A mechanical approach to facilitate the formation of dodecagonal quasicrystals and their approximants

Zhehua Jiang, Jianhua Zhang, Mengyuan Zhan, Jiaqi Si, Junchao Huang, Hua Tong, Ning Xu · 2025

Read A mechanical approach to facilitate the formation of dodecagonal quasicrystals and their approximants by Zhehua Jiang, Jianhua Zhang, Mengyuan Zhan, Jiaqi Si, Junchao Huang, Hua Tong, Ning Xu (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-09894.txt.

Introduction

Seven authors form twelve sided quasicrystals by a mechanical trick in this 2025 paper. Quasicrystals have orderly patterns that never quite repeat, and making them usually needs several length scales in the material, a strict demand.

Starting from a square packing of identical hard disks, a single length scale system, the team shook the packing in a set way. Motifs and near versions of dodecagonal quasicrystals formed on their own, which challenges current theory. Applied to a system known to form such a quasicrystal, the same shaking built better order than letting a liquid settle, even at low temperatures where self assembly stalls. The method may speed the search for new quasicrystals.

Catalog record

CREATORZhehua Jiang, Jianhua Zhang, Mengyuan Zhan, Jiaqi Si, Junchao Huang, Hua Tong, Ning Xu
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE33 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-09894

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A mechanical approach to facilitate the formation of dodecagonal quasicrystals and their approximants Zhehua Jiang, Jianhua Zhang, Mengyuan Zhan, Jiaqi Si, Junchao Huang, Hua Tong, Ning Xu Abstract The conditions for forming quasicrystals and their approximants are stringent, normally requiring multiple length scales to stabilize the quasicrystalline order. Here we report an unexpected finding that the approximants and motifs of dodecagonal quasicrystals can be spontaneously formed in the simplest system of identical hard disks, utilizing the unstable feature of the initial square packing subject to mechanical perturbations. Because there is only one length scale involved, this finding challenges existing theories of quasicrystals and their approximants. By applying the same approach to a system known to form a dodecagonal quasicrystal, we develop decent quasicrystalline order in a purely mechanical manner. With the aid of thermal treatment, we achieve a significantly better quasicrystalline order than that from the direct self-assembly of the liquid state within the same period of time. In sufficiently low temperatures where the self-assembly of a liquid is significantly hindered, our approach still promotes the formation of quasicrystals. Our study thus opens a venue for high-efficiency search and formation of quasicrystals, and may have broader implications for the design and synthesis of quasicrystalline materials. Quasicrystals, first discovered by Shechtman et al. Shechtman_Blech_Gratias_Cahn_1984 , exhibit sharp Bragg peaks with symmetries forbidden in ordinary crystals and lack long-range translational order Levine_Steinhardt_1984 . For the first two decades, quasicrystalline orders were mainly observed in metallic alloys, until the discovery of quasicrystals in soft matter in 2004 Zeng_Ungar_Liu_Percec_Dulcey_Hobbs_2004 . The building blocks of soft matter may span multiple scales, making it a playground for diverse physical phenomena Saarloos_Vitelli_Zeravcic_2024 and providing vast possibilities to tune interparticle interactions and the shape of structural units for the formation of quasicrystals Ungar_Zeng_2005 ; Dotera_2011 ; Su_Zhang_Yan_Guo_Huang_Shan_Liu_Liu_Huang_Cheng_2020 ; Nagaoka_Schneider_Zhu_Chen_2023 . Consequently, soft quasicrystals Lifshitz_Diamant_2007 have been observed in a wide range of soft matter systems, including dendrimer liquid crystals Zeng_Ungar_Liu_Percec_Dulcey_Hobbs_2004 , star-shaped polymers Hayashida_Dotera_Takano_Matsushita_2007 , binary nanoparticle systems Talapin_Shevchenko_Bodnarchuk_Ye_Chen_Murray_2009 , block copolymer micelles Fischer_Exner_Zielske_Perlich_Deloudi_Steurer_Lindner_Förster_2011 , mesoporous silica Xiao_Fujita_Miyasaka_Sakamoto_Terasaki_2012 , DNA-engineered biomolecules Zhou_Lim_Lin_Lee_Li_Huang_Du_Lee_Wang_Sánchez-Iglesias_et_al._2024 and microspheres in applied magnetic and electric fields Gao_Sprinkle_Marr_Wu_2025 . Compared to quasicrystals, their approximants, which share the same prototiles but exhibit long-range translational order, are easier to form. This makes quasicrystal approximants an ideal starting point for elucidating both the formation mechanism and structural attributes of quasicrystals Chen_Li_Kuo_1988 ; Keys_Glotzer_2007 ; Hayashida_Dotera_Takano_Matsushita_2007 ; Lee_Bluemle_Bates_2010 ; Schenk_Krahn_Cockayne_Meyerheim_de_Boissieu_Förster_Widdra_2022 ; Mueller_Lindsay_Lewis_Zhang_Narayanan_Lodge_Mahanthappa_Bates_2024 . Owing to their unique structural and physical properties, such as exceptional hardness, low friction, and thermal stability, quasicrystals and their approximants hold promising applications in thermal insulation, surface coatings, and advanced materials engineering Yadav_Mukhopadhyay_2018 . Although the structures of quasicrystals and their approximants have been extensively studied Walter_Deloudi_2009 , their formation mechanisms are not yet fully understood Steurer_2018 ; Je_Lee_Teich_Engel_Glotzer_2021 ; Yin_Jiang_Shi_Zhang_Zhang_2021 . Typically, multiple characteristic length scales are involved in the structures of quasicrystals and their approximants. This leads to the prevailing hypothesis that their formation necessitates the introduction of multiple length scales. Consequently, studies often employ complex interparticle interactions with multiple length scales Lifshitz_Diamant_2007 ; Dotera_2011 ; Engel_Trebin_2007 ; Dotera_Oshiro_Ziherl_2014 ; Barkan_Engel_Lifshitz_2014 ; Engel_Damasceno_Phillips_Glotzer_2015 ; Schoberth_Emmerich_Holzinger_Dulle_Förster_Gruhn_2016 , polydisperse isotropic particles Fayen_Impéror-Clerc_Filion_Foffi_Smallenburg_2023 ; Bedolla-Montiel_Lange_Ortiz_Dijkstra_2024 , or anisotropic particles with patches Reinhardt_Romano_Doye_2013 ; Noya_Wong_Llombart_Doye_2021 or polyhedral shapes Haji-Akbari_Engel_Keys_Zheng_Petschek_Palffy-Muhoray_Glotzer_2009 ; Je_Lee_Teich_Engel_Glotzer_2021 . A notable exception to this general view was reported recently: both dodecagonal and octagonal quasicrystals can be formed by monodisperse isotropic disks interacting via simple spring-like repulsions Zu_Tan_Xu_2017 ; Fomin_Gaiduk_Tsiok_Ryzhov_2018 . In this case, quasicrystals are formed without explicitly engineering multiple length scales, but instead relies on the high density of the system: the soft-core nature of the interactions promotes the self-assembly of disks into pentagons, which then serve as the fundamental building blocks for quasicrystal formation. Note that disks interacting via spring-like repulsions effectively behave as hard ones at sufficiently low pressures Xu_Haxton_Liu_Nagel_2009 ; Xu_2019 . Here we address a more challenging question: Can the simplest system of monodisperse hard disks spontaneously form quasicrystals or their approximants? Given the presence of only one length scale - the hard disk diameter - this question may sound counterintuitive based on previous understanding. It is an indisputable fact that the thermodynamic equilibrium state of monodisperse hard disks is the hexagonal phase Royall_Charbonneau_Dijkstra_Russo_Smallenburg_Speck_Valeriani_2024 . Although other metastable states, such as polycrystalline packings of hard disks, can be obtained via rapid compression from liquid states, to our knowledge, no spontaneous formation of complex crystalline or quasicrystalline structures has ever been reported, even under nonequilibrium conditions. Figure 1: Formation of a DDQC approximant using hard disks and the transformation pathway. a DDQC approximant obtained from the perturbation of a square packing. Circles and lines represent disks and bonds, respectively. Red bonds highlight the (3^{2}.4.3.4) Archimedean tiling. b Diffraction pattern of the approximant shown in a . While 12-fold-like symmetry is visually apparent, close inspection reveals only four diffraction spots lying on each ring (red dashed circles), indicating a 4-fold symmetry. c Local transformation pathway from a square packing to the approximant. Gray bonds represent the initial square packing. Orange and red bonds represent the approximant. Arrows indicate the displacements of disks over the transformation. Directed circles illustrate the rotational direction of the squares. Red bonds highlight the (3^{2}.4.3.4) Archimedean tiling. However, a straightforward analysis suggests that the idea might not be totally infeasible. Stampfli-Gähler tiling of a dodecagonal quasicrystal requires only two building blocks: squares and equilateral triangles Stampfli1986ADQ ; gahler1988quasicrystalline . A hexagonal packing of hard disks is composed of equilateral triangles. Hard disks can also be arranged into a square lattice, which is however unstable due to the presence of soft modes, i.e., normal modes with zero frequency or energy. Therefore, these two building blocks can be constructed using hard disks, albeit at different packing densities. The critical challenge is to determine how to make these two building blocks spontaneously coexist and assemble into more complex motifs of quasicrystals or their approximants. Utilizing the unstable feature of the square lattice, we unexpectedly observe the spontaneous formation of the approximant of the dodecagonal quasicrystal (DDQC) via a slight perturbation of the square packing of hard disks at constant pressure. By selectively removing pairs of disks from the square lattice, the same protocol results in the spontaneous formation of DDQC motifs. Although global formation of DDQCs has not yet been achieved with hard disks, this protocol significantly accelerates the formation of DDQCs in known DDQC-forming systems. Our study reveals the previously unrecognized capability of hard disks to assemble into complex crystals and identifies a novel pathway of the formation of DDQCs and their approximants, providing a highly efficient and mechanical method to facilitate the formation and search for DDQCs. Figure 2: Formation of DDQC motifs using hard disks. a Introduction of a vacancy pair along the 45^{\circ} direction (dashed line) to a square packing of N=81 disks (top panel) and the resulting DDQC motif (bottom panel). Disks transformed to the center, first shell, and second shell of the motif are shown in red, purple, and green, respectively. Lines in the bottom panel represent bonds, with red bonds highlighting two head-to-head (3^{2}.4.3.4) Archimedean tilings. b Generation of another DDQC motif with a 30^{\circ} rotation relative to that in a , achieved

Read the complete text