue line with square markers in Figure 1 , the accuracy of dominant sentiment for predicting the stock’s movement trend (bullish for rise and bearish for fall) on the next day (T+1) was 47.63%, 3 days later (T+3) was 46.99%, and 7 days later (T+7) was 47.01%. These results suggest that using aggregated sentiment for stock prediction yields accuracy that is not even better than random guessing, demonstrating the limited predictive value of social media sentiment. Such underperformance indicates that the majority of social media posts contain significant noise rather than actionable trading information. In fact, social media data is inherently noisy when used as trading signals [ 19 , 20 , 21 , 22 , 23 ] . This stems from the open nature of these platforms, where anyone can post opinions that often lack predictive power. Retail investors’ discussions, for example, have limited impact on stock movements, and many of their posts are speculative, driven by personal biases, or based on rumors [ 24 ] . These non-professional posts often lack investment insights, making them unreliable as trading signals [ 25 ] . Additionally, there is potential for insider traders to manipulate social media to influence investor sentiment and, in turn, affect market trends [ 26 ] . Moreover, the prevalence of emotional and impulsive posts during market volatility further contributes to this noise, as users tend to react to price movements rather than provide predictive insights [ 27 ] . As a result, truly informative posts from expert users are rare, making it crucial to accurately identify these experts amidst the noise [ 21 ] . Despite efforts in existing research to identify expert signals [ 19 , 28 , 21 , 20 , 29 ] , current methods struggle to reliably distinguish true experts from users who simply appear to be experts due to random correlations with market movements. These methods often overlook the fact that true experts should be able to make precise predictions across different market regimes. Their expert identification approaches tend to favor users who post frequently and whose posts happen to be correct during specific market trends, leading to biased results. Furthermore, these methods do not address the widespread presence of bots and spam accounts in social media posts, further undermining their effectiveness in identifying genuine expert signals. To address these limitations in expert identification, we propose a novel dynamic expert tracing algorithm tailored to stock data. Our algorithm incorporates multiple key principles to ensure robust expert identification. First, it filters out noise from bots and spammers to address the data quality issue. Second, it evaluates both long-term and dynamic prediction accuracy across various market regimes to identify experts. Third, it ensures that experts focus only on a manageable number of stocks by filtering out users with numerous posts on different stocks in a single day. Furthermore, we identify both true experts and ‘ inverse experts ’—users

Read the complete text